On viewFilm & Screen

Josephine review: Sundance prize-winner stumbles, but its eight-year-old star does not

Sundance prize-winner Josephine pairs a superb debut from eight-year-old Mason Reeves with high-concept missteps; the verdict is withheld, but the film's contrivances are not.

Josephine review – Channing Tatum and Gemma Chan ballast knotty drama about a child witness to a rape
Josephine review – Channing Tatum and Gemma Chan ballast knotty drama about a child witness to a rapeAI-generated

Programme

  1. Mason Reeves, an eight-year-old newcomer, plays the title role in Beth de Araújo's Josephine.
  2. The film premiered at Sundance and has won prizes and acclaim.
  3. Channing Tatum and Gemma Chan play San Francisco parents Damien and Claire.
  4. The story hinges on a child's witness testimony at a trial whose verdict is never shown.

Eight-year-old newcomer Mason Reeves gives the outstanding performance in Josephine, Beth de Araújo's Sundance-honoured drama about a child who witnesses a rape — and he carries a film whose high-concept ambitions do not all land.

The movie has won prizes and acclaim since its premiere at Sundance. That track record deserves note, but it also invites scrutiny: the reviewer found himself unsure about some of the film's high-concept ideas even while rating Reeves's lead performance as outstanding.

Channing Tatum and Gemma Chan play Damien and Claire, a smart professional couple in San Francisco with a bright young daughter, Josephine, played by Reeves. One morning Damien takes Josephine to Golden Gate Park to play football — the family watches the English Premier League on TV. Josephine runs ahead of her father to a secluded spot where he cannot immediately find her. There she witnesses a rape, filmed in long shot, no less horrifying for the distance.

What happens after the park?

Damien catches up, gives chase to the rapist, and Josephine and the victim end up in the back of a police car — almost as if they are culprits and prisoners — while the officers and Damien handle matters. Deeply affected by something she cannot understand or process, Josephine starts acting out at school. Damien bizarrely insists she take self-defence classes, which does not help. Her disorientation borders on psychosis as the court date nears, when Josephine must give evidence before a jury.

Where does the film falter?

There are strong moments. There are also moments when Damien and Claire's furious rows look like an acting improv class. The film's central motif — the rapist appearing silently in scenes like a ghost only Josephine can see — arguably approximates what many people in this situation experience, but after a while it feels contrived.

The plot thins where it should tighten. The victim is supposedly absent from court, not being subject to a subpoena, a procedural chill the film cancels when she arrives at the end to give Josephine an emotional thank you for her courageous evidence.

The verdict is never shown. The defence tries to undermine Josephine's testimony and suggest something more complex was going on — some consensual role-play — but the film itself creates no complexity or ambiguity from what Josephine saw or from what the audience sees through her eyes. Perhaps the point is that the verdict does not matter, that Josephine and her parents must still get on with their lives and deal with the after-effects of the trauma. That is fair enough. In the real world, the verdict would surely matter a great deal.

So the film earns some misjudgments. Reeves does not. His performance is the reason to watch, and the measure against which the film's riskier choices — the ghost motif, the withheld verdict, the softened procedural logic — fall short.

Source: Guardian Film

josephine, mason-reeves, sundance-film-festival, film-review, beth-de-araujo

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »