Queer Memoir in an Age of Error: Rereading Brian Blanchfield's Proxies
Brian Blanchfield's Proxies, 24 essays first published in January 2016, breaks memoir's contracts and reads as queer respite amid a second Trump administration.

Programme
- Brian Blanchfield's Proxies, 24 short essays, was first published in January 2016.
- Claire Lowdon's 2017 review called the book's repetition 'mantra, then superstition, then OCD-style neurosis.'
- The book appeared at the start of the first Trump administration; ten years later queer rights continue to be eroded.
- Fact-checking is confined to a separate chapter, 'Corrections', at the back of the book.
- Memoirs and general nonfiction are currently not selling well amid publishing's broader collapse.
Brian Blanchfield's Proxies turned ten this year, and the book has rarely felt more urgent. First published in January 2016, at the front of the first Trump administration, the collection of 24 short essays now arrives at its anniversary amid a second administration in which, as one critic puts it, queer rights are still being eroded at breakneck speed.
The essay opens on a personal scene. In 2018, the writer received the book from a new friend, part of the early stages of a mutual crush, together with a promise that she would love it. The trick worked. The two later shared a snowy cab ride home after lingering over orange wine at Molasses Books in Brooklyn. But the desire that quietly colors Proxies proved less captivating than what the author identifies as the book's real achievement: Blanchfield's ability to weave between genres with little care for establishing parameters for his reader.
Proxies, subtitled essays near knowing, is Blanchfield's third book. It combines autobiography with apparently arbitrary interest points: talking owls, housesitting, frottage, and the pesky task of defining gay sex. The prose swings between the floral language of a seasoned poet and the straightforward tones of a memoirist, balancing academic touchpoints against whole cultural remembrances.
How does the book break memoir's rules?
Each essay follows a rigid frame. A topic is announced, then a subheader follows, always reading Permitting shame, Error and Guilt, Myself the Single Source. Then the unspooling begins. In her 2017 review in The White Review, Claire Lowdon lamented that the repetition atop the page "becomes mantra, then superstition, then OCD-style neurosis." She noted that Blanchfield "is forcibly staking out territory for himself and declaring it a safe space. It doesn't work like that. You have to earn it."
Blanchfield is a lone authority here, but a faulty one, and he says so up front. His story is told not as truth but as memory best recalled. Unlike traditional memoir, which tells the story of what happened, Blanchfield insists on witness rather than testimony. He reserves fact-checking for a separate chapter, aptly titled 'Corrections', placed at the back of the book after he has wrung out his topics in full. The separation renders factuality nearly irrelevant. He has built a form of truth through processing.
In 'On Reset', Blanchfield quotes Gertrude Stein: 'repetition is never exact repetition, because the human registering it is different the second time.' Blanchfield describes the whole project in his preface as 'a concession to imprecision, a failure'.
What does this change for queer writers now?
The answer lies in the current publishing climate. Memoirs, along with general nonfiction, are not selling well. Media outlets and publishing houses are folding, reading has become aesthetic, attention spans have condensed to one-minute clips, and freelance rates have barely changed since 2000. The author argues part of the collapse stems from publishing's resistance to move away from marketing tactics that previously served memoir well.
Proxies does not claim even to be a memoir. It chooses a different language for itself. The author, whose own genre-blurry debut now enters the world, writes that the book gives her great comfort in a time when believability is threatened daily. Queer stories, she argues, have always been respite from formulaic failures, and queer writers may continue to hold Proxies as a secret handshake in what is possible within understanding ourselves.
Blanchfield closes his makeshift autobiography with a scene from 2010: "Our first date was on Election Day, 2010. ...we kissed in the beams, which made the little globes on the ghostery bush galactic. We mark our anniversary out from there, and we tell everyone every year we re-elect each other. Campaign comes from the Latin campus. Open country. And country from contra. All the area out in front of you, facing you. No term limits. The queer heart."
As memoir contracts and queer archives come under pressure, writing with an eye toward error stands as both a critical mode of rebellion and a step closer to a truer version of the form.
Original: bookshop.org
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,486 articles



