On viewFilm & Screen

Sunrise on the Reaping review: a Hunger Games prequel with no reason to exist

The Guardian pans Sunrise on the Reaping, the new Hunger Games prequel starring Joseph Zada as young Haymitch Abernathy, calling it a film with no reason to exist beyond its fanbase.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping review – surreally awful prequel to the Katniss Everdeen era
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping review – surreally awful prequel to the Katniss Everdeen eraAI-generated

Programme

  1. The Guardian's review calls Sunrise on the Reaping a film with 'no authentic reason to exist' beyond monetising its fanbase
  2. Joseph Zada plays 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy, the role Woody Harrelson played in the earlier films
  3. Ralph Fiennes plays President Snow; Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin and Jesse Plemons co-star
  4. The film is the second prequel after The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes; the Games' actual origin remains undramatised

The Hunger Games franchise has produced another prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping, and our reviewer's verdict is blunt: this is a film with "no actual interest and no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase."

That is the closing judgment of the Guardian's review, and it lands after nearly 400 words of mounting exasperation with Suzanne Collins's adapted universe. The reviewer calls this latest entry "surreally boring" — a striking phrase for a series built on televised death matches.

What is 'the reaping'?

For the uninitiated, the title's faux-mythic abstraction has a simple, grim meaning. The "reaping" is the annual process by which the dystopia's rulers randomly select ordinary, ragged citizens for compulsory participation in a brutal, televised survival contest. The reviewer frames it as "a bread-and-circuses nightmare" designed to keep the populace cowed and pacified.

The Darwinian logic extends into the arena itself. Competitors strategically team up with — and then betray — fellow players in the short term, purely to stay alive longer. It is coalition politics with knives.

The title earns its own jab. "What, 'harvest dawn' not old-timey enough?" the reviewer asks, placing Sunrise on the Reaping alongside its predecessor's "equally tiresome subtitle", The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.

Who is in it?

The film charts the youth of Haymitch Abernathy, the character played as a grown man by Woody Harrelson in the original Katniss Everdeen-era films. Joseph Zada takes the role here as a 16-year-old — a "cheeky kid", in the reviewer's words, who finds himself picked for the Games.

The supporting cast reads like an awards-season wishlist:

  • Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, the chilling potentate the reviewer says resembles George Washington
  • Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle
  • Kieran Culkin as smarmy young TV presenter Caesar Flickerman
  • Jesse Plemons as Games organiser Plutarch Heavensbee, the younger version of the role the late Philip Seymour Hoffman played in earlier films

The plot turns on Haymitch's defiance. He infuriates Snow with a gesture at the opening ceremony, then again with an apparent conspiracy to destroy the Games using explosives.

Where does the film go wrong?

Two failures dominate the critique. The first is tonal. The ruling class — Close and Culkin's characters chief among them — form "a bafflingly bizarre pantomime gallery of grotesques" that sits in "a bewildering contrast" to the Steinbeck-style realism of the rustbelt depression inhabited by ordinary folk. The reviewer finds these elites "unconvincing and unfunny in their unreality".

The second is logical. The Games are supposedly a mass-television spectacle, rendered on retro-style TV screens throughout the franchise. Yet, as the review notes, no one is ever actually shown watching. Haymitch and his proletarian, quasi-hillbilly community don't own televisions. And the middle class supposedly glued to their sets? Nowhere to be seen.

Plemons escapes the worst of it, rated "marginally less caricatured and tiresomely ridiculous" than his co-stars — faint praise in a review this scathing.

A prequel that skips the interesting part

There is an odder structural problem. Sunrise on the Reaping and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes both predate the Katniss era that introduced audiences to the series. But the actual origin of the Games — how this barbaric institution came into being — remains undramatised. The franchise keeps circling its own mythology while avoiding the one story that might justify the exercise.

Instead, the review argues, we get iteration without purpose. "Yet another" entry in a series the reviewer describes as "utterly exhausted" and "unbearably extended", trading on a fanbase that has already proven it will pay.

The verdict, then, is unambiguous. Until Collins and the studio tackle the founding of the Games themselves — the genuine prequel — this franchise appears content to harvest its audience rather than surprise it.

Source: Guardian Film

sunrise-on-the-reaping, the-hunger-games, suzanne-collins, film-review, haymitch-abernathy

Also on view

« Previous articleNext article »