On viewVisual Arts

Etsy AI terms trigger artist departures before 16 December

Etsy’s revised Terms of Use take effect on 16 December, granting partners AI-training rights that have prompted creators to close stores, warn customers and seek alternatives.

Artists Are Fleeing Etsy Over AI Policy
Artists Are Fleeing Etsy Over AI Policywal_172619 / pixabay

Programme

  1. Etsy’s revised Terms of Use take effect on 16 December.
  2. Section 5 permits AI and machine-learning development using seller content, subject to applicable opt-out rights.
  3. Etsy bans listings by bots and requires product photos to match the item sold.
  4. VP James Ossman says sellers retain ownership of their work.
  5. Etsy provides no general AI-training opt-out for sellers.

By Daniel Okafor

What changes in Etsy’s terms?

Etsy’s revised Terms of Use take effect on 16 December. They authorise the company and third-party partners to use seller content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine-learning systems.

The new clause in Section 5 states:

“This also includes the right for us and our third party partners and vendors to use Your Content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies, including to improve the Services and/or help keep them safe, subject to any applicable opt-out rights described in our Privacy Policy”

Section 5 already granted Etsy a perpetual licence (an enduring permission) to reproduce, modify, distribute and create derivative works from user content. The added authorisation extends that reach to AI development and service safety.

Those terms followed Etsy’s update to its content rules. The marketplace now bans listings by bots. It also requires product photos to resemble the item actually for sale. Creative Bloq reported that creators largely welcomed both measures, because quality products have struggled against AI “slop” and copied art posted by automated accounts.

Creative Bloq described Etsy as one of the best online places to sell art and design, particularly handmade craft items. Its sellers have included makers of jewellery and gifts produced with Cricut machines, alongside illustrators and poster designers. For some creators who rely on Etsy for income, the revised policy now presents a difficult commercial decision.

How are creators responding?

Creative Bloq reported a wave of store-closure announcements on social media. Some creators designed flyers and goodbye letters in their signature styles. Others remain on Etsy because they depend on it for most of their income, particularly during the year’s important sales period. Some fear the policy could damage their businesses in the short term.

That leaves several sellers asking customers to buy directly from them. They are using Etsy mainly as a storefront while moving transactions elsewhere. Alternative platforms include Marmalade Handmade, which takes a specifically anti-AI position. Creative Bloq noted that such alternatives remain small beside Etsy. The outlet expects independent website builders could receive more custom work from artists and crafters as sellers leave.

What does Etsy say about AI training?

James Ossman, Etsy’s VP of Customer Operations, addressed sellers in an update on the Etsy Community site. He said sellers retain ownership of their creative work and that Etsy is using AI to support sellers and improve the shopping experience.

Ossman wrote:

“We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity. Again, this is not changing. Our goal at Etsy has always been to connect you and your unique items with buyers.”

He listed the platform’s intended AI applications. These include identifying potentially fraudulent accounts and related listings, understanding inventory, helping buyers find products, generating tailored recommendations and building tools that make sellers’ businesses more efficient.

Ossman also said Etsy uses security tools to detect and limit unauthorised scraping (automated retrieval of marketplace content). Its terms prohibit unauthorised use of marketplace content for AI training. For authorised partners, however, the position remains less clear.

The clause does not say whether authorised partners can train models for uses unrelated to Etsy. Etsy has also not provided a general opt-out (a mechanism for sellers to refuse such use). For sellers, the distinction is as practical as displaying stock on a shelf versus surrendering the right to reproduce it.

Where can sellers go?

Plain communication would have helped. Creative Bloq argued that if the authorised uses are benign, Etsy should have communicated the update more clearly. The existing wording leaves creators to decide whether reassurance outweighs uncertainty.

Before 16 December, sellers who reject the clause need a direct-sales route or a smaller alternative platform. Until Etsy clarifies outside partners and provides a general opt-out, its reassuring language will not settle the argument.

Source: artsjournal.com

etsy, ai-training, artist-rights, online-marketplace, creative-content

Also on view

« Previous article