On viewArt Market

Phillips Retreats as Christie's and Sotheby's Stand Alone

Phillips sold a record $746 million in 2022; now its CEO says it is "time really to look at profitability," leaving the art market facing a Christie's–Sotheby's duopoly.

As Phillips Scales Back, the ‘Big Two’ Auction Houses Seem to Stand Alone
As Phillips Scales Back, the ‘Big Two’ Auction Houses Seem to Stand Alonesucco / pixabay

Programme

  1. Phillips sold a record $746 million in 2022 but now prioritizes profitability over growth, per CEO Martin Wilson.
  2. Christie's and Sotheby's offer 45 lots above $10 million this week against Phillips's two.
  3. Bonhams out-earned Phillips by $43 million last year; Heritage hit $2.2 billion in 2025.
  4. Phillips staged the most lucrative watch auction in history in Geneva, $112.3 million, this month.
  5. The house holds about 7 percent of industry sales, per ARTDAI.

Two lots in Phillips's marquee New York sale this week — a David Hockney group portrait and a Modigliani limestone head — carry estimates above $10 million. Christie's and Sotheby's between them offer 45 lots above that blue-chip threshold. That gap is the story of the modern auction market.

Phillips, the 226-year-old house long positioned as the third challenger to the "Big Two," has pulled back from all-out competition, and experts now worry the art market is heading toward a genuine duopoly.

"One client described us as scrappers and I loved that description," Martin Wilson, Phillips's chief executive, said. "That is how we put our sales together. We don't get a ready-made big collection landing in our laps."

Wilson, who joined the firm as a lawyer in 2018 and took the top job in 2024, rejected the idea that Phillips was withdrawing — but said the house would no longer grow at all costs. "You start with growth being the priority over profitability. We had reached that point in growth where we had credibility," he said, adding it was "time really to look at profitability."

What changed at Phillips?

Four years ago the picture looked different. In 2022 Phillips sold $746 million of art and design — a company record — from a sleek new space, with spring sales including an $85 million Jean-Michel Basquiat painting, a $20 million Yves Klein blue monochrome and a $15.7 million Alexander Calder sculpture. Caroline Sayan, chief executive of the advisory Cadell North America, said the firm's expansion had made it "the envy of the bigger auction houses."

Yet even then Phillips held only about 7 percent of industry sales, according to the market database ARTDAI. Its value to consignors was leverage: a seller whose $18 million Joan Mitchell might be fifth-billed at Christie's could get star treatment at Phillips.

"The more competition in the auction market, the better it is for consignors," said Thomas Danziger, a lawyer who represents art sellers. "To have a third leg of the stool is important to any healthy market, especially the art market. Two-legged stools never do as well."

According to three former executives who spoke anonymously, the Russian ownership — Mercury Group founders Leonid Fridlyand and Leonid Strunin, who completed their acquisition in 2012 — grew reluctant amid a market contraction to spend the hundreds of millions needed to win major collections. Phillips retreated from a yearslong pursuit of the $922 million Macklowe collection, four former executives said; Sotheby's won the trove, then the most valuable collection sold at auction. Ownership also soured on guarantees after the 2023 Triton Collection sale of Cubist and Expressionist works brought in $84.7 million, three former executives said. A Phillips spokeswoman, Jaime Israni, denied the sale had disappointed the owners.

Wilson disputed any pullback: "They have reiterated their unwavering commitment to Phillips, remaining optimistic about the future and success of the company."

Where does the house go now?

Some staff read the pivot as a shift to the "middle market" of works between $50,000 and $500,000. "The company that I put 10 years of my life into, and had a lot of fun and success doing so, is now a very different beast," said Jonathan Crockett, who resigned as chairman of Phillips Asia in September. "The strategy no longer resonated with me." Most of the 2020 leadership team has left.

The middle market is itself contested. Bonhams out-earned Phillips by $43 million last year and opened new headquarters on Manhattan's Billionaire's Row; Heritage Auctions hit a record $2.2 billion in 2025 sales on collectibles demand.

Wilson counters with concrete numbers. Phillips held its first modern and contemporary sale in Paris in October; the high estimate for this week's New York evening sale is up almost 45 percent on last year, helped by the Modigliani, estimated at $28 million to $35 million. In Geneva this month the house staged the most lucrative watch auction in history, at $112.3 million.

The caveat is scale. "The revenue of one top day sale painting is maybe 50 watches," Sayan said. The next few years will show whether profitability and top-level competition can coexist at a house that Wilson insists still wants "to compete at the highest level we can" — with the tools it actually has.

Source: NYT Arts

phillips, christie-s, sotheby-s, auction-market, middle-market

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »