On viewFilm & Screen

Letterboxd's $330 Million Sale Talks Worry the Theaters That Rely On It

The New York Times Company is in exclusive talks to buy Letterboxd for roughly $330 million, and repertory programmers are asking what a sale would change for theaters and audiences.

What Happens If We Break Letterboxd?
What Happens If We Break Letterboxd?geralt / pixabay

Programme

  1. The New York Times Company is in exclusive talks to buy Letterboxd for roughly $330 million, reported November 5.
  2. Ticket sales for Wajda's 'Kanał' at the Trylon in Minneapolis picked up after opening-night Letterboxd reviews.
  3. Simkl's importer can move watchlists, ratings, and full review text, but comments and follows stay behind.
  4. The Trylon's Dede Allen series runs 'Dog Day Afternoon' on December 11 and 'Mike's Murder' on December 18, both in 35mm.

The New York Times Company is in exclusive talks to buy Letterboxd for roughly $330 million, the New York Times reported on November 5. Under the deal being discussed, the film-logging site would likely keep operating on its own and use the Times Company's advertising technology. For small theaters across the country, the question is simpler: can a person who loved a movie on Monday still reach a person who might see it on Wednesday?

The Trylon in Minneapolis has been living inside that question. Earlier this month, the cinema gave audiences six chances over three days to see "Kanał," Andrzej Wajda's 1957 film about Polish resistance fighters retreating into the sewers of Warsaw. After opening night, programmer John Moret saw enthusiastic reviews appear on Letterboxd. The next evening, ticket sales picked up.

Moret could imagine the calculation for somebody still on the fence. "Oh, these people I trust went to go see this movie, and they loved it. And it's just playing for two more days," he said.

Five days before "Kanał" opened, Ken Russell's "The Devils" sold out the Trylon on election night.

What does Letterboxd actually do for theaters?

Moret also co-founded the national Programmers' Jam with Bret Berg, theatrical sales director at the American Genre Film Archive, and Dan Halsted of Portland's Hollywood Theatre. When the Jam met in Los Angeles in May, Berg told IndieWire that programmers had access to more restorations than ever before, more places to show them, and a new audience coming through the doors.

When they spoke again this month, Berg said Letterboxd drives "the FOMO of needing to be conversant in a movie of the moment." He can see why a press company might be a good home for the site. He also remembers what the last sale taught him. Something people had spent years building was "just an asset to be bought and sold."

In the r/Letterboxd thread about the talks, one commenter liked the prospect of a ratings system free of "studios putting their fingers on the scale." They worried about paywalled features and ads.

How do programmers read the reviews?

Berg reads reviews from one town with the next town in mind. A joke review with thousands of likes might tell him little about who would pay to see a film. Five people writing about a one-off screening at a DIY microcinema might tell him a great deal. For someone deciding which films in the archive's catalog deserve another look, that is "some interesting free data."

Three and a half stars on Letterboxd is enough to make Berg give an unfamiliar title in his own catalog a closer look. Then he asks: "How many audience moments are there? That's what I care about." He named Spectacle in Brooklyn and Whammy! in Los Angeles as venues where reviews reliably tell him whether a movie made an impression.

Moret still checks Letterboxd after a screening. "I can see that night exactly how they responded," he said. He has watched patrons meet Trylon volunteers and follow each other afterward. Some knew one another by their Letterboxd handles before they started going to movies together.

His December Dede Allen series has its own logic: "Dog Day Afternoon" plays in 35mm on December 11, followed by James Bridges' 1984 mystery "Mike's Murder," starring Debra Winger, on December 18.

What happens if the site breaks?

Berg also values who gets to write. He singled out trans critics among the writers who can find an audience on Letterboxd without first persuading an editor to commission a review. If the site imploded, he said, he would expect "a return to gut feeling."

Andrew Masyk, founder of rival tracking site Simkl, says its importer can bring over a watchlist, ratings, and the full text of reviews. Custom lists can migrate using a separate tool. Comments and follows stay behind. "People have to find each other again, and that's the hardest part of moving," he wrote.

Masyk's test for any buyer is whether the exit stays open. "So the export button matters more than who owns the company," he wrote.

If a buyer gave sponsored posts more room in the feed, users could still log every movie and miss the three sentences from a friend that would have carried them to the Trylon. Hear about "Kanał" on Monday, and you can still go. Hear about it on Wednesday, and you have missed it.

Source: indiewire.com

letterboxd, independent-theaters, film-reviews, film-discovery, media-acquisitions

Also on view

« Previous article