On viewFilm & Screen

Sixth Hunger Games Film Runs 158 Minutes and Delivers Little

Francis Lawrence's 'Sunrise on the Reaping,' the sixth Hunger Games film, runs 2h38m and earns a blunt verdict: bloated and limited, saved only by Jesse Plemons and a closing montage.

‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Review: Another Tribute
‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Review: Another TributeBru-nO / pixabay

Programme

  1. "The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" is the sixth Hunger Games film, set 24 years before the first movie.
  2. The prequel runs 2 hours 38 minutes and is rated PG-13 for strong violence and bloody images.
  3. Francis Lawrence directs; he has helmed every Hunger Games film except the first.
  4. Joseph Zada plays young Haymitch Abernathy, the role originated by Woody Harrelson.
  5. Jesse Plemons plays Plutarch; Ralph Fiennes plays President Snow.

The sixth installment of the "Hunger Games" franchise, "Sunrise on the Reaping," runs 2 hours 38 minutes — and spends nearly all of it as setup for a closing montage. Directed by franchise mainstay Francis Lawrence, the prequel opened in theaters rated PG-13 for strong violence, bloody images, disturbing material, some smoking and teen drinking.

The film centers on a young Haymitch Abernathy, played by Joseph Zada, the character Woody Harrelson originated as a curmudgeonly ally in the first four films. Set 24 years before the first "Hunger Games" movie, the story follows Haymitch as a bright-eyed, compassionate teen thrust into the annual death match that defines this dystopian society — the same arena that will later shape Katniss Everdeen, the heroine played by Jennifer Lawrence.

The review's verdict is blunt: the film manages to be "both bloated and limited." It juggles three burdens at once — the politics of fascism and revolt, Haymitch's transformation from idealist to wearied cynic, and the infrastructure of the games themselves — and develops each thinly.

What actually works?

Very little, according to the critique. Near the film's end, Haymitch is awakened from a drunken stupor by Plutarch, played by Jesse Plemons, a co-conspirator in the shadows. Their confrontation about the long arc of history, the nature of sacrifice and revolution as a vast continuum is called "the only moment with real dramatic teeth and weight" in a movie full of death and tears. All of the film's best moments, the review notes, involve Plemons's "too-scant presence."

Ralph Fiennes, playing the evil President Snow, briefly elevates the film too. But the review says both actors "seem to be trapped in this dystopia too."

Where does it fall short?

Several concrete failures stand out:

  • The action is uninspired. The games' set pieces often read as blurry computer-generated iterations of the flying monkey assault of "Oz."
  • The visual twist is a gimmick. The film trades the drab, gray spectacle of earlier entries for a rainbow cornucopia, meant as a sinister counterpoint to the bloodshed. The brightness cannot obscure what it is meant to.
  • The world feels cloistered. The vision of both the games and the wider dystopia is trapped in a bubble, where the stakes and hysterical emotions have little real dramatic foundation. The film offers a faint reason for this by the end.
  • The revolution is vague. Haymitch tries to compromise the games amid a stirring uprising that is never sketched out properly.

The review identifies the deeper structural problem: the games were never the franchise's interesting component. The drama of the relationships and the politics of insurgency were — and this edition develops both thinly.

What does this change for the franchise?

The comparison the review draws is pointed. Jennifer Lawrence "had the raw pathos to both ground and expand a world in a way many younger stars often can't." Her absence is felt throughout, and nothing in Zada's performance fills it.

The film functions mostly to satisfy the formulaic thrills of young adult fantasy: dystopian pulp, doomed romance, teenage heroism and rebellion. Its coda — a sweeping montage after the confrontation between Plutarch and Haymitch — will likely strike an emotional chord for die-hard fans of the books and films. Whether that chord is enough to sustain a sixth entry, 158 minutes long and light on dramatic foundation, is the question the review leaves fans to answer at the box office.

Source: NYT Arts

sunrise-on-the-reaping, hunger-games, francis-lawrence, joseph-zada, film-review

Also on view

« Previous article