On viewLiterature

Seven Poetry Collections That Take Music Seriously

Musician Reed Turchi names seven poetry collections — Voigt, Finney, Ondaatje, Jones, Jordan, Dobyns, Kaminsky — that capture music through granular detail, not vague sentiment.

Seven Poetry Collections on Music, Musicians, and Listening
Seven Poetry Collections on Music, Musicians, and ListeningIguanat / pixabay

Programme

  1. Musician Reed Turchi names seven poetry collections on music, musicians and listening
  2. His own collection, 'Dancing with Poets', is published by University Press of Colorado
  3. The list spans Voigt's 'Collected Poems' to Kaminsky's 'Deaf Republic'
  4. Ondaatje's 'Coming Through Slaughter' centers on Buddy Bolden, who left no recordings
  5. Kaminsky's endnote: 'The deaf don't believe in silence. Silence is the invention of the hearing.'

By Tom Whitfield

Blues musician Reed Turchi has named seven poetry collections that, in his view, do the hardest thing in writing about music: avoid vagueness. The list, published alongside his own collection "Dancing with Poets" (University Press of Colorado), runs from Ellen Bryant Voigt to Ilya Kaminsky and makes one argument — that granular detail, not sentiment, is what lets poetry capture sound on the page.

Turchi's credentials are practical. He has been, by his own account, a performer, songwriter, A&R rep, producer, label director and studio owner. "Most of what I have done — and loved the most — is making music, and then traveling around performing that music," he writes. His poems draw on that life: studio engineers, dive-bar audiences, instruments, particular songs.

The list, he says, favors poets who do not approach music as "some vague thing," but who operate with the kind of truth that only close attention arrives at. That is the criterion. Here is how each book meets it — and where the claim is thinner than it sounds.

What does each book actually do?

Ellen Bryant Voigt, Collected Poems. The strongest entry. Voigt names the piano's parts — "hammers of walnut," "the pinblock, hard-grained beech," "the knuckles, rosewood" — in her Rubato sequence, then moves outward to the players and generations around the instrument. "She knows nothing, but Bach knows everything," runs "At the Piano." Turchi calls the result masterful; the excerpts back him up.

Nikky Finney, Head Off & Split. The four-poem "Condoleezza Suite" builds a biography of Condoleezza Rice from her pianist's background. Finney turns Rice's unfamiliarity with the black keys into a political image: "When she plays Secretary of State on the world stage, the black keys will always be a stretch." Turchi praises the technical grounding. The method risks reducing a public figure to a single metaphor, and he does not address that.

Michael Ondaatje, Coming Through Slaughter. A hybrid of prose, poetry, historical record and invention, centered on Buddy Bolden — the cornetist credited as jazz's inventor, who left no recordings and died after confinement in an asylum. Ondaatje filled documentary gaps with imagination. Turchi has carried one scene for decades: Bolden's fingers pressing a lover's back "as though he were plunging them into a cornet" while, unknown to her, "he had been improving on Cakewalking Babies." The lesson Turchi draws is cautionary: performer and listener may feel the same notes and understand entirely different things.

Rodney Jones, Elegy for the Southern Drawl. Jones treats Southern speech itself as the instrument. He names songs, chords, trees, rivers — never abstractions. The title poem stacks "Country songs, sorghum, the odor of lard" into a palimpsest of place, while a later section follows a "hippie cowboy" with a pink guitar case into a Music City Day's Inn elevator in Nashville.

A Van Jordan, Rise. The counter-example to Voigt. The speakers are not musicians; music is a soundtrack to their consciousness. In "Public Radio Plays Eddie Harris," radio carries the speaker through the news of Harris's death: "Eddie always said there's no such thing as a wrong note, / Only bad connections to the next." Turchi's point: you do not need expertise in piano construction to write music into a poem. Detail about feeling, he argues, is sufficient — though the poem itself does more work than that formulation admits.

Stephen Dobyns, Cemetery Nights. Not about music as subject, but about sound as physical event. "Loud Music" cranks the volume "whether Bach or rock and roll" until "each bass note is like a hand smacking the gut," wiping out the ego. What remains is "a landscape stripped of people and language — / how clear the air becomes, how sharp the colors."

Ilya Kaminsky, Deaf Republic. The list's endpoint: a town under military occupation that goes deaf in protest. Kaminsky builds the book around the removal of sound. "Silence, like the bullet that's missed us, spins," he writes, and the endnotes deliver the sharpest line in the entire list: "ON SILENCE: The deaf don't believe in silence. Silence is the invention of the hearing."

What does this change for readers?

Little, if you want a neutral canon — this is one musician's working shelf, assembled to teach himself attention. Much, if you write: the sequence from Voigt's walnut hammers to Kaminsky's invented silence sets a standard, and a warning, for anyone who treats music as atmosphere rather than material.

Original: bookshop.org

poetry-collections, music-and-literature, contemporary-poetry, jazz, reed-turchi

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »