On viewLiterature

Biden Memoir Called "Startlingly Dull" in Five Review Roundup

Five critics take on Biden's $10M memoir, Hall's Medea, Woodward's memoir, Douglas's autobiography and Giridharadas's Jordan Neely book. Verdicts range from "startlingly dull" to "too panoramic."

5 Book Reviews You Need to Read This Week
5 Book Reviews You Need to Read This WeekEliFrancis / pixabay

Programme

  1. Amy Davidson Sorkin calls Biden's Promise Me, America, reportedly advanced at $10 million, "startlingly dull" in The New Yorker.
  2. Anahid Nersessian reviews Edith Hall's Medea: A Life; filicide accounts for about 2.5% of annual US murder arrests.
  3. George Packer reviews Bob Woodward's Secrets: A Reporter's Memoir in The Atlantic; Woodward is 83 with a half-century of best sellers.
  4. Dan Piepenbring reviews Michael Douglas's One Helluva Ride in Harper's; father Kirk Douglas lived to 103.
  5. Nick Tabor reviews Giridharadas's Man in the Mirror in The New Republic, citing models Random Family (2003) and Behind the Beautiful Forevers (2012).

Joe Biden's memoir Promise Me, America is "startlingly dull," Amy Davidson Sorkin writes in The New Yorker — this from a book that carried a reported advance of about ten million dollars. Sorkin's verdict anchors a week of five major book reviews compiled by Book Marks, Lit Hub's review aggregator, covering subjects from Greek tragedy to the New York subway.

The reviews span four outlets and five authors. Here is what each critic found.

What does Sorkin say about Biden's memoir?

Sorkin's central charge is denial. "The news of the memoir, in short, is that there is no real news: Biden is as stubbornly in denial as ever," she writes. The book treats questions about Biden's competency during his presidency "as extraneous and gratuitous," including his June 2024 debate performance against Donald Trump, which Biden dismisses by noting that "debates had gone badly for lots of incumbent Presidents."

Sorkin notes the memoir largely omits Biden's earlier self-description as "a bridge" — a phrase widely understood to mean one term. Much of the book, she writes, "has the feel of something written by a committee." Her closing judgment: "The one thing Biden doesn't know how to mourn, it seems, is his Presidency." In plain words, Sorkin wanted a book about grief and lost powers, and got a defense brief.

How does Edith Hall's Medesa biography fare?

Anahid Nersessian, also in The New Yorker, reviews Edith Hall's Medea: A Life. Hall, a professor of classics and ancient history at the University of Durham, frames the book as biography, but Nersessian calls it closer to a "critical fabulation" in Saidiya Hartman's sense — a partly invented narrative for a figure lost to the historical record.

Nersessian opens with a stark statistic: filicide accounts for around two and a half percent of annual murder arrests in the United States. She argues Hall's characters behave as if on The White Lotus while "spouting psychobabble" that the Greeks would not recognize. Applying therapeutic categories to ancient tragedy, she writes, "obscures their insights into the unpredictable and unaccountable nature of human suffering" and undermines Aristotle's eleos — compassion. The takeaway: myths endure through transformation, but diagnosis flattens them.

What is George Packer's verdict on Woodward?

George Packer reviews Bob Woodward's Secrets: A Reporter's Memoir in The Atlantic. Woodward is 83. A Woodward book has appeared like clockwork for half a century, and Packer judges the enduring value of the best sellers as "an epic court chronicle" of presidential power.

The memoir, Packer argues, exposes Woodward's limits as his own subject. Citing Orwell's warning that "autobiography is only to be trusted when it reveals something disgraceful," Packer finds Woodward "scrupulous with facts but famously unable or unwilling to reflect." Woodward's self-description — "I believe my approach is straightforward and my manner forthright" — strikes Packer as earnest naivete. The gap in self-knowledge, he concludes, is "more damaging than an incorrect fact."

What does the Douglas memoir reveal?

Dan Piepenbring, in Harper's, finds Michael Douglas's One Helluva Ride — credited to two co-writers — "more brokered than authored." The gossip is abundant: lines of cocaine with O.J. Simpson, an affair with Kathleen Turner, drug-running in suitcases his father gave him. But Piepenbring flags glaring absences, including Douglas's 2013 claim about throat cancer and cunnilingus, and total silence on Disclosure.

The sharpest moment involves Glenn Close. When Douglas agreed to reshoot the ending of Fatal Attraction after test audiences rejected her character's suicide, Close asked how he would feel if it were his character. His reply: "Babe, I'm a whore." Piepenbring calls those four words something that "touch American bedrock." The book's best material is the father-son thread with Kirk Douglas, who lived to 103; his death, Piepenbring complains, rates barely a footnote.

Does Giridharadas's Neely book cohere?

Nick Tabor reviews Anand Giridharadas's Man in the Mirror: Hope, Struggle, and Belonging in an American City in The New Republic. The book examines the killing of Jordan Neely, the government policies that failed him, the trial of Daniel Penny, and American polarization. Giridharadas, best known for the 2018 bestseller Winners Take All, cited Adrian Nicole LeBlanc's Random Family (2003) and Katherine Boo's Behind the Beautiful Forevers (2012) as models.

Tabor's verdict is mixed. The book is "too panoramic," shifting among dozens of characters, some present for only a few pages. Giridharadas offers no explicit thesis, even though his New York Times essay supplied one: the subway death revealed "one of the last things we have in common — abandonment." Ultimately, Tabor writes, "the book fails to say enough about anything in particular." The sweep is commendable; the argument is missing.

Across the five reviews, a single theme recurs: powerful subjects — a president, a reporter, a movie star — who cannot see themselves clearly, and the critics who charge them for it.

Original: theatlantic.com

book-reviews, memoirs, joe-biden, promise-me-america, literary-criticism

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »