On viewFilm & Screen

Soap Villains Can Be Forgiven, But Not All Crimes Wash Out

A Soap Opera Digest column argues GH, Y&R, BTG and DAYS keep writing crimes their villains can't come back from — with Roger Howarth stuck in the same trap twice.

Opinion: From GH to Y&R, Redeeming Dangerous Soap Villains Is Tricky Business
Opinion: From GH to Y&R, Redeeming Dangerous Soap Villains Is Tricky BusinessSunriseforever / pixabay

Programme

  1. Roger Howarth's GH Franco brain-tumor retcon failed; his Y&R rapist character Matt Clark is called 'untenable' despite his Daytime Emmy win
  2. GH freed Heather Webber via a cobalt-poisoning explanation; her victim Britt Westbourne returned from the dead
  3. Beyond the Gates premiered in 2025 with Leslie poisoning Laura's IV
  4. DAYS is teasing Dominic as the secret child of Marlena and Stefano, with a claim to controlling interest in DiMera Enterprises
  5. B&B's Sheila shot her son Finn and Steffy, a crime the critic says sealed her fate

Roger Howarth now finds himself in the same trap twice. A Soap Opera Digest opinion column argues that General Hospital, The Young and the Restless, The Bold and the Beautiful, Beyond the Gates and Days of our Lives all need to think twice before scripting crimes that make true redemption impossible.

The critic's core distinction: there's a big difference between a standard soap baddie and an irredeemable criminal. The common mistake is hiring fantastic actors to play despicable characters. The performer catches on, and the show rewrites the backstory to absolve him or her.

What happened to Franco on General Hospital?

GH tried to whitewash Franco Baldwin's stalking, assault and murder by blaming a brain tumor after recasting the role with Roger Howarth. It failed. The critic notes rape is daytime's most unforgivable crime — viewers watched the original Franco sexually assault Sam as Jason watched. (The column adds a footnote: Luke's 1979 rape of Laura was off-camera and retconned to a "seduction." That wouldn't fly today.)

Murder, conversely, is routinely forgiven because the victim can simply come back to life. That's GH's play with Heather Webber, freed on the pretext that a bum hip gave her cobalt poisoning. Her latest target, Britt Westbourne, returned from the dead, softening the offenses. Heather's settlement from the hip-implant company let her buy Wyndemere. And GH wisely has characters pushing back, as Portia did: "Cobalt poisoning doesn't turn a person into a murderer. She shouldn't be here having normal conversations with people who haven't killed people."

That, the critic writes, is the trick to believable redemption: characters we care about reject the criminal's return, then the perp slowly wins them over.

Why is Y&R's Matt Clark story 'untenable'?

Y&R, the critic says, could have learned from GH's Franco fiasco. Instead, Howarth — fresh off a Daytime Emmy win — plays Matt Clark, a character the column calls untenable because Matt is a rapist. No amnesia, brain tumor or inexplicable forgiveness from Sharon will undo what viewers watched him do to her in the 1990s. Nick speaks for the audience: "I do not care how many times Matt insists he has changed. Walking into your home and finding you alone with the monster who terrorized you for so long nearly sent me over the edge." The critic's verdict: kill Matt in a cathartic denouement, then bring on his twin.

Y&R is having better luck with Mariah, who kidnapped Devon and Abby's young son. Her wife Tessa has forgiven her and she has sought professional help — a path that could keep her viable in the Newman orbit.

Beyond the Gates and DAYS: where's the line?

Beyond the Gates, which premiered in 2025, opened with Leslie running Laura off the road and poisoning her IV. The show has since softened her with regret and a family link to the late Barbara Mitchell. Anita semi-forgave her at a recording session with Y&R's Devon and Lily. The critic's jury is out. Anita has no such patience for Hayley, telling her: "You do not want this fight because I will end you." Hayley stays viable — she failed to kill Bill and gets the show's funniest lines, including calling motherhood a "cult with diapers."

Days of our Lives gets credit for not ignoring EJ's rape of Sami after the recast; it made a story of it, with Johnny estranged from his father. But the critic flags the Dominic twist — if he's Marlena and Stefano's secret child, conceived during her coma — as high on the "ick factor," especially with Dominic claiming controlling interest in DiMera Enterprises and poised to push Johnny and Chanel out of Salem.

B&B's Sheila Carter, nearly 20 years a villain, is the cautionary tale: her crimes could once be waved off, but shooting her own son Finn sealed her fate. Begging Deacon to love her made no sense after that. The critic would rather watch Sheila unleash a swarm of bees. It's only an opinion.

Source: soapoperadigest.com

soap-operas, daytime-television, television-criticism, villains, redemption-arcs

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »