Billy Evans Breaks Silence on Amanda Seyfried in A24's Holmes Doc
Billy Evans says Amanda Seyfried was 'eager' to 'play a character' in A24's Holmes documentary 'You Can See Everything' — his first interview since its release.

Programme
- Billy Evans gave his first interview since the documentary's release to CBS News' Matt Gutman, published Sunday.
- "You Can See Everything" opened in theaters on Oct. 16 after more than three years in production.
- Evans said Seyfried was 'eager' to 'play a character' and that he was 'glad Nathan was there to help her.'
- The film is eligible for best documentary feature at the 99th Academy Awards and will be submitted across the board, per A24's awards site.
- Seyfried will be campaigned in the supporting actress category; Holmes is serving an 11-year prison sentence.
Billy Evans has given his first interview since the release of A24's documentary "You Can See Everything," and he used it to take a swipe at Amanda Seyfried's portrayal of Elizabeth Holmes.
Speaking to CBS News chief correspondent Matt Gutman in a sit-down released Sunday morning, Holmes' partner was asked directly what he thought of Seyfried's role in the film, which hit theaters on Oct. 16 after more than three years of quiet work by directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim.
"I'm really glad that they included her because it shows what a difference there is between the real thing and how eager she was to play a character," Evans said.
What did Evans actually say?
Pressed by Gutman on whether the actress played the disgraced Theranos founder well, Evans offered a barbed non-answer: he was "glad Nathan was there to help her." Gutman noted, "Doesn't seem like you hold very high opinion of her acting, or of her as a person."
Evans then closed the exchange. "Matt, I'm gonna do my best not to speak poorly about other people right now, because I've had a lot of people do that about me recently, and I know how it feels," he said.
That restraint is notable, because the bad feeling runs in both directions. Seyfried recently told Rolling Stone about her experience filming "You Can See Everything," revealing she did not tell her agents about the project and had "no approval" over filming. She also said her opinion of Evans "only got worse" as filming went on, and that she felt he "disrespected" her during a tense dinner-table conversation captured in the documentary.
What is the film, and why does it matter now?
"You Can See Everything" offers a close, at times uncomfortable look at Holmes a month before she began an 11-year prison sentence for defrauding Theranos investors. Seyfried appears as herself while reprising her Emmy-winning turn as Holmes from the Hulu series "The Dropout" — a performance that, in Evans's telling, now stands as a contrast to "the real thing."
The film is also heading into awards season with unusually broad ambitions. Beyond eligibility for best documentary feature at the 99th Academy Awards, A24's awards site lists submissions across the board:
- Best picture
- Director
- Production design
- Cinematography
- Costume design
- Film editing
- Makeup and hairstyling
- Sound
- Original score
Seyfried herself will be campaigned in the supporting actress category — a placement that keeps her on the circuit alongside a film in which she plays both participant and re-enactor.
What does this change for the film?
For a documentary already positioned as an Oscar contender, a public feud between its most famous participant and the partner of its subject adds fuel precisely when awards voters are watching. Evans has now put his criticism on record; Seyfried has put hers on record too. Neither has retracted anything.
Whether that friction helps or haunts the campaign will become clear as the 99th Academy Awards season unfolds.
Original: rollingstone.com
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,449 articles



