Andrew Scott's Ian Charleson Film 'Elsinore' Fumbles a Great Role
Andrew Scott stars as Ian Charleson, who died of AIDS while playing Hamlet in 1990. Simon Stone's 'Elsinore,' premiering at Telluride, opens November 20 — but the review finds prestige overshooting feeling.

Programme
- "Elsinore" premiered at the 2026 Telluride Film Festival; Focus Features releases it November 20
- Andrew Scott, 49, plays Ian Charleson, who died of HIV/AIDS complications in 1990 during a 24-performance run as Hamlet at the National Theatre
- The film co-stars Olivia Colman as Dr. Margaret Johnson, who named her HIV testing clinic after Charleson
- The screenplay is by Stephen Beresford; Simon Stone directs
Andrew Scott gives what many will call the role of a lifetime in "Elsinore," and the film around him cannot keep up. Simon Stone's drama, which premiered at the 2026 Telluride Film Festival and opens in theaters November 20 through Focus Features, stars the 49-year-old Irish actor as Scottish actor Ian Charleson, who died of HIV/AIDS complications in 1990 while playing Hamlet at the National Theatre in London.
Charleson's story remains largely unknown. He was not out, and he resisted pressure from his inner circle to announce his illness during a stage run that lasted 24 performances. Actors of that era feared damaging their reputations. The review argues little has changed in that regard, even as treatment advances have made HIV/AIDS feel, in some places, like a plague of the past.
Who is Andrew Scott playing?
Scott has built a career on roles that slyly play off his status as an out gay man while hiding something off-center beneath the surface. He played Tom Ripley, more sociopathic than Matt Damon's calculating version, in the Netflix series "Ripley." He played the Hot Priest in "Fleabag." He starred in "All of Us Strangers" as a lonely adult orphan opposite Paul Mescal. Last year in New York, he played up to nine roles across genders in Anton Chekhov's "Vanya" onstage.
In "Elsinore," a blond-headed Scott throws himself into Charleson with the urgency of his best work. The review is clear about where blame lies: "the problem isn't his." The film dulls his performance with conventional storytelling and over-complication in post-production. Stone, working from a screenplay by playwright Stephen Beresford, churns every emotional beat into frenzied montage editing that, in the reviewer's words, "won't let the material take a breath. Or the audience sink in."
Who was Ian Charleson?
Charleson played an Olympian athlete in the 1981 Best Picture winner "Chariots of Fire" and an Anglican priest in the following year's Best Picture topper, "Gandhi." Before that, he played an outré bisexual in Derek Jarman's 1978 film "Jubilee." Jarman, his former lover, died of AIDS in 1994. Charleson otherwise kept to the stage, with a handful of film credits including Dario Argento's giallo "Opera," alluded to in "Elsinore." At one point, Scott's Charleson opines about how much more satisfying stage work is for an actor without an editor to chop you to pieces. Stone does not follow his protagonist's lead.
What does the film do wrong?
The review identifies a familiar pattern. "Elsinore" triggers the signifiers of the AIDS awards-bait movie: Tom Hanks in "Philadelphia," Ed Harris in "The Hours," the 2014 Oscar winners from "Dallas Buyers Club." The reviewer asks whether HIV/AIDS is being exploited in the package of a would-be Oscar hit, or whether young queer audiences are being shown how it was. The structure of "Elsinore," the review concludes, tips toward the former.
The supporting cast includes:
- Olivia Colman as Dr. Margaret Johnson, the practitioner who treated Charleson's disease at its most stigmatized and later named her groundbreaking HIV testing clinic after him
- David Dawson as Derek Jarman, described as excellent and tender
- Johnny Flynn as Richard Eyre, who directed the 1990 "Hamlet"
- Joe Locke as a young man ailing alongside Charleson in Johnson's AIDS clinic
The best material concerns Charleson's secret affairs and friendships with out men, including a scene in which Jarman invites him home after drinks and they instead part with a tacit kiss between former lovers. But the review finds no life in the telling. The crucial Hamlet performances, the supposed reason Charleson keeps living, are relegated to a rushed montage near the end.
Mike Eley's pallid gray cinematography mirrors the disease taking hold but offers no aesthetic passion to counterbalance the misery. The review contrasts Robin Campillo's 2017 Cannes-winning "Beats Per Minute," which gave an AIDS story heat and spectacle. Its sharpest line: "Watching someone die of AIDS in a room becomes a bore unless anyone is given a reason to keep on living."
Scott's scenes, especially his repartee with Colman, hold the screen. Yet the review's verdict lands firmly: we are told how much Charleson mattered to people, but never shown it. "Elsinore" joins the ranks of HIV/AIDS movies seeking prestige over deep feeling — and the November 20 theatrical release will test whether Scott's performance can carry it past that judgment.
Source: indiewire.com
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,586 articles



