On viewArts & Culture

Eleven EU States Demand New Copyright Law to Shield Creators from AI

Germany and ten EU member states are pressing the European Commission for new copyright legislation to protect creators whose work trains AI systems, ahead of Thursday's Culture Ministers' meeting.

Ten European Countries Urge Stronger Copyright Rules To Protect Creators In An AI Age
Ten European Countries Urge Stronger Copyright Rules To Protect Creators In An AI AgeRalphs_Fotos / pixabay

Programme

  1. Eleven EU member states, led by Germany, have urged the Commission to propose new AI copyright legislation.
  2. The note was submitted for the Culture Ministers' meeting on Thursday and Friday.
  3. The coalition grew from eight countries in May to eleven now.
  4. The Commission's legislative package on copyright is due in the second quarter of 2027.
  5. The existing EU Copyright Directive allows creators to opt out of AI training use.

Eleven European governments have formally urged the European Commission to propose new copyright legislation protecting creators from AI data scraping. Germany, Spain, Poland, Austria, Cyprus, Croatia, Denmark, Estonia, Portugal, Slovakia and Slovenia submitted the call for the agenda of the EU Culture Ministers' meeting on Thursday and Friday.

"We call on the European Commission to present a corresponding legislative proposal as soon as possible," the note from the 11 countries reads.

The coalition has grown by three since May, when eight countries issued a similar appeal. The initiative is the latest push by the supporting culture ministries for a legislative tool to shield copyright holders from the data scraping practices of AI developers.

Why are ministers acting now?

Advanced AI systems such as large language models are trained on trillions of data points scraped from the open internet and other sources, often with little regard for whether the material carries copyright protection.

The document submitted by the 11 states frames the stakes in unusually direct terms. "Since AI has moved from pure research into broad practical application, it has led to profound upheavals in human creative processes and the perception and experience of art and culture," it states. "Its extent is becoming increasingly clear, and the need for action more urgent."

The divide is not only between industries. National governments are split internally, with economy ministries tending to side with start-ups while culture ministries back creators.

What does each side want?

The positions are irreconcilable on the surface:

  • The tech sector argues that restricting access to copyrighted material would leave Europe further behind the US and China in the AI race.
  • The creative and cultural industries describe current practices as mass theft that undermines their livelihoods.

The 11 countries insist the two goals can coexist. "The aim is to protect human creative work while enabling AI innovation in Europe," the document states. "European innovation and AI development require fair competition and a level playing field with non-European providers, irrespective of where the AI was developed and, in particular, where it was trained."

The demand for a level playing field targets a structural asymmetry: European developers face copyright constraints that competitors training models elsewhere may not.

What tools already exist?

The EU's existing Copyright Directive already allows creators to opt out of having their work used to develop AI. In the note, the 11 countries call for swift action to make that opt-out easier to enforce — a signal that the current mechanism is seen as too weak in practice.

Earlier this month, the Commission closed a public consultation on possible measures to strengthen copyright protection, including the use of protected content in AI.

When could legislation arrive?

According to its work programme, the Commission is due to present a legislative package covering digital transformation, simplification and copyright in the second quarter of 2027. That timeline leaves roughly two years before any proposal materialises, and longer before enforcement begins.

For a coalition that has expanded from eight members in May to eleven today, the pressure campaign is designed to accelerate that schedule — and to ensure that when the package does arrive, it contains binding protections rather than voluntary ones.

Source: artsjournal.com

ai-and-copyright, eu-policy, european-union, creative-industries, copyright-law

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »