On viewFilm & Screen

Four Crowd-Pleasers, One Oscar Slot: The Best Picture Underdog Race

Four crowd-pleasers — 'I Play Rocky,' 'Club Kid,' 'Being Heumann' and 'Mr. Irrelevant' — vie for one likely best picture slot, with 'Club Kid' leading on Metacritic at 80.

The Oscars Usually Reward One Crowd-Pleaser Movie With A Nomination
The Oscars Usually Reward One Crowd-Pleaser Movie With A Nominationdbreen / pixabay

Programme

  1. Four films compete for one likely best picture nomination slot this Oscar season.
  2. "Club Kid" leads the field with an 80 Metacritic score; "Being Heumann" trails at 63.
  3. "I Play Rocky" director Peter Farrelly made the 2019 best picture winner "Green Book."
  4. Paramount gave "Mr. Irrelevant" a Christmas Day release after strong test scores.
  5. "CODA," the 2022 best picture winner, proved crowd-pleasers can take the top prize.

Four films are competing for what is likely a single best picture nomination in this year's Oscar race, according to the Los Angeles Times' breakdown of the "crowd-pleaser" lane. The contenders: "I Play Rocky," "Club Kid," "Being Heumann" and "Mr. Irrelevant."

The pattern is familiar. Crowd-pleasers — movies built on underdogs, uplift, tears and warm endings — rarely get much love from Oscar voters. Yet "The Blind Side" earned a best picture nomination, and "CODA" won the top prize outright in 2022.

What does each contender bring?

"I Play Rocky" tells the story of struggling actor Sylvester Stallone writing a movie and demanding to play the lead. That movie was "Rocky," which won best picture in 1977. Director Peter Farrelly made the 2019 best picture winner "Green Book." The film sits at an OK 68 on Metacritic. Anthony Ippolito plays Stallone as a cuddly figure whose biggest flaw is believing in himself too much, while Tracy Letts plays a studio exec unhappy with Stallone's stubbornness. Butkus the bullmastiff, as half a century ago, steals every scene. The Times' verdict: "Hollywood loves scrappy self-mythology. It could be a contender."

"Club Kid" follows a hard-partying queer club promoter who sobers up after learning he has a 10-year-old son. Producer Alex Coco won best picture two years ago for "Anora," which shares its chaotic energy. Critics like it most of the quartet — it has an 80 on Metacritic. Writer-director Jordan Firstman cast himself as Peter, and Reggie Absolom plays the cool kid who arrives at his door. With A24 fielding multiple contenders ("You Can See Everything," "The Invite," "The Debut"), the paper argues the realistic win would be an original screenplay nomination for Firstman — "a strong possibility."

"Being Heumann" chronicles disability-rights activist Judy Heumann, who died in 2023. Director Siân Heder, who co-wrote the film with Rebekah Taussig, won an Oscar for writing "CODA." It has the weakest critical score of the four, a 63 on Metacritic. Ruth Madeley brings Heumann's fire, wit and abrasiveness to the lead role, and the film closes with Heumann in her wheelchair before the Capitol steps — no ramp in sight. Still, the Times finds the storytelling "a little too cute and formulaic" to go far with the academy.

"Mr. Irrelevant" stars David Corenswet — last seen as Superman — as John Tuggle, the last player chosen in the 1983 NFL draft, who makes the team and is then diagnosed with cancer. Michael Shannon, a two-time nominee, plays Giants coach Bill Parcells. The film hasn't screened for critics, but strong audience test scores pushed Paramount to give it a prime Christmas Day release. The paper's verdict: "Peak dad-core, but no awards" — though it will likely win the family movie night over the holidays. Unless the family lives in Philly.

What does this change for the race?

The crowd-pleaser lane typically yields one nomination at most, and pedigree matters. Two of the four films carry direct best picture bloodlines — Farrelly's "Green Book" win for "I Play Rocky," Heder's "CODA" screenplay Oscar for "Being Heumann." But the strongest critical scores belong to "Club Kid," whose A24 slate could split the studio's own votes. With nominations still months out, the critical reception of "Mr. Irrelevant" — the only film critics haven't seen — remains the race's biggest unknown.

Source: artsjournal.com

oscars, best-picture, awards-season, crowd-pleasers, underdog-films

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »