Robert Christgau, 83, Gets the Documentary He Demanded: A Love Story
Robert Christgau, 83, demanded his marriage appear in 'The Last Critic.' Matty Wishnow's debut won at SXSW and Oak Cliff and premieres in New York.

Programme
- Robert Christgau, 83, started his Consumer Guide at the Village Voice in 1969 and still writes it on Substack.
- 'The Last Critic,' directed by debut feature filmmaker Matty Wishnow, won jury prizes at SXSW and Oak Cliff plus the 2026 Screen Dallas grand prize.
- Christgau and novelist Carola Dibbell have been together since summer 1972, more than 50 years.
- Randy Newman reveals in the film he wrote 'Lost Without You' about the couple's marriage.
- Gene Simmons was a student in Christgau's 1970 rock criticism class at CUNY Staten Island.
Robert Christgau set one condition before agreeing to "The Last Critic." Director Matty Wishnow called; the 83-year-old critic said yes — with strings attached. "Yes, if you include my marriage," Christgau told Rolling Stone, a demand he admits "took him aback." Wishnow came around. Christgau's verdict: "It was the marriage that made the movie."
The film, Wishnow's debut feature, has already collected hardware: the jury prize at South by Southwest and Oak Cliff, plus the 2026 Screen Dallas grand prize. It gets its New York premiere now. Joe Levy, a longtime Rolling Stone contributor and editor, co-produced.
Christgau began his Consumer Guide column at the Village Voice in 1969 and never stopped; it runs on Substack today. He has reviewed music for six decades and claims, plausibly, to have heard more albums than anyone on the planet. Lou Reed devoted part of his live album "Take No Prisoners" to grousing about a B+ for "Street Hassle." Bono joked about his Village Voice reviews from the Grammy stage in 1988. Sonic Youth ("Kill Yr Idols") and Public Enemy ("Bring the Noise") both wrote songs attacking him. On Prince's "Dirty Mind" in 1980, he delivered one of criticism's most quoted lines: "Mick Jagger can fold up his penis and go home."
What makes a critic's documentary a love story?
Carola Dibbell, Christgau's wife of more than 50 years and a novelist, met him at Ratner's Deli in the summer of 1970. They argued about Godard. Both English majors, they later matched on the same celebrity in a party game — Martin Chuzzlewit, Dickens's 1844 creation. They got together in the summer of 1972, after Christgau had dated one of Dibbell's best friends for nearly a year.
They married amid a cultural reckoning. "People were asking, 'Oh, is it OK to be a feminist and get married?'" Dibbell recalled. The answer they built was a marriage of equals — though Dibbell says she "had to figure out how to be heard." The film captures their arguing habit. Dibbell's summary: "If I told him 'I agree with you,' he'd say, 'That's where you're wrong.'"
The couple still lives in the East Village apartment they've held for 50 years, greeted at the door by a painting of the Shirelles.
Who appears, and what does Randy Newman reveal?
The film features artists Christgau reviewed and writers he inspired, from Sonic Youth's Thurston Moore to Pulitzer-winning novelist Colson Whitehead, plus a touching interlude with Greil Marcus, his lifelong friend and fellow founding rock critic. The surprise is Randy Newman, who recalls their friendship and admits he wrote a song about the couple, "Lost Without You," inspired by their closeness. Christgau liked the song before he knew it was about them.
Newman and Christgau met when a BMI editor assigned a profile; they played basketball afterward. Each remembers the other winning. In the Nineties Newman wrote a fan letter admiring Christgau's perseverance with new music and asked for hip-hop recommendations. The answer was Public Enemy.
The interview also ranges wider: Christgau taught rock criticism at CUNY Staten Island in 1970, where Gene Simmons — then Gene Klein — "sat in the back and kept his mouth shut." He credits Rolling Stone and Greil Marcus for his career, says Ellen Willis made him a militant feminist critic, and admits Dibbell had to argue him into writing his memoir "Going Into the City." Europeans now approach him with dog-eared copies of his Consumer Guide books. "I feel like I built something," he said.
Dibbell, who published her novel "The Other Ones" in 2014, resists her husband's framing that the marriage made the work possible. Her favorite scene shows her editing him, relaxed, in agreement. That, plus the worldwide premiere, should keep the Dean argumentative for years.
Source: rollingstone.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,394 articles


