Women Now Lead Hemingway Scholarship — and the Backlash Has Faded
As "The Sun Also Rises" turns 100, women hold the top posts in Hemingway scholarship — and the old questions about justifying the field have largely vanished.
Programme
- "The Sun Also Rises" marks its centennial in 2026; the 1926 novel still sells just under 40,000 print copies this year per Circana.
- Women lead Hemingway scholarship: Sandra Spanier edits the Hemingway Letters Project; Suzanne del Gizzo edits The Hemingway Review.
- U.S. sales of the novel topped 1 million over 20 years, versus nearly 8 million for "The Great Gatsby."
- Brendan Hemingway, 65, said of the backlash: "We've outlasted the baggage. We've outrun the backlash."
- A centennial event was held last month at the 92nd Street Y Unterberg Poetry Center in Manhattan.
Hilary K. Justice, the Hemingway scholar at Boston's John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum, was once told that studying Hemingway amounted to professional suicide. "'Haven't we killed him yet?' was the comment of one professor in my PhD program," she recalled in a recent interview, some 30 years after her graduate school years. "I used to be able to count on being asked 'How do you, as a woman, justify studying Hemingway?' at every Q&A session at every public speaking event."
That question has largely disappeared. Women now hold many of the leading positions in Hemingway scholarship, and this year marks the centennial of "The Sun Also Rises," the 1926 novel that made Hemingway's name.
Justice oversees the Hemingway collection at the JFK library, where the author's papers are stored. She names the women who now anchor the field: Debra Moddelmog, on the editorial board of The Hemingway Review; Sandra Spanier, general editor of the Hemingway Letters Project; and Suzanne del Gizzo, editor of The Hemingway Review.
What has changed in a hundred years?
Hemingway died more than 60 years ago, and at least a generation of students has come of age knowing little about the man who embodied, for countless predecessors, the ideal — or anti-ideal — of the writing life: the macho adventurer, drinker and womanizer who defined courage as "grace under pressure."
Verna Kale, an associate research professor at Penn State, recently asked a group of students if they had ever read Hemingway. None of them had. Ross K. Tangedal, an associate professor of English at the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point and a member of the Hemingway Letters Project editorial team, said his students usually were "exposed to his work in small doses in high school."
"So when they come to my college classroom they encounter the work before the myth," he added.
Scholars say the outsized legend has receded enough that the books can now stand or fall on their own.
How did the family mark the centennial?
At a centennial event last month at the 92nd Street Y Unterberg Poetry Center in Manhattan, actors Maya Hawke, Will Harrison and Sarah Pidgeon read from "The Sun Also Rises." A panel discussion featured "Bright Lights, Big City" novelist Jay McInerney and a handful of Hemingway descendants.
Grandson Brendan Hemingway, now 65, was a teenager during the rise of second-wave feminism in the 1970s. Female classmates approached him in high school hallways just to tell him how much they despised the author.
"People decided that they'd project on to me whatever they liked or didn't like about Ernest Hemingway and were surprised that wasn't a great experience for me," he said. "And the big thing for me at 100 (years of 'The Sun Also Rises') is for my daughter's generation that's all gone. We've outlasted the baggage. We've outrun the backlash. For my daughter's generation, you read him or you don't."
McInerney, 71, told the audience he first read the novel in college, where it "blew me away."
"I couldn't believe how fresh it was and how it seemed really cool, to me," he said. "When the book was published, it essentially revolutionized English prose. It was a really radical new voice that somehow still spoke directly to me."
Is the book still selling?
"The Sun Also Rises" follows British and American expatriates adrift in Europe, sustaining themselves on sex, alcohol, boxing and bullfights. It was a foundational text for the post-World War I "Lost Generation" and for many aspiring writers after.
The novel still sells, though far below its famous contemporary, F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby." According to Circana, which tracks around 85% of the print market, "The Sun Also Rises" has sold just under 40,000 copies this year, down from a peak of more than 60,000 in each of several years in the 2010s. Over the past 20 years, U.S. sales have topped 1 million copies — "Gatsby" approached 8 million over the same period.
What does the book offer new readers?
Moddelmog acknowledges that many readers familiar with Hemingway's image regard the women in his books as stereotyped and marginalized. But she calls Hemingway a "deceptive" writer whose famously terse prose holds unexpected dimensions. She cites the libertine Lady Brett Ashley as a character whom close reading reveals to be a "complex character rather than the typical femme fatale."
Kale, an associate editor for the Hemingway letters project and editor of a Norton Library edition of "The Sun Also Rises," is a self-identified Gen-Xer who started out in medieval literature. She changed her focus after reading "The Sun Also Rises" on a night train to Spain during a trip to Europe.
"I was just the right age to read it, and I became very interested in the expatriate modernists," she said. "I've never had any misgivings about studying Hemingway whatsoever. I find his writing captivating, and documenting his life through his letters has become my life's work."
With the centennial arrived and the backlash outrun, the question for the next hundred years is no longer whether Hemingway may be studied, but whether new readers will keep finding him on their own.
Source: artsjournal.com
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,638 articles



