On viewFilm & Screen

HBO's 'When A Witness Recants' Charts 36 Years of Injustice in Baltimore

Dawn Porter's HBO documentary traces how three 16-year-olds were convicted of a 1983 Baltimore murder and spent 36 years in prison before exoneration and a $48 million settlement.

Why Did 3 Men Spend 36 Years in Prison for a Murder They Didn’t Commit?
Why Did 3 Men Spend 36 Years in Prison for a Murder They Didn’t Commit?MarcusFriedrich / pixabay

Programme

  1. Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins and Andrew Stewart were convicted on May 24, 1984 and exonerated in 2019 after 36 years.
  2. The men settled a lawsuit against the Baltimore Police Department for $48 million in 2020.
  3. The HBO film is based on Jennifer Gonnerman's 2021 New Yorker article and features Ta-Nehisi Coates.
  4. The 1983 murder victim was 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett, shot over a Georgetown jacket.
  5. Director Dawn Porter says she cannot bring herself to watch the finished documentary.

Three Baltimore teenagers spent 36 years in prison for a murder they did not commit. Director Dawn Porter has told their story in the HBO documentary "When A Witness Recants" — and she refuses to watch her own film.

"I go through this cycle of getting really angry and sad and angry again," Porter told Rolling Stone. "Now that I know [these men], it's even worse because they are three of the most honorable, kind, fun people. I just can't take it. I get overcome with the injustice of it."

The case began on November 18, 1983, when 14-year-old Harlem Park Junior High School student DeWitt Duckett was shot in a hallway of his West Baltimore school. Two friends who were with him, Ron Bishop and Eddie Capers, told authorities a young man demanded Duckett's navy-blue satin Georgetown jacket, then shot Duckett in the neck. Duckett died of his injuries.

Police moved fast. Eight days after the shooting, they arrested Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins and Andrew Stewart, each 16 years old. On May 24, 1984, all three were convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison. It took eight days to arrest them. It took 36 years to prove their innocence.

"The more light that's shined on this the better," Stewart said on a joint Zoom call with Rolling Stone. "Because we're just three dudes. How many other people [are] in our same situation?"

What does the documentary reveal?

The film, based on Jennifer Gonnerman's 2021 New Yorker article of the same name, uses archival news footage, first-person interviews and animations. Porter and the Pulitzer Prize-nominated journalist Ta-Nehisi Coates, who grew up in Baltimore and appears in the film, persuaded the men to participate after their 2019 exoneration. Coates's wife, Kenyatta Matthews, executive produced.

"It was very important to convince them that we understood their pain, that they could trust us, and that we felt the story on a deep level," Coates said. "Their [arrests] were a systemic failing at a point when our communities were at their most vulnerable. It's despicable."

The film's central findings:

  • Bishop and Capers say Detective Donald Kincaid pressured them to implicate the three boys, interviewing them without a parent present and threatening to blame the shooting on them if they refused to testify. Kincaid declined to participate in the film.
  • Prosecutors claimed Duckett's Georgetown jacket was found in Chestnut's house. Chestnut's mother produced a dated receipt proving she had bought it. Jurors never heard this.
  • Several witnesses told police another teenager had been overheard confessing. They were dismissed.

The men's attorney, Barry Diamond, says in the film that Judge Robert Bell allowed the prosecution to suppress necessary evidence.

"I lived right across the street from the Western District Police Station, so they ain't had to go far to come get me," Chestnut recalled. "The next day was Thanksgiving, so the first thing they asked all three of us was, 'Do you want your mother to bring you a Thanksgiving plate?' That was the worst [memory] for me."

Because they maintained their innocence, the men never qualified for parole. Asked whether they were tempted to implicate one another in exchange for deals, all three answered in unison: "No."

"I told my mother I might die in prison because I'm never going to that parole board and telling them Alfred or Ransom committed a crime I know they didn't commit," Stewart said.

How did freedom come?

Chestnut spent years sending records requests to the police department. Each was denied. A letter to then-State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby reached Lauren Lipscomb of Baltimore's Conviction Integrity Unit, whose review found prosecutors had withheld key information. The men were exonerated in 2019.

"We'd still be in there fighting to get out," Chestnut said. "I just knew that our case was probably sitting on a shelf in boxes."

In 2020, the three sued the Baltimore Police Department, including Kincaid, alleging withheld evidence and witness coercion. They settled for a historic $48 million.

Porter wants viewers to see how easily injustice becomes routine. "When you talk about the power of the state, it's hard to see it, and this was such a clear example of what that incredible power can do," she said. "But it wasn't just him. The prosecutor didn't have to suppress those documents. The judge didn't have to seal those records without looking at them."

The men, still adjusting to life outside, want the film to drive further exonerations. "I hope people [are] mindful and [know] anybody could be in this same situation," Chestnut said. "Life is precious. Freedom is precious. Don't take it for granted."

Source: rollingstone.com

hbo, documentary, baltimore, wrongful-convictions, dawn-porter

Also on view

« Previous article