Heysel 85 review: rage at the failures that killed 39 fans
Teodora Ana Mihai's Heysel 85 reconstructs the bad judgments that let 39 fans die before the 1985 European Cup final — a visceral, contested denunciation.

Programme
- 39 fans died before kickoff at the 1985 European Cup final between Juventus and Liverpool at Heysel stadium, Brussels
- Teodora Ana Mihai directs and co-writes Heysel 85; she is a former collaborator of Cristian Mungiu
- The film depicts the match going ahead after the deaths, on the authorities' bread-and-circuses reasoning
- The film has been criticised for fictionalising the players' unawareness and caricaturing Brussels mayor Hervé Brouhon as the fictional Marc Dumont (Josse De Pauw)
Thirty-nine fans died before kickoff at football's 1985 European Cup final between Juventus and Liverpool, and Teodora Ana Mihai's new film Heysel 85 holds the sport's authorities directly responsible. The Guardian's review describes the result as an immersive, viscerally powerful drama-thriller that turns shame and rage into its central keynotes.
What happened at Heysel — and what does the film argue?
The disaster unfolded in Brussels on 29 May 1985, in a crumbling, poorly maintained Heysel stadium that was badly policed. Crowd disorder in the run-up to the final resulted in the deaths of 39 fans. Mihai and her passionately committed cast, in the Guardian critic's words, "reconstruct the grim sequence of bad judgments" that led to those deaths.
The film's most striking formal choice is sonic. In Mihai's stadium, the roar of the crowd echoing through the claustrophobic tunnels sounds, in the critic's phrasing, "like the wailing of the damned," while the sport's officer class flinch and panic as if suffering a wartime loss. That contrast — spectators as the damned, officials as a panicked command structure — is the film's thesis in miniature.
The most damning fact the film dramatises came after the deaths: the match was allowed to go ahead. The authorities reasoned on a bread-and-circuses basis that the game itself would restore order, and that abandoning it would only trigger greater violence and chaos. Juventus and Liverpool played the final while bodies lay in the stadium's wreckage.
Who made it — and who does it draw on?
Heysel 85 is directed and co-written by Romanian-born, Belgian-based film-maker Teodora Ana Mihai. She is a former collaborator of Cristian Mungiu, the Romanian director known for rigorous, austerity-era realism, though the Guardian review suggests the stronger influence here is Paul Greengrass, the filmmaker whose name has become shorthand for handheld, procedural disaster reconstruction.
What has the film been criticised for?
The film-makers have faced criticism for fictionalising key aspects. The most consequential: the film depicts the players as unaware that fans had died before they took to the field. In reality, the players were largely aware — although, as the review notes, it may well be true that the slippery authorities sought to minimise the truth as much as they could. The dramatisation shifts some blame from officials to ignorance, even as it aims its anger at those same officials.
A second controversy concerns the mayor. The fictionalised mayor of Brussels, named Marc Dumont and played by Josse De Pauw, has been criticised as an unfair drunken caricature of the actual mayor, Hervé Brouhon. The film gives its villain a face; the criticism is that the face belongs, in distorted form, to a real man.
What does this change?
What does this change for how the disaster is remembered? Heysel 85 will not settle the historical record — its fictionalisations guarantee that — but it pushes a decades-old argument back into public view: that the deaths at Heysel were not an accident of hooliganism alone but the product of institutional negligence, from stadium maintenance to policing to the decision to play on. For a tragedy long flattened into a footnote of English football's hooligan era, a rage-filled feature reconstruction keeps the question of official responsibility alive.
Source: Guardian Film
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,497 articles



