36 Years in Prison: Dawn Porter Revisits a Baltimore Injustice
Dawn Porter's 'When a Witness Recants' retraces the 36-year wrongful imprisonment of three Baltimore men, with Ta-Nehisi Coates as guide. NYT Critic's Pick, on HBO Max.

Programme
- Andrew Stewart, Ransom Watkins and Alfred Chestnut spent 36 years wrongfully imprisoned for the 1983 murder of 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett in Baltimore.
- They were exonerated in 2019 through Baltimore's Conviction Integrity Unit.
- Dawn Porter's documentary 'When a Witness Recants' runs 1h 52m and streams on HBO Max; it is an NYT Critic's Pick.
- The film builds on Jennifer Gonnerman's 2021 New Yorker article about witness Ron Bishop, who was 14 in 1983.
- Ta-Nehisi Coates, a Baltimore native who was eight at the time, serves as the film's on-screen guide.
Three Baltimore men spent 36 years in prison for a murder they did not commit, and a new documentary argues the system that convicted them knew it all along. Dawn Porter's "When a Witness Recants," an NYT Critic's Pick now streaming on HBO Max, runs 1 hour 52 minutes and reconstructs one of the longest wrongful-imprisonment cases on record.
The film returns to the story of Andrew Stewart, Ransom Watkins and Alfred Chestnut, convicted as teenagers for the 1983 murder of DeWitt Duckett, a 14-year-old student shot at a Baltimore junior high school. They were exonerated only in 2019, after new information came to light — 36 years after the conviction.
Who guides the story?
The author Ta-Nehisi Coates appears at the outset and intermittently throughout. A son of Baltimore, he was eight when the shooting occurred. He describes the killing as a "break" — a rupture in the community's sense of itself. The case made national news and, by Coates's account, reshaped local residents' sense of security and their trust in institutions.
Porter builds on a 2021 article by Jennifer Gonnerman in The New Yorker, which centered on the witness Ron Bishop, who was 14 at the time of the murder. By braiding news clips, deposition footage and animation by Dawud Anyabwile, Porter assembles what the review calls "a harrowing portrait of police and prosecutorial misconduct."
What does the witness's recantation change?
The documentary's title names its pivot: Bishop recanted, and the film stages an indelible meeting in which he explains, face to face, why he lied. The camera holds on Ransom Watkins's stock-still expression as the man whose testimony helped imprison him gives his account.
Other moments carry quieter force. Stewart sits on a couch with his mother, listening to a recording of the phone call he made to her with the news of his release. Chestnut describes the three habits older inmates advised him to adopt: "Go to school, work out and work on your case."
That last discipline proved decisive. Chestnut's persistence led him to Baltimore's Conviction Integrity Unit, which produced the exoneration.
Is the exoneration the ending?
Porter refuses to treat it as one. The review credits her for not framing the 2019 exoneration as "too-easy closure" — and warns that audiences cannot afford to either. Thirty-six years do not reverse.
What the film offers instead is a documented anatomy of how the conviction happened: a coerced 14-year-old witness, official misconduct and three teenagers who worked their own cases from inside. Whether the institutions responsible face accountability is a question the documentary leaves hanging — and one the review does not answer.
"When a Witness Recants" is unrated. Running time: 1 hour 52 minutes. Streaming on HBO Max.
Source: NYT Arts
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,546 articles



