On viewMusic

Diane Warren’s 18th Oscar Nomination Revives a Music Branch Debate

Anne Thompson says Diane Warren’s campaigns tilt the Best Original Song vote; Marcus Jones credits her persistence with bringing independent films into contention.

Should the Oscars Keep Nominating Diane Warren?
Should the Oscars Keep Nominating Diane Warren?stevepb / pixabay

Programme

  1. Diane Warren is heading for her 18th Best Original Song Oscar nomination after a third consecutive Hollywood Music in Media Awards win.
  2. Warren’s 17 previous Best Original Song nominations produced no competitive win; she received an honorary Oscar in 2022.
  3. At the Middleburg Film Festival, Warren showed a Jennifer Hudson and Andrea Bocelli duet from Al Pacino’s “Maserati: The Brothers.”
  4. A music publicist said Warren sponsors two Academy applicants each year.
  5. Jones said re-recording mixer Kevin O’Connell made 20 Best Sound Oscar attempts without winning.

Daniel Okafor

IndieWire Editor at Large Anne Thompson and IndieWire Awards Editor Marcus Jones assess Diane Warren’s prospective 18th Best Original Song Oscar nomination following a third straight Hollywood Music in Media Awards win.

The dispute is unusually clear. The answer is not.

Both writers note that Warren has 17 previous Best Original Song nominations without a competitive win. The Academy gave her an honorary Oscar (a noncompetitive award) in 2022. Thompson sees continued recognition as an avoidable distortion. Jones credits Warren’s persistence with widening the category’s reach.

Does Oscar politics explain Warren’s record?

Thompson says outsiders confront an annual mystery: Warren reaches the Oscars with films many voters have not seen. Most other nominees come from popular films that Music Branch voters know. Her verdict is blunt: “It’s politics, stupid.” One member told her: “She’s ruthless.”

Jones rejects the premise that every nominee comes from a popular film. He points to “Viva Verdi!” from the previous year and asks which other writer Thompson considers more deserving. He also says bias is a factor in the category.

At the Middleburg Film Festival this fall, Warren stopped people she knew in the hallways to show them her latest song on her mobile phone. It was a soaring duet by Jennifer Hudson and tenor Andrea Bocelli for Al Pacino’s upcoming “Maserati: The Brothers,” which no one has seen. Thompson says the display was direct campaigning.

She also had the well-reviewed documentary “Relentless” made about her. Its tagline is “Hitmaker. Legend. Pain in the ass.” The film refers to her bracelet, inscribed “relentless as fuck.” Thompson calls Warren a self-promotional marketing whiz, then says she is fun to hang out with.

Does campaigning help smaller films?

Jones grants that the Middleburg display was forward. His defense of campaigning is broader. As the number of films nominated each year seems to shrink and campaigns grow more expensive, Warren’s one-woman awards run has turned truly independent films, often without major studio backing, into Oscar nominees. He calls that inspiring: “Campaigning works!”

Thompson says Warren’s friendships matter inside the Academy’s Music Branch (its music-voting body). Warren has worked for over four decades and is friends with most members in Los Angeles. She invites them to her home every winter for a lavish holiday party.

Jones says such indirect campaigning is not uncommon. He notes that the president of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences attended the year’s biggest celebrity wedding, where the bride was another current Best Original Song contender.

What wins a Music Branch vote?

Thompson calls this direct campaigning. She says voters identify with Warren because many are later in their careers and entered the Academy for music they wrote decades ago. They like her melodic tunes.

Warren gets a few songs into movies each year and submits them. Thompson says winning a competitive Oscar is Warren’s goal in life. Her peers admire her pluck, tenacity and drive.

Jones says remove all 17 nominated songs and Warren remains among the most accomplished songwriters of all time. He cites Toni Braxton’s “Un-Break My Heart” and Cher’s “If I Could Turn Back Time.”

He calls both definitive for their artists. A chart-topping run often lasts a decade at best. Warren found a different lane and sustained community recognition for more than four decades.

Thompson’s answer is blunt: old work should not decide whether the current song serves the current movie. She also says most branch members look at video clips rather than the movies themselves, and may favor a major pop star for the Oscar telecast.

Jones calls that a misconception. If telecast appeal controlled the vote, Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran and Miley Cyrus would have nominations after several attempts. He concedes that bias matters.

He says members assess how a song functions within the film, the category’s stated purpose. Warren, he says, is more mindful than many, even when producing music videos for contenders. Her songs never feel tacked onto a project.

What does Warren’s influence mean for other writers?

Thompson says many voters owe Warren their place in the institution. “She got me into the Academy,” one voter told her. A music publicist said Warren sponsors two Academy applicants a year. Jones says that point is difficult to dispute.

He also notes that she keeps all her publishing rights (her control over ownership and revenue from the songs), an unusually lucrative achievement for a songwriter. This can complicate work with bigger studios, whose record labels are sister companies. Songwriters are often asked to give artists a cut of publishing, he says, projecting the idea that the artists write all their own songs.

What should the branch do with another nomination?

Thompson says Warren’s success has consumed slots that could have gone to other writers. She calls her selfish and greedy, and says she does not need a second Oscar. Jones replies that a successful songwriter has every reason to keep trying to win.

He notes that composer Randy Newman and cinematographer Roger Deakins each received more than a dozen nominations before their first Oscars, without similar demands to withdraw.

The Best Sound category also includes contenders with no win; re-recording mixer Kevin O’Connell (the specialist who assembles a film’s final sound mix) reached 20 tries without press telling him to step aside.

Warren, Jones says, takes film songwriting seriously and sets a bar few can clear. Her 18th nomination will test whether the Music Branch treats persistence as a standard for songwriting or as evidence that its rules need resetting.

Source: indiewire.com

diane-warren, academy-awards, best-original-song, film-music, songwriting

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »