On viewArts & Culture

AI Recommendations Are Squeezing Out Europe's Cultural Fringe

Deezer reports 90,000 AI tracks uploaded daily, over half of all uploads. European artists say opaque recommendation algorithms push minority-language voices off the feed.

How AI Algorithms Are Narrowing Cultural Choices
How AI Algorithms Are Narrowing Cultural ChoicesPexels / pixabay

Programme

  1. Deezer reported around 90,000 AI tracks uploaded daily in July, over half of uploads but 1–3 per cent of listening.
  2. A Danish library study found authors from less popular nationalities got up to 40 per cent less recommendation exposure.
  3. Amazon's monthly new e-book output rose from about 100,000 to roughly 300,000 by the end of 2025.
  4. Germany assigned about 151,000 more ISBNs in 2025 than 2022, a 16.2 per cent rise.
  5. The EU's AI strategy for cultural and creative sectors is expected in early 2027; AgoraEU faces a proposed cut from €8.6bn to €6bn.

Deezer reported in July that roughly 90,000 AI-generated tracks are uploaded to its platform every day. That figure, cited by Marc du Moulin, secretary general of the European Composer and Songwriter Alliance (ECSA), accounts for more than half of daily uploads — but only 1–3 per cent of listening. The rest is clutter competing for a royalty pool in which musicians receive less than 10 per cent of total streaming revenues.

The numbers frame a wider problem. A recent European Commission study linked the visibility of European cultural works to opaque recommendation algorithms, language barriers and platforms' habit of amplifying mainstream content. A separate study of book recommendations in Danish public libraries found that authors from less popular nationalities received up to 40 per cent less exposure. A study of ChatGPT's book and music recommendations reached the same verdict: popular titles in, lesser-known works out.

Who loses visibility first?

"Currently, it is hard to quantify the direct impact that AI is having on discoverability, mostly due to the lack of transparency of streaming services," du Moulin told EU Perspectives.

Rhys Nugent, advocacy officer at Culture Action Europe, said minority-language artists and experimental creators are disproportionately hit, because the systems "reinforce what is already dominant while undermining cultural diversity". That pressure predates chatbots. Streaming, social media and online bookshops have long shaped what audiences encounter.

There is one bright spot. Lorenzo Dall'Omo, policy and advocacy officer at the European and International Booksellers Federation (EIBF), points to BookTok, the book community on TikTok. "Book influencers and viral trends have brought many books to the forefront, introducing new readers to authors and titles they might otherwise never have encountered," he said.

What about human curation?

The same mechanisms can deepen inequality. Algorithms prioritise personalisation, engagement and quick attention-grabbing, Dall'Omo explained, so bestsellers gain exposure while debut writers, independent publishers and smaller linguistic communities struggle. He flags particular risks for BIPOC and LGBTQ+ authors and readers. "The risk is not necessarily that these books disappear, but that they become less visible in an increasingly algorithm-driven environment," he said.

Music tells a similar story. Du Moulin relayed complaints from ECSA members in Finland after a major streaming platform moved local playlist editing abroad, reducing Finnish artists in favour of mainstream international songs. "AI definitely presents further risk to diversity and visibility of local repertoire, but these reports indicate that the issue of diversity in recommendations has been present even in the case of curated playlists," he said.

When the competition isn't human

In June 2025, the band The Velvet Sundown appeared on Spotify and drew more than a million monthly listeners within weeks. The band, its promotional images and its backstory were all AI-generated. It was not an isolated case.

Publishing faces its own flood. Amazon's monthly new e-book output rose from about 100,000 before ChatGPT to roughly 300,000 by the end of 2025. In the Netherlands, distributor CB reported more purchases and print-on-demand titles, yet stock held steady since 2021. Germany assigned about 151,000 more ISBNs (International Standard Book Numbers) in 2025 than in 2022, a 16.2 per cent rise. Dall'Omo cautions that AI's share of that growth remains unmeasurable. "The challenge is then no longer simply getting a book published, but ensuring that readers can find it and that professionally produced, meaningful content does not get lost in an increasingly crowded marketplace," he said.

Money questions sharpen the fight. The Suno–Warner Music deal, which settled a copyright lawsuit and lets Warner artists opt in to AI use of their voices, likenesses and compositions, may set terms smaller players cannot match. "Deals between large rightsholders and AI companies risk boosting the existing catalogue of the major rightsholders, threatening to increase market concentration and penalising smaller and independent authors and other right holders who may not be able to license their music on similar terms," du Moulin said. "Songwriters and composers are not against AI. However, AI services must pay their fair share and respect the principles of authorisation, remuneration, and transparency."

What is Brussels doing?

The European Parliament adopted a non-binding resolution in March calling for transparency, fair remuneration and new AI licensing rules. The Digital Services Act already obliges platforms to explain their recommendation parameters; very large platforms — over 45 million EU monthly users, including Instagram, TikTok and YouTube — must offer a non-profiling option. ECSA wants the burden of proof reversed, so AI companies must show they did not use copyrighted works without permission, plus disclosure, licensing and action on streaming fraud and metadata.

Culture Action Europe's Ask, Pay, Trust campaign demands artist involvement in policymaking and fair pay. Nugent warns of a proposed 30 per cent cut to the AgoraEU culture and media programme, from €8.6bn to €6bn, in the EU's next long-term budget. He sees a chance in the European Commission's AI strategy for cultural and creative sectors, expected in early 2027: "We believe the upcoming AI strategy for the cultural and creative sectors is the perfect opportunity to place these values into action when it comes to the discoverability of cultural content both online and offline."

Deezer, for its part, has excluded AI music from recommendations and plans a listener filter for search results before the end of 2026. Dall'Omo keeps the frame sane: "Ultimately, the objective should not be to use AI to make everyone discover the same books more efficiently, but to use technology in ways that allow readers to discover a wider diversity of books, authors and ideas."

Source: artsjournal.com

ai-recommendations, cultural-diversity, music-streaming, digital-publishing, eu-cultural-policy

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »