On viewFilm & Screen

Broadway's Ryan McCartan Leads Indie Crime Drama 'Only Good Feelings'

Ryan McCartan, star of Broadway's 'The Great Gatsby,' leads the indie crime drama 'Only Good Feelings,' opening in a limited New York run in February 2027 from SNR Films.

Broadway Star Ryan McCartan to Star in Crime Drama ‘Only Good Feelings’ (EXCLUSIVE)
Broadway Star Ryan McCartan to Star in Crime Drama ‘Only Good Feelings’ (EXCLUSIVE)Pexels / pixabay

Programme

  1. Ryan McCartan makes his theatrical film debut as the lead in 'Only Good Feelings.'
  2. SNR Films gives the film a limited New York run in February 2027.
  3. The film won best narrative film at the Manhattan Film Festival.
  4. McCartan's Broadway debut was in 2018 as Fiyero in 'Wicked.'
  5. The film was shot entirely in New York City.

Ryan McCartan, fresh off playing Jay Gatsby in Broadway's "The Great Gatsby," will make his theatrical film debut as the lead of "Only Good Feelings." SNR Films has given the indie crime drama a limited New York run starting February 2027.

The film shot entirely in New York City. McCartan plays Benny, a man haunted by guilt after his fiancée dies in a car accident. According to the official logline, the story follows Benny as he "spirals" and reconnects with "Kam (Kacavas), a troubled childhood friend who pulls him into robbery, insurance fraud and extortion as part of a desperate plan to flee to Mexico. What begins as an escape becomes a collision course with everything Benny has been running from."

Who joins McCartan on screen?

The ensemble is a familiar mix of indie and television faces:

  • Elias Kacavas ("Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin") as Kam
  • Heather Burns ("Manchester by the Sea")
  • Ajay Naidu ("Office Space")
  • Amanda Steele
  • Ryan Whitney Newman ("See Dad Run")

Shervin Nassi directed and co-wrote the screenplay with Grant Schumacher. Michael Marlon produces.

The casting marks a genre shift for McCartan. He has built his career on musical stages, not extortion schemes. His Broadway debut came in 2018 as Fiyero in "Wicked." In 2020 he took over as Hans in "Frozen." His most recent on-screen credit is the 2022 CW thriller series "The Winchesters."

How has the film fared so far?

"Only Good Feelings" already has festival credentials. It won best narrative film at the Manhattan Film Festival and best directorial debut for Nassi at the Chicago Indie Film Awards. Its 2026 selections include:

  • San Francisco Jewish Film Festival
  • Dallas Movie Fest
  • SoCal Film Awards
  • San Diego Independent Cinema Awards

What does the February 2027 run signal?

A limited New York theatrical release is a modest distribution footprint. It's the standard route for festival titles seeking reviews and awards attention before wider or streaming distribution. For McCartan, it is a first test of leading-man weight on film, after a résumé built on Broadway marquees and one CW series.

The February 2027 dates give SNR Films time to build on the festival momentum. Whether McCartan's stage audience follows him into a story of insurance fraud and flight to Mexico is the question the box office will answer.

Source: Variety Film

ryan-mccartan, only-good-feelings, indie-films, crime-drama, film-festivals

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »