On viewMusic

Berlin Philharmonic Violinist Details Fazıl Say Confrontation in Istanbul

Hande Küden told Günaydın that Fazıl Say humiliated her in front of 80 musicians, revealed she was not the orchestra's first-choice concertmaster, and performed only out of professionalism.

Uproar in Istanbul as concertmaster confronts orchestra founder
Uproar in Istanbul as concertmaster confronts orchestra founderartesitalia / pixabay

Programme

  1. Berlin Philharmonic violinist Hande Küden gave her account to the Turkish newspaper Günaydın after Fazıl Say denied mistreating her.
  2. Küden says Say humiliated her in front of 80 people during a rehearsal on the day of the concert.
  3. Anonymous Özyeğin Philharmonic Orchestra musicians confirmed Say used a humiliating and accusatory tone toward Küden onstage.
  4. Küden says an organizer told her she was not the orchestra's first-choice concertmaster and that they 'had no choice'.
  5. After Küden announced she would never work with Say again, organizer Ms. Emel asked her to remove her social media posts.

Berlin Philharmonic violinist Hande Küden has publicly detailed what she says happened between her and pianist-composer Fazıl Say during her guest stint as concertmaster of the newly founded Özyeğin Philharmonic Orchestra in Istanbul. Küden gave her account to the Turkish newspaper Günaydın, responding directly to Say's earlier denials about his treatment of her.

Küden's statement, published in full, describes two escalating incidents and names the organizers involved.

What does Küden say happened at the first rehearsal?

Küden's account begins with a professional request. After the first rehearsal, she asked Say whether the second rehearsal could include 15 minutes of separate string and wind section work, so players could hear one another properly in terms of intonation. She says Say "rudely rejected" the request.

The next morning, before rehearsal, an organizer identified as Ms. Emel told Küden: "From now on, nobody will speak directly to Fazıl. Everything will go through me."

Küden says Say then requested a meeting, with Ms. Emel present, and told her: "You don't know this project very well. You're not going to be coming here all the time anyway. We agreed on two concerts. You actually weren't even the first concertmaster we preferred to invite here; we had no choice. Look, sitting behind you are concertmasters, soloists, and even professors who could do this job."

When Küden protested — "What does that mean? Is this how you thank me?" — she says Ms. Emel squeezed her arm as if to silence her and said: "After all, he is the world-famous Fazıl Say."

Say, according to Küden, responded: "If we didn't value you, we wouldn't have invited you here in the first place." Küden says she answered: "Please, let us remain within the boundaries of mutual respect." Then the rehearsal began.

Küden says she considered leaving at that moment. A main reason she had accepted the engagement, she says, was a desire to contribute to the new orchestra. She decided to stay and overlook the incident.

What happened on the day of the concert?

The second incident, in Küden's telling, occurred in front of 80 people during the final rehearsal. She says Say suddenly stopped the rehearsal and addressed her "in a humiliating manner and with an ugly tone": "Hande! How can you play that passage like that? Can't you see it's a triplet? Look at that note, look at the note! You're playing it like sixteenth notes! We've rehearsed it five times, why isn't it working? Why are you playing like that?!"

Küden says she stayed silent until Say demanded, "She's not even answering. Answer me!" She replied: "Could you speak to me properly?" She says nothing changed in his tone.

When she asked, "Why are you singling me out like this?", Küden says Say answered: "Because I can hear you, that's why I'm telling you." She told him she was not playing alone and that he needed to address the entire section.

At that point Küden turned to the orchestra's conductor and said: "He is insulting me right now." The conductor, according to Küden, replied, "I am so sorry to hear that," and tried to calm the situation before continuing.

Why did Küden perform anyway?

What does this change for a guest concertmaster facing a founder's conduct on concert day? In Küden's case, she performed. After the rehearsal she asked Ms. Emel: "Can you give me one reason why I should perform this concert?" Emel's reply, as Küden recounts it: "So that you won't be remembered as Hande Küden who abandoned the concert."

An unnamed orchestra musician came to Küden's room and asked: "Why did this happen? Why did Fazıl do this?" Küden told the musician she would not perform. The musician answered: "If I were you, I wouldn't stay for the concert either." The conductor then visited Küden, said she did not understand Turkish but could tell Say had spoken in a humiliating manner, and said she fully supported Küden for defending herself.

"Nobody apologized to me," Küden told Günaydın.

She says she went onstage out of professionalism and her sense of responsibility toward the newly established orchestra, telling herself she would never take part in any project with Fazıl Say again.

What did Say do after the concert?

Küden says Say then acted "as though nothing had happened between us." He suddenly decided she should go onstage alone, although the plan had been for everyone to enter together — a change the concert presenter had not been informed of, so the players ended up entering at the same time anyway. Say then introduced Küden and the principal violist to the audience "as if the orchestra consisted of only two people," Küden says, though no introduction had been listed in the schedule sent to the musicians.

Küden says Say subsequently shared a video on social media of the moment he introduced her, presenting it, in her words, as proof that "Look, nothing happened."

The following day, after Küden publicly announced on social media that she would never work with Say again, she received a message from Ms. Emel: "Please, let's calm down. I'm having a very difficult time right now. I'm asking you to remove these posts."

Do others corroborate the account?

Members of the Özyeğin Philharmonic Orchestra, speaking on condition of anonymity, have confirmed that Fazıl Say used a humiliating and accusatory tone toward Küden onstage. Their corroboration, alongside Küden's detailed public statement, keeps pressure on Say after his denials — at a moment when such conduct is no longer normalized in the classical music world and, as the source notes, is taken seriously with necessary action taken.

Source: Slipped Disc

fazl-say, hande-kuden, berlin-philharmonic, ozyegin-philharmonic-orchestra, classical-music

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »