American Doctor review: US medics risk everything in Gaza
Poh Si Teng's angry, despairing documentary follows American doctors volunteering at Nasser hospital in Gaza — one refused entry, another packing antibiotics and a will.

Programme
- American Doctor, directed by Poh Si Teng, follows three US doctors volunteering at Nasser hospital in southern Gaza in early 2025.
- ER doctor Thaer Ahmad was refused entry to Gaza the night before the group crossed.
- Director Poh Si Teng quit ABC News and used her savings to fund the documentary.
- Dr Mark Perlmutter packed antibiotics in a dozen plastic bags and drew up a will before traveling.
Poh Si Teng's documentary American Doctor follows three American physicians who volunteer at Nasser hospital in southern Gaza in early 2025. One of them never gets in. Thaer Ahmad, an ER doctor of Palestinian heritage from Chicago, was refused entry the night before the group crossed into Gaza.
His colleagues completed the mission without him. Dr Feroze Sidhwa, a trauma surgeon, and Dr Mark Perlmutter, a Jewish-American orthopaedic surgeon, are both Gaza veterans — this was not their first trip.
The film is the latest documentary about medics travelling to Palestine to treat civilian casualties. The Guardian's review calls it "a powerful, angry film, in a state of despair at the scale of suffering and devastation."
Who are the doctors?
The trio's composition carries its own quiet argument: a Palestinian-American ER doctor barred at the border, a trauma surgeon, and a Jewish-American orthopaedic surgeon working side by side in a war zone. Their shared qualification is conscience.
Perlmutter's preparations tell the story of the border itself. Before leaving, he packs antibiotics into a dozen or so small plastic bags scattered through his luggage — a hedge, so that if customs turns him back, some of the life-saving medication might still get through.
He also had a will drawn up before departing. Medics in this war die at a high rate.
How did the film get made?
Director Poh Si Teng quit her job at ABC News and cashed in her savings to get the documentary off the ground. The review notes that the same conscience driving her three subjects — "individuals acting on their conscience" — can be said of the filmmaker herself.
What does the film leave you with?
Despair, mostly, with what the review calls "a sliver of hope" in the form of the doctors themselves. The anger is directed at the scale of suffering and devastation; the hope is narrowly personal, attached to named people doing specific work in one hospital.
The review's central judgment is blunt: this is a powerful film about powerlessness, and the volunteers profiled here are the thin counterweight. For audiences tracking the wave of Gaza medical documentaries, American Doctor arrives as another entry in a growing body of work — and one whose maker bet her own savings on getting it seen.
Source: Guardian Film
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,463 articles

