On viewMusic

Kim Deal’s Live at the Barbican adds orchestra and choir to 18 songs

Kim Deal’s second solo album pairs 18 songs with a 13-piece orchestra and choir at London’s Barbican, turning her solo catalogue into a filmed concert performance.

Live at the Barbican
Live at the Barbican12019 / pixabay

Programme

  1. Deal’s first solo album arrived 38 years after she joined Pixies; her second follows two years later.
  2. Live at the Barbican contains 18 songs, including 10 from Nobody Loves You More.
  3. The concert features a 13-piece orchestra, a choir and Teenage Fanclub’s Raymond McGinley.
  4. The first half recreates Nobody Loves You More, omitting only “Bats in the Afternoon Sky.”
  5. Sarah Wilson’s cello gives “Beautiful Moon” new life in what Kim calls its definitive version.

By Grace Kim

18 songs, a 13-piece orchestra, a choir and a concert film: Kim Deal’s second solo album, Live at the Barbican, captures her concert at London’s upmarket Barbican venue. The project pairs Deal’s regular live band with Teenage Fanclub’s Raymond McGinley.

Deal took 38 years to move from joining Pixies to releasing her first solo album. Her second arrives two years later, after Nobody Loves You More. The release celebrates a career through Pixies, the Breeders and the Amps, work that has made Deal one of indie rock’s most singular voices and songwriters.

I called Nobody Loves You More “a big, soulful night out,” and found the debut a delight. Mariachi trumpets, slightly sloppy disco and doo-wop, a close-harmony R&B vocal style, sit beside fleeting moments of darkness.

I hear those darker passages as recorded in the ragged small hours of a cosmopolitan party. The concert’s scale follows that palette, which the Barbican orchestra can reproduce in full.

The orchestra reproduces the record’s gorgeously warm string and brass arrangements on stage. I hear an ecstatic Barbican audience, yet the largely faithful execution initially feels like a near-verbatim recreation of the studio album before an adoring crowd the listener cannot join.

The size of Deal’s solo catalogue raises the first practical doubt about whether 18 songs can fill a concert without padding. Ten of the 18 come from Nobody Loves You More, and the first half recreates that album closely.

Deal leaves out only “Bats in the Afternoon Sky,” with its gothic ambience. Earlier solo songs and the occasional Breeders cut follow. Leaving out one track makes the otherwise close sequence easier to measure, keeping the concert focused on reworking one album.

What does the orchestra change for listeners?

Subtle polish is my answer. The orchestral support first registers as an atmospheric wash of luxury rather than a decisive rewrite. With time, its effect becomes clear: it sharpens the detail around Deal’s songs without changing their basic character.

Strings glide and swoop beneath the brief guitar solo in “Glide.” An orchestral swoon opens “Crystal Breath.” The string-and-brass arrangement gives the Breeders original “Off You” a blossoming rush.

I single out cellist Sarah Wilson’s thoughtful line in “Beautiful Moon” as the recording’s finest addition. The song was minimal and lo-fi (low-fidelity) on record; here, Wilson’s cello makes it elegant and haunting. I call this “what must be the song’s definitive version.”

The practical difference is small but consequential. A first-time listener may notice only an atmospheric wash of luxury; a returning listener can identify the strings, brass and cello as they reshape familiar songs. That is why I cannot rip the live album off my stereo.

The concert film adds enough beyond the studio record to justify hearing it as a separate release. Wilson’s cello, the strings beneath “Glide” and the brass lift in “Off You” supply that difference. The live release changes the scale, not the repertoire, and that is what makes it distinct on its own terms.

Source: pitchfork.com

kim-deal, live-at-the-barbican, barbican-centre, pixies, the-breeders

Also on view

« Previous article