Frick reattributes Virgin and Child to Andrea della Robbia
X-ray fluorescence readings and a clothed Christ Child move the Frick's glazed terracotta Virgin and Child from "school of Della Robbia" to Andrea della Robbia, c. 1470s-80s.

Programme
- The Frick reattributed its Virgin and Child to Andrea della Robbia, dating it to the 1470s or 80s; the relief had been catalogued as "school of Della Robbia" since at least 2008.
- Conservation fellow Greta Llanes Serrano took multiple XRF readings on the back and front of the relief over the past year in the Frick's new conservation studio.
- Allan Marquand identified the relief as by either Luca or "very early Andrea" in a 1906 publication, then decided "that it had to be Andrea" in 1914.
- Helen Clay Frick acquired the relief in 1922; a few weeks ago it moved from the Frick Art Research Library to the damask-lined first-floor Octagon Room.
- Chief conservator Julia Day, appointed last year, says conservation-guided upgrades happen perhaps once a decade; the Virgin and Child is the Frick's only Della Robbia.
The Frick Collection has reattributed its Virgin and Child to Andrea della Robbia and dated it to the 1470s or 80s. The glazed terracotta relief had been catalogued as "school of Della Robbia" — a lower rung it occupied since at least 2008.
Attribution carries most of the value in Della Robbia collecting. For much of the 15th and 16th centuries, Florentine sculptors named Della Robbia made glazed terracotta — fired clay coated with a glassy, painted surface — of great renown.
Scholars and collectors have long preferred Luca della Robbia (1399/1400-1482), who founded the dynasty, and his nephew Andrea (1435-1525). Similar works by later Della Robbias, or by the workshop, come in a very distant third.
The object is a framed relief: a veiled Madonna holding a Christ child, attended by cherubs. It is buff-coloured earthenware, carries the family's distinctive white and blue glazes, and keeps traces of gilding. Helen Clay Frick, Henry's daughter, acquired it in 1922, and for most of the last century it sat outside the main reading room of the Frick Art Research Library.
How did a workshop piece become a 15th-century Andrea?
The trail starts with Allan Marquand (1853-1924), the Princeton University art historian and early American luminary in Della Robbia studies. In a 1906 publication, when the relief belonged to a private German collector, Marquand identified it as by either Luca or "very early Andrea". Then, in 1914, he decided "that it had to be Andrea".
- After the relief reached the Frick family collection and found its way to the library entrance, it moved from being a Della Robbia generally to a work by Andrea — a decision a librarian recorded, though Llanes Serrano says nobody knows who actually made the call.
- By 2008 at the latest, it had been demoted to "school of Della Robbia", the status it held for decades.
Llanes Serrano says the road to the new attribution ran through twists and turns, and an outright gap or two.
Julia Day, appointed last year as the Frick's new chief conservator, opened the case after attending a Della Robbia conference in spring 2025. "I just thought that we have this piece, and nobody's really spent time looking at it," Day says.
Greta Llanes Serrano, a conservation fellow at the Frick who worked on the recent treatment, analysed the relief over the past year in the museum's new conservation studio. She took multiple XRF readings — X-ray fluorescence, a non-invasive technique that identifies which chemical elements are present — on different spots of the back and front.
The readings revealed the elements in the glaze. Comparing them with analyses of autograph Della Robbia works, meaning pieces made by the sculptors themselves, placed the relief in a 1470s-80s window, when the older Luca gave way to the younger Andrea.
A second clue was visible without instruments. "The Christ Child is clothed," Llanes Serrano says. In later versions of the motif, made by the sculptors and their workshop, it was more common to show him unclothed.
Her conclusion stays deliberately hedged. "We're suggesting it's by Andrea," says Llanes Serrano.
What does the reattribution change for visitors?
Two things, one institutional and one physical. The museum has rewritten the object's authorship and date, replacing a workshop label with a named artist and a decade of the 1470s or 80s. And the relief now hangs where the public can see it.
A few weeks ago the Frick moved the work out of the library, where it had been out of view from the general public, and installed it in a damask-lined spot in the mansion's first-floor Octagon Room, redecorated during the museum's recent renovation. For most of a century, visitors could not see the piece at all.
Upgrades of this kind are rare here. Day says conservation-led reappraisals happen perhaps once a decade. The Virgin and Child is the only Della Robbia in the museum's collection.
The Frick's chain of reasoning now travels with the relief: XRF readings, comparative analyses, a clothed Christ Child, and a 1914 verdict that lasted as "school of" only because nobody looked closely. Other museums holding similar workshop pieces will have to decide whether they can match that level of scrutiny.
Source: theartnewspaper.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,640 articles
Also on view
Fondazione Vezza to open sculpture trail at medieval monastery site in 2027
Bronze Saints and Broken Hearts: A Review of the Frick in 2026
Huntington Acquires Five Works Spanning Four Centuries, From Deruta Plate to Raqib Shaw
Broken Sculptures to Muholi Portraits: Four Art Books That Land This November



