Angel Studios' 'Hershey' Biopic Strips the Chocolatier's Life of Flavor
Angel Studios releases 'Hershey' on November 25: a fully authorized, largely conflict-free biopic of Milton S. Hershey that one critic calls the cinematic equivalent of carob powder.

Programme
- Angel Studios releases 'Hershey' in theaters on Wednesday, November 25.
- The film stars Finn Wittrock as Milton S. Hershey, with Alexandra Daddario as Kitty Sweeney and Alan Ruck as his father.
- Mark Waters, director of 'Mean Girls' and 'Freaky Friday', directs from a script by Sharon Paul and Timothy Michael Hayes.
- The production company Dandelion Media partnered with Hershey Entities on the fully authorized feature.
- The company that bears Hershey's name has faced criticism for diluting products with compound coatings to save money.
Angel Studios will release "Hershey," a feature-length biopic of chocolatier Milton S. Hershey, in theaters on Wednesday, November 25 — and the film has already drawn one of the year's most hostile reviews. David Ehrlich's critique for IndieWire, from which this report draws, calls the movie "the cinematic equivalent of carob powder" and "a godforsaken affront to good storytelling."
The facts of the production are straightforward. Mark Waters, the director once known for "Mean Girls" and "Freaky Friday," helms the film from a script by Sharon Paul and Timothy Michael Hayes. Finn Wittrock plays Hershey; Alexandra Daddario plays his wife, Kitty Sweeney; Alan Ruck plays his father. Angel Studios did not technically make the movie itself — that credit belongs to Dandelion Media, which partnered with Hershey Entities on a fully authorized feature meant, in the company's words, to "bring [the chocolate brand's] story into culture in a more immersive way."
That last phrase deserves scrutiny. Hershey Entities is, on this account, effectively paying for a feature-length commercial about its founder's purity at a moment when the company has faced criticism for diluting its products with compound coatings to cut costs. What does that change for the viewer? It means a biopic engineered to burnish a brand rather than examine a life.
What does the film leave out?
According to the review, a great deal. The film ignores the Milton Hershey School's history of racial and social discrimination. It skips the labor disputes that unsettled the Hershey chocolate factory in the late 1930s. Its treatment of Kitty Hershey reduces her to a cheerleader who "collapses in undiagnosed pain whenever he leaves the room." The couple's inability to conceive a child is leveraged, the critic writes, into a philanthropic regime that housed and educated "any number of white male orphans."
The film's conflicts resolve with improbable speed. A low moment is redeemed by a massive overseas order. A traveling salesman bursts in with an offer to invest in chocolate. "This chocolate," Wittrock's Milton sniffs, "it could be good if it wasn't so bad." The next disaster is followed, in the very next scene, by the discovery of the Hershey Kiss. The review calls the plotting schematic enough to make "Bohemian Rhapsody" look like Gus Van Sant's "Last Days."
The film's strangest sequence may be its Titanic scene. Milton and Kitty, having learned that a twist of fate kept them off the ill-fated ship, dance for joy on the bow of another vessel — while, as the review notes, upwards of 1,400 people drowned that night. "I'm not sure that qualifies as bringing the brand's 'story into the culture in a more immersive way,'" Ehrlich writes, "but it's definitely what I'm going to be thinking about the next time I bite into a milky and delicious Hershey Bar."
Who is Angel Studios, and why does it matter?
The distributor's background frames the critique. Angel Studios grew out of a filtering service that illegally edited "objectionable content" out of Hollywood films. It built its audience on projects including "The Chosen" and "Sound of Freedom," the latter associated with a ticketing model the review describes as questionable. The critic's argument: the bigger the studio got, the more it removed from its films — not just sex and profanity, but "anything that even vaguely resembled a soul."
"Hershey" is, by Angel Studios' standards, almost secular. Its overt religiosity amounts to one scene in which Hershey pleads with an unspecified higher power. The film instead channels the "prosperity gospel" structure the review attributes to the Erwin brothers' faith-based biopic formula: every obstacle is a speed bump on a blessed march toward reward, scored by Rolfe Kent's saccharine music and lit, per the critic, with a blown-out brightness that reads as a literal interpretation of Angel's promise to "amplify light."
What holds up, and what doesn't
Not everything in the review is dismissal. Richard Kind, as the saintly confectioner Joseph Royer, earns a note of praise — "as close to a live-action Bing Bong as he's ever been." The opening match cut, transforming a chocolate Kiss into a lump of coal, is singled out as the film's first and only stylistic flourish.
The reviewer also concedes the underlying story has substance. A warts-and-all version of Hershey's life — the abandoned child of a drifting father who built a caramel company, survived repeated near-ruin, and remade a Pennsylvania town in his own image — "would still be a model of American success." The failure, in this reading, is one of omission: a film so determined to launder one man's dreams into reality that it assumes "its own kind of dream logic," divorced from cause and effect.
Whether audiences share the critic's verdict is a separate question, and one the review does not address. "Hershey" opens Wednesday, November 25, against a holiday release calendar that has historically been kind to inspirational fare. The brand's marketing spend, as the review notes, remains to be judged — and the box office will render its own verdict on whether flavorless sells.
Source: indiewire.com
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,496 articles


