On viewFilm & Screen

Review: David O. Russell's 'Madden' Fumbles as a Purposeless Football Biopic

Amazon MGM releases David O. Russell's 'Madden' on November 18, with Nicolas Cage under 55 pounds of prosthetics and gained weight — and the studio barely naming its director.

‘Madden’ Review: David O. Russell Fumbles Again with an Unfunny and Purposeless Football Biopic
‘Madden’ Review: David O. Russell Fumbles Again with an Unfunny and Purposeless Football Biopicjarmoluk / pixabay

Programme

  1. Amazon MGM releases 'Madden' in select theaters and on Prime Video on Wednesday, November 18.
  2. Nicolas Cage wore 30 pounds of prosthetics on top of 25 pounds gained for the role of John Madden.
  3. The film is David O. Russell's eleventh feature and covers the Raiders' 1976 AFC Championship win over the Steelers.
  4. Russell's 2010s films earned Oscar wins for Christian Bale and Jennifer Lawrence, plus nominations for Amy Adams, Bradley Cooper and Robert De Niro.

Amazon MGM Studios releases "Madden" in select theaters and on Prime Video on Wednesday, November 18 — and its own marketing team seems eager to keep director David O. Russell's name off the poster.

The studio emphasizes Nicolas Cage's performance as the NFL coach and broadcaster instead. The poster shows Cage and Christian Bale, playing Oakland Raiders owner-coach Al Davis, flashing Super Bowl rings. No Russell credit. Even the publicist at a sparsely attended press screening introduced the film as, "Please enjoy Nicolas Cage's 'Madden'!"

It's a defensible strategy, if an odd one. Russell's 2010s run delivered Oscar wins for Bale and Jennifer Lawrence, plus nominations for Amy Adams, Bradley Cooper and Robert De Niro. Actors kept working with him despite repeated on-set mistreatment incidents and a sexual assault allegation, partly because his lavish studio productions let them "make choices" and reap acclaim for it.

What happens in the film?

"Madden" is Russell's eleventh feature. John Madden leads the Raiders past the Pittsburgh Steelers in the 1976 AFC Championship, then wins the Super Bowl. A bleeding ulcer diagnosis pushes him into retirement. He becomes a stranger in his own home, pivots to broadcasting, and eventually licenses his likeness to EA Sports for the "Madden" video game franchise, one of the most profitable on the market. He then lives happily ever after.

Yes, that's the whole plot. As the review notes: "If that sounds like a film with little-to-no conflict, you would be correct." Madden's life simply lacks drama or intrigue. The reviewer suggests he belongs in a Saturday-morning cartoon, solving mysteries with the power of his football mind.

Russell, known for imposing zany plots on real subjects, here dutifully relates events. The result is so milquetoast it makes "Amsterdam" — which "at least had the decency to have a narrative" — look good by comparison.

How do Cage and Bale fare?

Cage wore 30 pounds of prosthetics on top of the 25 pounds he gained for the role. He resembles Madden, "at least if you ignore Cage's actual face." Bale adopts Davis's Noo-Yawk accent and bold fashion sense.

The performance is affectionately caricatured but suffocating. Cage's slurred, vowel-swallowing voice work "occasionally threatens to tip into outright cruelty" — the real Madden speaks at the film's end, and Cage's exaggerated diction borders on absurd by contrast.

The film flirts with a genuinely interesting thread: Davis as a devil on Madden's shoulder, an old buddy pressuring him for "just one more beer" long after retirement. Russell ultimately "chickens out" from making Davis a malign influence. Instead, the Maddens and the Davises — Carol Davis played by SiSi Miller — become tightknit couple friends whose ups and downs stay manageable.

Kathryn Hahn's Virginia brings more life than the archetypal long-suffering wife, but she and Cage generate little chemistry. John Mulaney appears as Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins, costumed like Steve Jobs; Shane Gillis delivers Shane Gillis-style lines; Marshawn Lynch dresses like a nerd.

Is it a comedy, at least?

Technically. The sidelines, locker room and announcing booth all feature — proven comedy settings — yet the jokes "die on the vine." One semi-sophisticated bit lands: Madden's one-track mind turns even a yearbook "XOXO" into a play design. Russell doesn't develop it.

The reviewer's verdict is blunt: "The Russell who made 'I Heart Huckabees' has long faded away, but it's still a shame that he's been reduced to directing one of the oddest and blandest examples of brand management in recent memory."

For a figure who taught America screen passes from whiteboards, broke through walls in Miller Lite ads and rode a custom bus across the country out of a fear of flying, the film offers only the security of an already-safe legacy.

Source: indiewire.com

madden, david-o-russell, nicolas-cage, christian-bale, sports-biopics

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »