On viewFilm & Screen

Take-Two sets a high bar for any Grand Theft Auto screen adaptation

Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick says any Grand Theft Auto adaptation must clear a high consumer-delight bar. The source weighs $1.6bn in GTA VI presales against a 70-hour main story.

Grand Theft Auto would be a huge TV series – here’s why it will never happen
Grand Theft Auto would be a huge TV series – here’s why it will never happensrkcalifano / pixabay

By Elena Vasquez

What does Take-Two’s caution mean?

About $1.6bn in GTA VI presales and a 70-hour main story underpin the article’s case against turning Grand Theft Auto into a linear television series.

Strauss Zelnick, CEO of the game’s parent company Take-Two Interactive, said on a recent podcast that a film or television adaptation would happen only if his team believed it could clear a demanding test.

His condition was exact: “somehow engage and delight our consumers. It’s a high bar to do that. And, of course, there’s always a risk of failure. So we don’t rule it out, but we’re very, very selective.”

Takeaway: Zelnick left the door open, but placed a deliberately high threshold in front of it.

Why would a scripted series weaken GTA?

The article’s central creative objection is that Grand Theft Auto gives two players no guaranteed identical route through its world. One might mow down civilians and bazooka police helicopters out of the sky; another might spend the same period hiking or exploring waterways.

Because each player’s route through crime, travel and exploration can differ, the article argues that a fixed, linear series would flatten a game “so open-ended, and so moulded to a player’s sensibility.” That openness, in the article’s view, cannot survive reduction to a single scripted narrative without feeling “uncomfortably thin.”

Takeaway: A television version would have to choose one player’s story and risk losing what makes GTA feel player-owned.

What do GTA’s scale and revenue change?

The article appeared on GTA VI’s launch day, and its author jokes about missing the chance to play. The 70-hour main story demands substantial time; the article likens it to every Game of Thrones episode arriving at once.

The financial comparison is starker. The source estimates that Grand Theft Auto V has made almost $11bn since its 2013 launch, roughly the combined worldwide theatrical gross of every Star Wars film ever made. GTA VI registered about $1.6bn in presales alone, according to the article.

The source therefore says Take-Two does not need television revenue. A weak programme would dilute attention around a franchise already commanding immense global spending and playtime.

Takeaway: GTA’s scale gives Take-Two more reason to protect the property than to monetize it quickly on television.

Why has Hamilton resisted a movie?

Lin-Manuel Miranda has ruled out turning Hamilton, his record-breaking musical, into a movie, though he keeps the door open to a better film version. He believes Thomas Kail’s live capture already achieves the best possible version.

“I have trouble visualising anyone topping what (director) Thomas Kail has done with this live capture,” Miranda told USA Today at a screening of the version currently available on Disney+. “If someone can prove to me that they can top it, I’m open to it. But I haven’t seen it yet.”

Takeaway: Miranda’s position is conditional: a future adaptation must demonstrably improve on Kail’s recording.

Why has Maus stayed a book?

In 1992, Art Spiegelman’s Maus became the first graphic novel to win a Pulitzer Prize. The memoir follows his father, an Auschwitz survivor, across life in Poland before and during the Holocaust, and Spiegelman’s visits to him in New York decades later. Its central device presents people as mask-wearing animals.

Studios begged to adapt Maus, but Spiegelman turned them down. “I like movies, but Maus is better served as a book,” he said in 2022. “[It’s a] more intimate form and comics adhere to the brain better.”

Takeaway: Spiegelman’s preference for the graphic novel over film is explicit, not a matter of timing.

Why has Calvin and Hobbes resisted animation?

Bill Watterson’s Calvin and Hobbes became a vast, rich fictional universe despite the premise that a picture book such as The Cat in the Hat could support two feature-length movies. Watterson ruled out animation in a 2013 Mental Floss interview.

“I have zero interest in animating Calvin and Hobbes. If you’ve ever compared a film to a novel it’s based on, you know the novel gets bludgeoned … As a comic strip, Calvin and Hobbes works exactly the way I intended it to. There’s no upside for me in adapting it.”

Takeaway: Watterson rejected animation in 2013 because the strip already works on his terms.

Why has Half-Life avoided film and television?

Half-Life, a pioneering first-person shooter, became a hit upon its 1998 release. Gabe Newell, co-founder of its studio Valve, said the game attracted endless film and television pitches whose stories failed to understand either the game or its fans.

“And their stories were just so bad,” he told PC Gamer in 2010. “I mean, brutally, the worst. Not understanding what made the game a good game, or what made the property an interesting thing for people to be a fan or enthusiast of.”

Takeaway: Newell’s rejection focused on the quality of proposed stories, not a blanket refusal of every possible adaptation.

Does refusing adaptation last forever?

The source notes that Gabriel García Márquez spent years refusing attempts to compress his 1967 masterpiece One Hundred Years of Solitude into an unsatisfying screen adaptation. He died in 2014. Five years later, Netflix announced a series; the source rated it three stars.

The example sets a limit on any creative veto. Death can end one decisionmaker’s control, and a new owner or studio can later test the commercial value of a property long held back from film or television.

For GTA, the near-term test is not whether the franchise can finance a series. Almost $11bn in estimated GTA V revenue and about $1.6bn in GTA VI presales remove that pressure; a linear adaptation must meet Zelnick’s consumer-delight test without weakening attachment to an open-ended game.

Takeaway: Take-Two can wait; any eventual GTA series will have to solve the creative problem before scale solves the commercial one.

Source: theguardian.com

grand-theft-auto, screen-adaptations, video-game-adaptation, take-two-interactive, creative-control

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »