Erin Capello Channels Judy Garland at St. Paul's History Theatre
Erin Capello stars as Judy Garland in Beyond the Rainbow at St. Paul's History Theatre, November 21–December 20, opening with Garland's 1961 Carnegie Hall triumph.

Programme
- Beyond the Rainbow runs November 21 to December 20 at the History Theatre in St. Paul.
- The musical opens with Judy Garland's 1961 Carnegie Hall concert, which won five Grammy Awards.
- Erin Capello and Elena Glass played the same role together at History Theatre in 2001, in The Christmas Schooner.
- Capello's first public song was "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" in a first-grade talent show.
Erin Capello plays Judy Garland in Beyond the Rainbow at the History Theatre in St. Paul from November 21 to December 20. The musical opens with Capello as a 38-year-old Garland facing a packed Carnegie Hall in 1961 — the concert recorded as Judy at Carnegie Hall, which won five Grammy Awards.
"It's a little bit meta in that way," Capello says. "I'm in front of an audience performing a woman [who is] performing in front of an audience, which is extremely special and vulnerable."
The show traces Garland's path from Grand Rapids, Minnesota, to Hollywood stardom. The older Garland, played by Capello, converses with her younger self, played by Elena Glass, moving through memories and time.
A full-circle role
Capello saw the first iteration of Beyond the Rainbow in 2001, with Jody Briskey in the lead. Now, she says, she "can look at these moments and empathize to a degree that I couldn't as a child."
The coincidence runs deeper. In 2001, a 14-year-old Capello and a 12-year-old Glass played the same role in a double production of The Christmas Schooner at the History Theatre — Capello's first show ever. Two decades later they share a stage again as two versions of the same woman.
"Elena is an incredibly intelligent actor," Capello says. "Not a second goes by where she isn't completely grounded in her character and also completely vulnerable. We're kindred spirits in that way."
From "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" to Garland
The first song Capello ever performed publicly was "Somewhere Over the Rainbow," in a first-grade talent show. Her mother bought the sheet music at Schmidt Music and wept behind a camcorder.
"I remember asking, 'Why did you cry?' And she said, 'This is what you're supposed to do,'" Capello recalls.
Theater itself became the goal when she first heard The Phantom of the Opera in a friend's basement. "From that very first overture, I was hooked. I thought, This is what I'm going to do for the rest of my life," she says.
Capello's Twin Cities credits include Theater Latté Da's Next to Normal and Artistry Theater's Waitress at the Bloomington Center for the Arts. She describes her voice as "thick" and "rich and meaty" — one that did not always fit musical theater but sits naturally in Garland's repertoire. "This feels like home, exactly where my voice is supposed to sit," she says.
How does she handle Garland's darkest chapters?
Capello has studied Garland's performances and interviews, deliberately avoiding opinion pieces. "I don't want to be a caricature of Judy. I want to be able to embody her and let her take over," she says.
She frames the role as cathartic. "These moments that I can have as Judy become very cathartic for me as Erin," Capello says. "It becomes a symbiotic relationship where I'm able to feel my own feelings and hers at the same time."
On Garland's legacy, Capello is direct: "She was one of the first victims of the monsters that are Hollywood and tabloid culture, and she was kind of eaten up by that." She adds that Garland's later performances showed "her coming back into herself and standing in her own power."
What should audiences take away?
Capello promises a display of craft. "Every single person who steps on that stage is a masterclass in music and theater," she says.
Her larger hope concerns compassion for performers. "When we see an artist, we feel a bit of entitlement and ownership to them, as if we can say whatever we want about this person who is giving so much of themselves," she says. "We never know what anybody's going through. We can only see the outside."
Audiences can test that proposition in St. Paul through December 20.
Source: mspmag.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,477 articles


