'The Fantasticks' Arrives on Broadway With Two Male Lovers
Second Stage's revival of the 1960 musical 'The Fantasticks' opened at Broadway's Helen Hayes Theater with two men as the young lovers, running through Feb. 7.

Programme
- "The Fantasticks" revival opened at the Helen Hayes Theater 66 years after its 1960 premiere; runs through Feb. 7.
- The young lovers are now two men: Lewis (Nathan Levy) and Matt (Maxim Chlumecky).
- Tom Jones retooled his book after Michael Lluberes suggested the same-sex leads for a 2022 Flint Repertory Theater production; Jones died in 2023.
- Sam Davis expanded the original two-instrument score to eight instruments.
- Running time is 2 hours 5 minutes.
A Broadway revival of "The Fantasticks" opened at the Helen Hayes Theater 66 years after the musical's 1960 premiere, with its young lovers rewritten as two men: Lewis (Nathan Levy) and Matt (Maxim Chlumecky). The production runs through Feb. 7.
Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt's show, a perennial favorite on school and amateur circuits, has arrived in a version directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli for Second Stage. Jones himself retooled his book and lyrics after director Michael Lluberes suggested two male romantic leads for a 2022 production at the Flint Repertory Theater. Jones died in 2023.
The gender swap sits within a broader trend on Broadway: a lesbian pairing in "Oklahoma!", a female Bobbie in "Company." Within the show itself, the conspiring fathers of the original have become meddling mothers, and nobody objects. "Two boys?" asks El Gallo (Zane Phillips). "And you're not worried?" Lewis's mother, Bessie (Ruthie Ann Miles), is unbothered: "They love each other. Why should we be worried?"
What makes this revival an outlier?
According to the review, the production stands apart not for its queerness but for its sincerity. It contains no sarcasm, no power belting, no video trickery. Supporting players David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila form what the critic calls connective tissue to Shakespeare and vaudeville.
Gattelli opens with winks to the original staging. A piano and a harp sit onstage, nodding to the original two-instrument score. A wheeled trunk marked Sullivan Street Playhouse references the venue where "The Fantasticks" premiered in 1960, when Greenwich Village could nurture a whimsical chamber musical. Jason Sherwood's stylized scenic design and the mime character the Mute (Ahmad Simmons) remain intact.
Music director and orchestrator Sam Davis expanded the sparse original arrangements to eight instruments while preserving Schmidt's melodic inventiveness. The buoyant "I Can See It" recalls Leonard Bernstein's theater writing — the show even includes a quick "West Side Story" joke — and at times suggests Jerome Moross's 1954 Off Broadway musical "The Golden Apple."
How does the cast fare?
Act I, in the critic's judgment, hits all its marks, balancing tenderness, sweetness and humor. The comic chops of Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, playing Matt's mother, anchor the humor; the reviewer writes that their "Never Say No" deserves watching on repeat. Chlumecky and Levy delineate their characters cleanly — Lewis the fiery dreamer proclaiming "I am special!", Matt the practical one — and their duet "Soon It's Gonna Rain" is particularly beautiful. Even Stephen Sondheim, who once dismissed "The Fantasticks" as "twee," might approve of the lack of gooeyness.
Act II falters. After the swinging "This Plum Is Too Ripe," the production spins its wheels. Jones's book summons disputes and declarations out of thin air — "I'll drink and gamble!", "I'll grow a mustache!", "I'll have an affair!" — and the grandness stops sounding natural. Gattelli, the critic argues, never solves the tonal shift, especially when Lewis and El Gallo grow close.
Phillips also loses grip on El Gallo as the character shifts from Cupid's helper to manipulative schemer. His muscular physique, dressed in a carnival-strongman costume the critic calls designer Linda Cho's single faux pas, proves distracting. Phillips acquits himself in the musical numbers but fulfills neither the dashing nor the dastardly.
The show's core, though, holds. "The Fantasticks" remains about romance and artifice alike, and as El Gallo warns: "What was last night scenic / May seem cynic by today." The reviewer's verdict: just as the lovers had to toughen up, "The Fantasticks" may have needed a little of that new Broadway spirit after all. Running time is 2 hours 5 minutes.
Source: NYT Arts
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,465 articles


