Judge Clears Path for Bic Heirs' Lawsuit Over Stolen Fra Angelico
Justice James G. Clynes rejected Richard Feigen's estate bid to dismiss the Bich heirs' claim to the $5.4M 'Saint Sixtus,' holding too many questions remain about the dealer's 2006 purchase.

Programme
- New York Supreme Court Justice James G. Clynes refused to dismiss the Bich heirs' lawsuit in a decision dated October 26, filed November 16.
- The disputed work is Fra Angelico's 'Saint Sixtus' (ca. 1453–55), bought at Sotheby's in 1972 for £130,000 and sold by Christie's in 2018 for $5.4 million.
- The heirs say chauffeur Roy Morrow stole the painting around 2006 and sold it to dealer Richard Feigen for $3 million; Feigen insured it for $8.5 million.
- Current owners Álvaro Saieh and Ana Guzmán bought the painting in good faith, relying on Christie's research.
- Claims against Feigen's revocable trust were dismissed for lack of evidence but can be refiled.
A New York judge has refused to dismiss a lawsuit brought by the heirs to the Bic pen fortune over a 15th-century Fra Angelico they say was stolen by their family chauffeur and later sold by the late dealer Richard Feigen.
In a decision dated October 26 and filed on November 16, New York Supreme Court Justice James G. Clynes rejected the attempt by Feigen's estate and associated businesses to end the case. Their central argument: the family had waited too long to sue.
They have not. Luke Nikas, a lawyer for the Bich family, told ARTnews: "No family should lose a treasured work of art simply because the people who handled this stolen property were sophisticated dealmakers. The Bich family is determined to recover what belongs to them, and today's decision is an important step toward achieving that result."
The ruling is a step, not a verdict. Clynes has not decided who owns the painting, or even whether it was stolen.
What is the dispute about?
The case centers on Saint Sixtus (ca. 1453–55), a panel by the Italian Renaissance master. Baron Marcel Bich, founder of Bic, bought it at Sotheby's in 1972 for £130,000. The painting passed to his son Bruno, who kept it in his Fifth Avenue apartment in Manhattan. Around 2006, it disappeared.
According to the lawsuit filed in March by Bruno's three sons — Gonzalve, Charles and Guillaume — the family chauffeur, Roy Morrow, stole the painting and sold it to Feigen for $3 million. The family says Morrow had no paperwork proving ownership. Feigen bought it anyway, the heirs claim, and promptly insured it for $8.5 million — nearly three times what he paid.
Feigen, one of New York's best-known Old Master dealers before his death in 2021, later consigned the work to Christie's. In 2018 it sold for $5.4 million to Chilean billionaire Álvaro Saieh and his wife, Ana Guzmán.
The brothers say they did not learn where the painting had ended up until 2023. They demanded its return the following year; Saieh and Guzmán refused. The brothers then sued, seeking the painting's return, damages and money from its sale.
What does the defense say?
Feigen's representatives tell a different story. In March, lawyers for his estate told Reuters that Morrow had signed a bill of sale stating he owned the painting. The Saiehs say they bought the work in good faith, relying on Christie's research.
Why did the statute-of-limitations argument fail?
Feigen's lawyers noted that he bought the painting in 2006 and sold it in 2018, while the brothers did not file until March 2026. Under New York law, however, when someone buys a stolen artwork in good faith, the clock on a claim for its return generally does not start until the rightful owner demands it back and the buyer refuses.
The calculus shifts when someone is accused of knowingly dealing in stolen property — the clock can start earlier. Clynes said there were too many unanswered questions about Feigen's purchase to settle the issue now.
The judge also rejected, for now, an argument that the family had delayed so long that continuing the case would be unfair — the doctrine known as laches. Both arguments can be raised again later.
Feigen's side did win one point. Clynes dismissed claims against Feigen's revocable trust and its trustees, because the family had not shown enough to connect the trust to the proceeds of the painting's sale. The brothers can refile those claims if they find more evidence.
The case now moves toward discovery on what Feigen knew in 2006 — the question on which ownership of a $5.4 million Renaissance panel may ultimately turn.
Source: ARTnews
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,642 articles



