'They want silence': how the film NAZA is shaking Israel
The Guardian-produced documentary NAZA, seen by 1.5 million people worldwide, remains unscreened in Israel amid death-penalty protests and a citizenship-stripping vow from Netanyahu.

Programme
- NAZA has been seen by more than 1.5 million people but has not been screened in Israel.
- The Guardian will stream NAZA for free on its website in early December.
- 24 army intelligence officers are interviewed anonymously in the film, which premiered at Venice with a 25-minute standing ovation.
- Over 200 soldiers have testified to Breaking the Silence about this Gaza war since 7 October.
- Netanyahu vowed to try to strip the film-makers' citizenship; chief of staff Eyal Zamir pledged "every tool at our disposal".
More than 1.5 million people have watched the documentary NAZA — and almost none of them live in Israel. The film, produced by the Guardian and set to stream free on its website in early December, has not been screened in its own country despite offers to distributors and cinemas there.
NAZA, by Israeli film-makers Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, depicts 24 army intelligence officers interviewed anonymously on rooftops across Tel Aviv. They describe the mass killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza over the past three years and the secret signoff system used by Israel's military. The film premiered at the Venice film festival to a 25-minute standing ovation and has collected a roster of prestigious awards.
Its title comes from "nezek agavi", the military acronym for the number of civilians expected to be killed in any attack — human life signed off as collateral damage. The film builds on investigations published by the Israeli-Palestinian magazine +972, the Hebrew outlet Local Call and the Guardian between 2023 and 2025.
Nadav Weiman, executive director of the veteran-led NGO Breaking the Silence, first grasped the film's domestic impact on Yom Kippur. Barely a handful of Israelis had seen it then. Yet as he moved between friends and neighbours in Shapira, his secular, left-leaning Tel Aviv suburb, almost everyone was discussing it. "Yes, almost all had very hardline views about the movie," he said. "But, everyone was talking about it."
Breaking the Silence has spent over 20 years collecting soldiers' testimonies — more than 1,000 to date, with Weiman's among them. Its stated aim: "expose the public to the reality of everyday life in the occupied territories."
Why is NAZA landing differently in Israel?
Weiman points to the messenger. "Most Israelis don't consume international media when it's in English," he said. NAZA is a Hebrew-language film, directed by Israelis, with evidence direct from soldiers. The intelligence units depicted are prestigious and mostly desk-based, not frontline. "These are people who live in Tel Aviv, vote for more progressive parties, work in hi-tech jobs … They killed hundreds of Palestinians from the air, many it seems without blinking twice. That's hitting a particular nerve here."
The political timing sharpened things. National election campaigns ran in recent months. "For the right wing it is very helpful to attack Yuval and Rachel," Weiman said. "It plays into their everyone-is-out-to-get-us narrative."
He argues Israeli media has failed, or actively refused, to cover Gaza. "There continues to be an iron wall between the Gaza Strip and the rest of Israel," he said, noting Tel Aviv and Gaza sit roughly 40 miles apart. "A teenager in Manchester knows better what is happening [in Gaza] than an Israeli who sits watching TV news all day."
How severe is the backlash?
Very. Military chief of staff Eyal Zamir said the army would use "every tool at our disposal" against the film. Protesters gathered outside Szor's parents' home demanding she face the death penalty. A mural in Ashdod depicted the film-makers through the sights of a gun. Benjamin Netanyahu vowed to try to strip their citizenship.
Weiman recognises the playbook. In 2018 Israel passed a law banning Breaking the Silence from schools; its funding has been targeted; legal investigations have targeted veterans who spoke out. "They want silence," he said.
Since 7 October, more than 200 soldiers have given the NGO testimony about this Gaza war. Early testifiers, Weiman said, "were annihilating Gaza, getting commands that were more similar to revenge than security operations: burning houses, using Palestinians as human shields and torture, not fighting against armed militants." After the final hostages were returned, the "steady stream turned into a waterfall". The NAZA furor has raised the stakes: testifiers now demand more assurances and protection before speaking.
Can the film shift Israeli opinion?
Weiman thinks it can, precisely because of its structure. "The film shows that the system is the problem," he said. "Not the irregularities, but the commands and how we fight." A single soldier can be dismissed as a bad apple. "But a cluster of 24 of soldiers speaking, individually, about this proves this is systemic. It's too many to write-off or ignore."
He draws on precedent: Biden-era sanctions on violent West Bank settlers. "The minute Biden enforced sanctions, a light was shed on a problem and dismissing it here was harder." This week the UK announced its own sanctions. Yet Netanyahu's far-right bloc still won the most seats in last month's elections, with no majority achieved and opposition parties hardly led by peaceniks.
"NAZA" has already entered Israel's national lexicon, Weiman said, and "the thirst for conversation here is growing." Once the film streams in December, Israelis can judge for themselves. "The most important thing for me is to speak to Israelis; it's a movie about us, we need to change."
Source: theguardian.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,510 articles



