Programme
- *Beginningless* is the debut album of the trio Anna Butterss, John Raymond and Ben Lumsdaine, and runs 37 minutes.
- The album grew out of a joint set the three played at Indiana University in 2024.
- Butterss and Raymond are associated with Chicago's International Anthem label; Raymond's solo album *Murmuration Without End* appeared in 2023.
- The album was improvised live in the studio on a mostly acoustic setup with sparing electronics.
- Standout tracks include "Parallax" and the title track.
By Elena Vasquez
Bassist Anna Butterss, trumpeter John Raymond and drummer Ben Lumsdaine have released their first album together, Beginningless, a 37-minute improvised studio session recorded in the wake of an explosive 2024 joint set at Indiana University. The trio built the record around repeated motifs, turning textural nuance into phrases that stick.
The album opens with static crackling in warm fuzz — the sound of a microphone dragged slowly across a fabric surface. That amorphous residue becomes the foundation: each player locks into it, reacting to the others in real time. The three recorded the full-length live in the studio, with no overdraft of prewritten material, homing in on how each musician responds to the smallest gesture from the others.
Where does the trio come from?
Butterss and Raymond are best known for their work with the Chicago-based label International Anthem. Butterss plays in SML and in Jeff Parker's ETA IVtet; Raymond released a solo album, Murmuration Without End, in 2023. All three members share connections to the scene around Indiana University, where the 2024 joint set proved convincing enough to push them into a studio to flesh out a full-length release.
What does the album sound like?
Across 37 minutes, the trio creeps around ghostly modes on a mostly acoustic setup. The soundscape is moody and umbral, awash in middling tempos and cool tones. Electronics appear sparingly, detectable mainly through subtle knob movements: delays break hi-hats into little tinny particles, and filter sweeps simulate gusts of wind carrying away the few melodies being played. The record dazzles most in its groove-forward approach to fleeting ambience, according to the review's account of the session.
With meditative focus, the trio strikes a hallucinatory balance of potential and kinetic energy. In plain words: the music moves slowly, but everything in it feels primed to move.
Which tracks stand out?
"Parallax" is the prime example of the group's method. The rhythm section focuses on the immersive depth of gorp jazz while the horn melodies hang with chilly restraint. Butterss' distorted bass is "thicker than a bowl of oatmeal," and its dubbiness creates a hefty ripple effect that pushes against the other instruments. The bass occupies a double role — holding down the beat while also taking the lead, however fragmentary the melody. Lumsdaine's drumming mostly chugs along, occasionally skittering into smaller ideas for variation. Raymond's sweet, spaced-out playing ties it together, shrouding everything in a psychedelic, out-of-body dissociative state.
The title track works similarly. Butterss and Lumsdaine double up on rhythm, as if to emphasize the impossibility of pinning down the silky-smooth brass. The slow melodic development rewards patience — the listener anticipates which sweet or sour notes Raymond will push through his sustain pedal to harmonize over.
What comes next?
Beginningless has no rating yet, and the trio has not announced follow-up plans. What the record establishes is a working method — improvised, detail-driven, motif-obsessed — that this Indiana University-connected lineup can carry into future sessions.
Source: pitchfork.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,533 articles



