Heirs Challenge $180 Million Van Gogh Ahead of Sotheby's Sale
Heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer claim a $180m Van Gogh was sold under Nazi coercion in 1936. Sotheby's sale is set for Wednesday. Legal teams meet in New York on December 16.

Programme
- Vincent van Gogh's 'Châtaigniers en Fleurs' is valued at $180 million and scheduled for Sotheby's auction on Wednesday.
- Heirs of German publisher Samuel Fischer say the painting was sold under Nazi pressure in 1936.
- Legal teams for Sotheby's and the heirs meet in New York on Monday, December 16.
- In early 2026, the US Congress expanded the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act, easing recovery of coerced sales.
- A Paris court annulled a Sotheby's Pissarro sale in early November.
Sotheby's and heirs of German publisher Samuel Fischer meet in New York on Monday, December 16, to fight over a Van Gogh valued at $180 million — roughly 1 billion reais — just two days before it goes to auction.
The painting, Châtaigniers en Fleurs (Chestnut Trees in Blossom), is scheduled for sale on Wednesday. The Fischer family says the work was sold under duress in 1936, during Nazi persecution of Jews in Germany.
Gunnar Schnabel, a lawyer for one group of heirs, said the painting had been deposited at a gallery in Amsterdam in the early 1930s before the forced sale. The canvas resurfaced this year as part of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, an Argentine family fortune built on sugar.
What does Sotheby's say?
Luke Nikas, counsel for Sotheby's, said the auction house conducted extensive research into the work's ownership history and takes restitution questions seriously. The company maintains dedicated teams that vet works once owned by Jewish families in territories under Nazi control.
The record is not spotless. In early November, a Paris court annulled a Sotheby's sale of a Camille Pissarro painting — a decision that went against the house.
Why the dispute could scare off buyers
Art advisers warn that a public fight over title tends to cool the bidding. Philip Hoffman, a former industry executive, called the situation a "nightmare" for all parties. Any settlement, he said, may not eliminate the risk of fresh claims from other heirs appearing after the sale.
Sam Dubbin, a lawyer specializing in restitution (the legal process of returning looted or coerced art), said prospective buyers would need rigorous investigations into possible claimants before raising a paddle.
Has the law changed?
Yes, and recently. In early 2026, the US Congress expanded the scope of the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act (a 2016 law easing statutes of limitations for Nazi-era claims). The amendment makes it easier for heirs to recover works their ancestors were forced to sell, and it now recognizes sales made under coercion even outside Germany.
That shift matters here. A 1936 transaction in occupied-era Europe once looked like settled history; under the amended law, it looks like an open question.
Who are the sellers?
The Blaquier-Arrieta collection carries its own controversies. The family patriarch, Carlos Pedro Blaquier, was accused in 2012 of unlawful deprivation of liberty for his alleged role in the disappearance of left-wing political activists. He died before standing trial.
So the auction pits a Nazi-era restitution claim against a seller family with its own unresolved history, under a recently strengthened American law, with $180 million on the table. Whatever emerges from Monday's meeting in New York will test whether Sotheby's sale still finds a bidder willing to accept the risk — and whether the Fischer heirs recover a painting their family says it lost to coercion nearly ninety years ago.
Source: brasilemfolhas.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,456 articles



