On viewFilm & Screen

How James Gray Recast His Own Parents for 'Paper Tiger'

James Gray says scheduling conflicts with Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway forced a recast that turned 'Paper Tiger' from sequel into a 'Hitchcockian' crime story opening wide November 20.

How ‘Paper Tiger’ Evolved When Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway Couldn’t Reprise Their ‘Armageddon Time’ Roles
How ‘Paper Tiger’ Evolved When Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway Couldn’t Reprise Their ‘Armageddon Time’ Rolesdcondrey / pixabay

Programme

  1. "Paper Tiger" expands nationwide on November 20 after opening in New York and Los Angeles.
  2. Gray would have waited 18 months for Hathaway (The Odyssey) and Strong (The Social Reckoning) to finish filming.
  3. "Paper Tiger" is set in 1986 in Queens, again following a Jewish family of four with two sons.
  4. Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller replace Anne Hathaway and Jeremy Strong as characters inspired by Gray's parents.
  5. "Armageddon Time," the 2022 film with Strong and Hathaway, was based on Gray's sixth-grade year in 1980s Queens.

James Gray has confirmed that scheduling conflicts with Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway forced him to recast the roles modeled on his own parents, and that the delay reshaped "Paper Tiger" from an informal sequel into a genre-driven crime story. Gray made the comments on this week's episode of IndieWire's Filmmaker Toolkit Podcast.

The backstory is concrete. Gray's 2022 drama "Armageddon Time" cast Strong and Hathaway as fictional versions of his mother and father, in a story drawn from Gray's own experience as a sixth grader in 1980s Queens. Gray said the likeness was unnervingly exact.

"Jeremy is doing my father to such a degree that it is disturbing. He sounds exactly like him, looks exactly like him; it's bizarre. Annie, too, is uncanny about [playing my mother]," Gray said. "So I had had such a great time with them shooting 'Armageddon Time,' I said, 'Well, why don't we do this again?'"

Why the original pairing fell apart

Gray knew his next film would be set in 1986 and would again follow a Jewish family of four, with two sons, in Queens. In the project's earliest stages, Hathaway and Strong were in line to reprise their roles. Then the calendar intervened. Production would have had to wait roughly 18 months, until Hathaway finished Christopher Nolan's "The Odyssey" and Strong finished "The Social Reckoning."

"You can't wait a year and a half," said Gray. "And then I started thinking, 'Well, maybe this is a blessing in disguise.' That the [film] could start to take on a new style, and so then I started to pursue it in a different way. So in the beginning, in its origin stages, it was [a sequel of sorts], but like any movie, it's like a wild horse that's going to get away from you."

Gray's account is candid about what the film no longer is. Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller play characters inspired by his parents, but not the physical and vocal facsimiles that Hathaway and Strong delivered. That loss, Gray argues, freed the film from straight memoir. "Paper Tiger" leans instead into crime-genre mechanics.

"What I tried to do was to make a film more in — for lack of a better way of really explaining — a bit more Hitchcockian in certain places. Almost — again, 'pulpy' is not quite the right word — a little bit more, how do I put this — more of an engagement directly with a tense idea of narrative, that it would be a driving, tense story," Gray explained.

What changed in the portrayal of Gray's father?

The recast altered more than logistics. In "Paper Tiger," Irwin (Teller) endangers his family when he unwittingly becomes entangled with the Russian mob while pursuing environmental consulting work for businesses along the polluted Gowanus Canal. Gray frames Irwin as guilty of pride and naivety — but, compared with his previous films, this is a positive portrait of a hard-working, earnest father chasing the American dream.

That is a sharp turn from Strong's "Armageddon Time" father: miserable, strict, tortured by generational trauma, unbending with his sons. Gray said he saw something in Teller that made the new portrayal possible.

"Miles has a kind of — I can't believe I'm going to say this, he might even resist this— a softness to him, which would probably offend him, but I think that's a great thing," said Gray. "He doesn't have a softness in his persona. He doesn't have it in physical terms. It's actually a tenderness inside. You have to embrace [that] beauty in him and hope it works for the film."

Note the hedge in that last clause: "hope it works." Gray is a director describing a bet, not a certainty.

How Scarlett Johansson got the part

For replacing Hathaway, Gray was bluntly practical. He wanted three things, and all three were non-negotiable:

  • A bankable star
  • A Jewish actor
  • A real New Yorker

Gray argued that the way the city seeps into a person's bones is not something even the best actors can learn. Those criteria made Johansson his first choice.

"I had met [Scarlett] years before on a project that never wound up happening, and quite liked her. She's a total New Yorker through and through. Then when I found out that Annie [Hathaway] was going off to do Chris [Nolan's] movie ['The Odyssey'] for a thousand years, she was the first choice because you're talking about one of the biggest stars in the world, and she's also a Jewish woman from New York, checks the boxes," Gray said. "When I sent [the script] to her, I sent her a note, 'There's probably no chance in hell you're going to do this, but I love you, can you read this?' And then she texted me back very, very quickly and was like, 'Let's go.'"

Hathaway's mother had been portrayed more openly and lovingly than Strong's father, so the recast demanded less contrast on that side. But Gray said Johansson's approach suits what "Paper Tiger" now needs.

"It's a more operatic idea of character than Annie's was in 'Armageddon Time," said Gray. "It's much more a kind of high emotion. And of course, because the situation is much more tragic, and she embraced it completely."

What does this change for the film?

For audiences, the answer is a different contract. "Armageddon Time" promised documentary-close access to Gray's family; "Paper Tiger" offers a looser, tension-driven story that borrows his parents as inspiration rather than template. Whether the genre shift pays off is now a question for ticket buyers: the film opened last weekend in New York and Los Angeles and expands nationwide on November 20. Gray's full interview is available on the Filmmaker Toolkit podcast on Apple, Spotify, and YouTube.

Source: indiewire.com

james-gray, paper-tiger, scarlett-johansson, miles-teller, armageddon-time

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »