M*A*S*H Wins Literary Hub's Bracket for Best Literary TV Adaptation
M*A*S*H beat Roots in the final of Literary Hub's six-round reader bracket for the best literary TV adaptation, capping a week of daily voting in November.
Programme
- M*A*S*H won Literary Hub's best literary TV adaptation bracket, beating Roots in the final after six rounds of voting.
- The series ran 11 seasons and 256 episodes on CBS, premiering in 1972.
- It adapts Richard Hooker's 1968 novel MASH: A Novel About Three Army Doctors, via Robert Altman's 1970 film.
- The 1983 finale still holds the record for the highest percentage of TV sets watching the same program simultaneously.
- Voting ran daily from November 9 to November 16, from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM EST per round.
MAS*H has won Literary Hub's reader-voted bracket for the best literary TV adaptation of all time, edging out Roots in the final round after six rounds of voting. The announcement came from James Folta, who ran the tournament and signed off with the words: "Now I retire to my Bracket Cave deep in the hills, to rest and to dream of what brackets may come."
The show competed in what Literary Hub called its Cozy category — a bracket slot for dependable, comforting television — and Folta argued that fit was no accident. "It feels fitting that a show from our Cozy category won this thing, since dependable and comforting is television's best, and truest, mode," he wrote.
How the bracket worked
The rules were simple: for every match-up, readers picked a favorite. Folta's instructions framed the contest as a search for the best show, not necessarily the most faithful adaptation — though fidelity could factor into a voter's thinking. Voting ran across a week:
- Round of 64: Monday, November 9
- Round of 32: Tuesday, November 10
- Round of 16: Wednesday, November 11
- Quarterfinals: Thursday, November 12
- Semifinals: Friday, November 13 through Sunday, November 15
- The Finals: Monday, November 16
Each round ran from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM EST, with results tabulated, in Folta's phrase, using "our best liberal arts major math."
What does MAS*H actually adapt?
The series traces back to Richard Hooker's 1968 novel MASH: A Novel About Three Army Doctors. Robert Altman adapted the book into his 1970 film, and CBS launched the television spinoff in 1972. Literary Hub's blurb for the winner tagged its subgenres as "War is Bad • Wisecracking is Fun" and summed up its premise as "Antics among atrocities."
The show ran for 11 seasons and 256 episodes. Over that span it evolved from a straight-ahead sitcom into something more dramatic and challenging. Folta pointed to one concrete marker of that shift: the show's changing relationship with its laugh track, which tracked how seriously MAS*H began to take its own stories.
Set during the Korean War, the series more obviously paralleled and criticized American involvement in Vietnam — a reading Literary Hub's own notes endorse, crediting the show with layering drama and genuine commentary onto its humor and challenging what a television comedy was supposed to look like.
The record that still stands
The numbers behind the win are hard to argue with. The 1983 finale still holds the record for the highest percentage of TV sets watching the same program simultaneously, and at the time of airing it was the most watched television episode in American broadcast history.
Folta also relayed a beloved piece of finale folklore, with a caveat about its veracity: the story that New York's toilets broke after the finale because so many viewers waited until the end of the two-and-a-half-hour episode to relieve themselves that the city's plumbing gave out at once. "What other TV show was so popular that it broke a city's toilets?" he asked. "Only MAS*H."
More than 50 years after its premiere, appreciation for the show endures — Literary Hub's verdict: "Put it on when you need a history lesson with personality." The site promises a new bracket next time around.
Original: bookshop.org
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,554 articles



