Santa Barbara's La Arcada Plaza goes on market without an asking price
Lynne Small Tahmisian has put the 90,000-square-foot La Arcada Plaza on the market without an asking price. The complex is more than 90 percent leased as buyers face a screening process.

Programme
- La Arcada Plaza spans 90,000 square feet on the 1100 block of State Street.
- Tahmisian put the property on the market without an asking price in its 100th-anniversary year.
- Hugh Petersen bought the property in 1973; Tahmisian took over daily management in 2001.
- Hensel reports more than 90 percent leased, with one retail vacancy and four office vacancies.
- The 1925 earthquake destroyed Our Lady of Guadalupe Church, which first occupied the site.
By Elena Vasquez
La Arcada Plaza, a 90,000-square-foot shopping and office complex on the 1100 block of State Street in downtown Santa Barbara, went on the market this Thursday without an asking price.
Hayes Commercial announced that Lynne Small Tahmisian is retiring and has put the historic property up for sale. The announcement came in La Arcada's 100th-anniversary year.
Who is selling La Arcada Plaza?
Petersen bought the property in 1973 after building independent wealth through investments in the Midwest. He stepped down from day-to-day management in 2001, when his niece Lynne Small Tahmisian took over.
He ran La Arcada as a labor of love rather than by standard commercial real estate rules. He chose tenants for their work, personality and compatibility with the existing mix, not only their ability to pay. Tahmisian carried that approach forward.
Since 1973, that policy has shaped tenant relations and the mix of businesses at the complex. It gave Petersen and Tahmisian direct influence over daily operations, rather than leaving those choices solely to rent levels and demand.
In practical terms, the sale transfers stewardship of a deliberately curated property from a family operator to a future buyer subject to screening.
How occupied is the property, and what will buyers face?
Caitlin Hensel, one of the Hayes Commercial partners representing the sale, said La Arcada is “more than 90 percent leased as it is.” One retail space on the first floor and four offices in the upstairs warren remain vacant.
On Hensel's occupancy measure, less than 10 percent remains unleased. The announcement gives no floor areas for those five spaces, so their combined size cannot be calculated from the reported figures.
No asking price accompanies the sale. Interested buyers “will be screened,” Hensel said, to determine their capacity to carry on La Arcada's tradition and their track record with other properties. The process makes buyer suitability central to the sale.
Among La Arcada's signature tenants are:
- Andersen’s Bakery
- Mizza restaurant
- Hook & Press designer donut shop
- Waterhouse Gallery
The offer therefore combines more than 90 percent occupancy, five vacant spaces and no published price.
What history and design must a buyer preserve?
Our Lady of Guadalupe Church occupied the site initially. The 1925 earthquake destroyed it. Architect Myron Hunt's “Nuevo Hispanified” designs informed the shopping center built on the site.
Its signature features include a red British phone booth, a turtle-inhabited courtyard fountain, and sculptures depicting a whale tail, Benjamin Franklin and window washers. These details form much of the property's recognizable public character.
The complex also contains a basement woodworking shop. It supports maintenance in the manner sought by Petersen and Tahmisian. La Arcada may be the only downtown Santa Barbara shopping complex equipped with such a facility.
The sale therefore places tenant culture, historic design, artwork and physical upkeep in the same frame as occupancy and buyer capacity. The next test is whether Hensel's screening process produces an owner able to preserve those qualities while retaining the existing tenant mix and near-full occupancy.
Source: independent.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,606 articles



