Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs Join Broadway’s Schmigadoon!
Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs take over Josh Skinner and Melissa Gimble in Broadway’s Schmigadoon! for a six-week run from Jan. 19 to Feb. 28, 2027, following Jan. 17 finales.

Programme
- Radnor plays Josh Skinner and Behrs plays Melissa Gimble from Jan. 19 to Feb. 28, 2027.
- The scheduled run lasts six weeks.
- Alex Brightman and Sara Chase give their final performances Jan. 17.
- Behrs makes her Broadway debut in Schmigadoon!.
- Radnor previously appeared on Broadway in The Graduate and Disgraced.
By Elena Vasquez
Who takes over, and when?
Broadway.com reported that Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs will play Josh Skinner and Melissa Gimble in the Tony-winning musical Schmigadoon! for six weeks, from Jan. 19 through Feb. 28, 2027. Original cast members Alex Brightman and Tony nominee Sara Chase will give their final performances Jan. 17.
The timetable allows no overlap between the named casts. Brightman and Chase end on Jan. 17, while Radnor and Behrs begin two days later. The announcement sets no extension beyond Feb. 28 and describes their engagement as the limit of their run.
Two named roles, two departing original cast members and one six-week replacement period define the change. Radnor will take over Josh Skinner; Behrs will take over Melissa Gimble. No other cast changes are listed in the report.
The result is a temporary, dated recasting rather than a permanent change to the Tony-winning musical.
What experience does Radnor bring?
Broadway.com identifies Radnor as best known for How I Met Your Mother. He previously appeared on Broadway in The Graduate and Disgraced. He also received a Lucille Lortel Award nomination for The Ally, an off-Broadway production.
Radnor’s film credits include Three Birthdays, All Happy Families, Social Animals and Afternoon Delight. His additional television credits include Hunters, Fleishman Is in Trouble, Rise and Mercy Street.
Radnor wrote and directed the film Liberal Arts. The report identifies Happythankyoumoreplease as his directorial debut, extending his work behind the camera.
Radnor brings two prior Broadway appearances, an off-Broadway award nomination and experience writing and directing for film into the engagement.
What does Behrs bring to her Broadway debut?
Broadway.com describes Behrs as a breakout from the CBS comedy 2 Broke Girls, a show that ran for six seasons before she later joined CBS’s The Neighborhood. Her film credits include Hello, My Name Is Doris and Monsters University.
Behrs makes her Broadway debut in Schmigadoon! as Melissa Gimble. The report also notes that she previously made her New York stage debut.
Behrs arrives with a six-season television profile and film credits, but without a previous Broadway production.
How does the six-week engagement change the cast?
The pairing brings two career profiles into the same two roles. Radnor already has Broadway credits in The Graduate and Disgraced, plus an off-Broadway award nomination. Behrs has six seasons on a CBS comedy and makes her Broadway debut here.
The schedule makes both changes fixed and brief. The original cast members finish before the newcomers begin, with no overlap in the reported dates. The newcomers then have six weeks, ending Feb. 28, 2027.
For audiences, the decisive dates are Jan. 17, Jan. 19 and Feb. 28. The first marks the outgoing cast’s final performances, the second opens the temporary run, and the third sets its end.
The next fixed point is the Jan. 19 opening of the Radnor-Behrs run.
Source: broadway.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,605 articles



