Amy Poehler's 'Dig' Arrives on Peacock Buried Under Its Own Ambitions
Amy Poehler and Hugh Laurie lead Peacock's 'Dig,' adapting Kate Myers' novel 'Excavations.' All 10 episodes drop November 23, but critics call the comedy-mystery spread thin.

Programme
- "Dig" premieres Monday, November 23 on Peacock, with all 10 episodes released at once.
- The series adapts Kate Myers' 2023 novel "Excavations"; episodes run 32-35 minutes.
- Amy Poehler plays Elise, a 49-year-old archaeologist; Hugh Laurie plays professor Neville Wycombe.
- Casting directors Allison Jones and Emily Buntyn assembled the cast, including Geraldine Viswanathan, Antonia Thomas and Fina Strazza.
- Guest stars include Jason Mantzoukas as a local looter and Max Greenfield as a sketchy art dealer.
Amy Poehler's new Peacock series "Dig" premieres Monday, November 23, with all 10 episodes released at once — and critics say its talent-rich cast can't rescue a show that refuses to commit to being any one thing.
The series adapts Kate Myers' 2023 novel "Excavations," with Poehler leading as Elise, a 49-year-old archaeologist who has spent decades working under Hugh Laurie's beloved British professor Neville Wycombe. Mike Schur, Poehler's collaborator on "Parks and Recreation," is among the creative team behind the project. Each episode runs 32-35 minutes.
The review's central complaint is tonal sprawl. "Dig" tries to be a comedy, a mystery, a romance and a drama simultaneously, and the review argues the blend dilutes whatever originally drew the team to the source material. As the critic puts it, whatever compelled the adaptation "gets spread so thin across the disparate parts of this broad adaptation that there's almost nothing left."
Even the lighting comes in for a jab: everything is "light" — the tone, the jokes, the drama, "even the lighting is light."
What's the show actually about?
The plot pivots on four women at a Greek dig site, neatly divided by decades. Elise, 49, has waited years to run her own site, but Neville keeps rescinding his promises to retire. Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan), Elise's flaky 29-year-old former protégé, returns after vanishing five years earlier — with a questionable back tattoo reading "a traveler on the adventure of life" and no luggage. Clare (Antonia Thomas), a 39-year-old head preservationist from money, is engaged to Dylan's ex-boyfriend Gary (Jon Pointing).
The standout, per the review, is Fina Strazza's Patty Borkman, the 19-year-old intern assigned to Neville. Patty wears silly hats, can't drive, and half-believes she's a demigod after reading one of Neville's Greek mythology books as a kid. Strazza turns what could be a "fizzy vat of quirky energy" into "a charming, fresh, coming-of-age character," and watching Patty come into her own is called "the most rewarding and compelling aspect of 'Dig.'"
Where does it go wrong?
The first season turns on the four women finding a rare statue and hiding it from Neville. The review finds that premise undercuts itself, because Neville's character keeps shifting to whatever each episode needs — "a mentor, an oppressor, a goofball, a stick in the mud, a nice old man, and a villainous monster." Laurie pivots skillfully, but the inconsistency signals a show "hesitant to commit to much of anything."
Subplots fizzle. The Gary-Dylan-Clare love triangle resolves without real conflict. Guest stars Jason Mantzoukas (a local looter) and Max Greenfield (a sketchy art dealer) feel like they were hired for arcs that got cut.
Poehler herself is flagged as a problem: playing a hard-working public servant without Leslie Knope's optimism, Elise's glum demeanor limits her ability to crack jokes or light up a scene.
The review's closing verdict: "'Dig' has all the talent it needs to be whatever show it wants to be." The cast just needs to pick a genre — and, when they do, "dig a whole lot deeper than this."
What does that mean for viewers? A bingeable cast and one genuinely distinctive performance in Strazza, wrapped in a show that may need a second season to figure out what it wants to be.
Source: indiewire.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,676 articles


