On viewArts & Culture

NEH Brings Conservative Intellectuals to Rome Palazzo

The NEH, the largest U.S. public funder of the humanities, quietly convened conservative intellectuals in a Rome palazzo to debate Western decline, religion and education.

At a Roman Palazzo, a U.S. Cultural Agency Defends the Western Tradition
At a Roman Palazzo, a U.S. Cultural Agency Defends the Western TraditionPexels / pixabay

Programme

  1. The NEH organized a two-day, unpublicized conference titled "Classical Foundations and Moral Authority" in Rome last week.
  2. The endowment directs part of its $207 million annual budget to Western civilization and civic thought centers.
  3. First Things, edited by speaker R.R. Reno, recently received a $2 million NEH grant.
  4. NEH chair Michael McDonald announced a follow-up conference next year in Athens.

The National Endowment for the Humanities, the largest public funder of the humanities in the United States, convened a two-day conference in a Roman palazzo last week titled "Classical Foundations and Moral Authority" — a gathering it has not publicized.

The event brought together prominent Italians with nearly a dozen Anglophone academics, largely drawn from conservative critics of universities, modern secular liberal democracy, or both. It reflects continuing shifts at the agency since President Trump's return to office, as it has aligned itself with White House priorities including the defense of Western civilization.

Over the past year, the endowment has directed a significant portion of its $207 million annual budget to university-based Western civilization and civic thought centers, which conservatives promote as a corrective to the liberal tilt of academia. It recently announced a new program of direct grants to public, private and religious high schools teaching a classical humanities curriculum. The endowment did not respond to requests for comment about the conference.

What did the ambassador say?

Brian Burch, the U.S. ambassador to the Holy See, recounted calls from friends since the midterm elections worried that "we are in the days of the fall of Rome." He reassured them that a two-year Congress "is a very short barbarian invasion."

Still, Burch — a longtime conservative political activist before becoming ambassador in 2025 — warned that the West faces danger from within as well as from its enemies.

"Decline is rarely imposed from the outside," Burch said. Rather, "it is chosen, one comfortable compromise at a time."

Michael McDonald, the endowment's chair, set the tone in his opening remarks. "The Western intellectual tradition forms the bedrock of our democratic institutions, our artistic achievements and our shared cultural heritage," McDonald said. "Yet we may be losing it."

Who spoke?

The American lineup included:

  • Patrick Deneen, a political theorist at the University of Notre Dame and author of "Why Liberalism Failed"
  • R.R. Reno, editor of the conservative religious journal First Things, which recently received a $2 million grant from the endowment
  • James Hankins, a former Harvard professor who last year wrote a widely discussed essay accusing that university of abandoning the teaching of Western history; he now teaches at the Hamilton School for Classical and Civic Education at the University of Florida
  • John O'Sullivan, the British president of the Danube Institute, a Budapest think tank closely aligned with Viktor Orban, the former prime minister of Hungary

Following Orban's defeat, the Danube Institute recently created an offshoot in the United States dedicated to uniting Europe and America against "malignant ideologies from woke progressivism to radical Islamism."

The panels, recorded and posted on an Italian government website, covered education, artificial intelligence, law and global affairs, with frequent warnings that Western democracies were coming unmoored from their moral and cultural underpinnings.

How central was religion?

On the opening panel, "Rome and the Foundations of Civil Order," the philosopher Marcello Pera — a former president of the Italian senate known for his intellectual friendship with Pope Benedict XVI — described an instability at the heart of modern liberal democracy. The liberal state, Pera said, "has conquered the West," but its individualism and neglect of the West's Christian roots have left it vulnerable.

"How can a society of individuals, each free to pursue their own conception of the good or happiness, remain stable or cohesive?" Pera asked. "How can the state itself avoid disintegration?"

Burch, speaking on the same panel, paraphrased a recent comment by Bishop Robert Barron, a prominent conservative bishop from Minnesota: "We cannot speak coherently about freedom and rights without speaking about God."

Reno praised a recently enacted Texas law mandating the teaching of the Bible, which he called "the fountain of our humanistic culture."

Where did the speakers disagree?

No specific policies or programs emerged from Rome. The discussion kept to a philosophical cast, and speakers divided over how to define the Western tradition itself: an unending argument with all perspectives valid, or a set of truths to be transmitted.

Deneen hailed the spread of university civic thought centers and K-12 classical schools but called such efforts "insufficiently ambitious." Justifying them as "viewpoint diversity," he said, risks reducing the Western classics to "one minor note in what is otherwise a dominant massive orchestra of modernist relativism."

"Most people who say they want to teach the Western tradition don't want our students to come away raving Communist lunatics," Deneen said, "but actually want them in some way, shape or form to have a certain set of beliefs." The challenge, he said, was doing that without stunting students' intellectual growth.

Hankins emphasized instilling "intellectual honesty," including about one's own mistakes. "Even if you walk away from Princeton or Harvard or Yale with socialist ideas, which I consider to be simply false," he said, "reason will get a second chance. Truth will get a second chance."

O'Sullivan took a darker view. Quoting the political theorist Chantal Delsol, he said the French education system has produced "an immense group of illiterates" — and it is no wonder, he said, that they want to "burn down not only their schools" but also the town hall.

What happens next?

At the closing session, McDonald announced a follow-up conference next year in Athens. One panelist said "the hour is late" and the problem urgent when it comes to renewing the cultural foundations of the West.

"Let's try to be more urgent in Athens," McDonald quipped.

Josephine de La Bruyère contributed reporting.

Original: firstthings.com

national-endowment-for-the-humanities, conservative-intellectuals, classical-education, western-civilization, religion-and-public-life

Also on view

« Previous article