Taylor Swift's CMA Comeoveracked With Debut-Era Easter Eggs
Taylor Swift's first CMA Awards appearance in 13 years paired new single "I Knew It, I Knew You" with 2006's "Our Song," dressing-room dresses and cameos fueling debut re-record theories.

Programme
- Swift's CMA Awards return was her first in 13 years.
- She performed "I Knew It, I Knew You" and "Our Song," her first Hot Country Songs Number One.
- The debut album's 20th anniversary passed on October 24.
- Dressing-room props included dresses from her 2006 CMA and ACM Awards appearances.
- She has said the debut re-record will come "when the time is right."
Taylor Swift returned to the Country Music Association Awards for the first time in 13 years, performing her new single "I Knew It, I Knew You" alongside "Our Song," the third single from her 2006 self-titled debut. The pairing was the biggest clue in a performance that fans are reading as a signal for the long-awaited re-recording of that debut album.
Swift's sleuths have dissected every frame of the broadcast since. Many now suspect "Taylor's Version" of Taylor Swift is coming. Swift fueled it herself on Instagram Stories after the show: "LOOKS LIKE I HAVEN'T YEE'D MY LAST HAW THANK YOU CMA!!!!"
What does the setlist tell us?
"Our Song" carries weight. It was Swift's first Number One on the Hot Country Songs chart, and she performed it at her CMA Awards debut in 2007. It's also a song she has rarely played in recent years — its last regular setlist appearance was on the Speak Now tour, with only a handful of spins in the Eras Tour's "surprise song" slot since.
The dressing room was a museum of Nashville-era Swift
The staging did the heavy lifting. Swift began "I Knew It, I Knew You" in a backstage dressing room. On the couch sat a Jessie the cowgirl doll, a nod to the song's Toy Story 5 connection. Around the room hung dresses from her Nashville days, including:
- Outfits she wore to the CMA Awards and the Academy of Country Music Awards in 2006
- The powder-blue dress from the "Our Song" music video
- A green dress from the "Teardrops On My Guitar" video
A hallway of old collaborators
On her walk to the stage, Swift stacked up cameos that map her country career. She greeted Brad Paisley, with whom she toured in 2007 — he was shown dusting off her old CMA trophies, perhaps penance for the prank that filled her tour bus with live crickets. She shared moments with Little Big Town and Sugarland, two acts she wrote songs for and with, and gave a fist bump to Eric Church, the opener she famously replaced on a 2006 Rascal Flatts tour. On stage, Keith Urban — whom she supported in the late 2000s — joined her.
One more detail: Swift spent the night seated next to Tim McGraw, whose name doubles as the title of her debut single.
What changes for the re-record?
Swift has said she regained the rights to her masters and would release the debut re-recording "when the time is right." The album's 20th anniversary passed on October 24 without an announcement. With this performance, she's built the case in public — the timing now looks less like coincidence than a rollout.
Source: rollingstone.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,674 articles



