Stephen Malkmus Verdict on Pitchfork's Indie Rock List: "Pretty Good"
Stephen Malkmus called Pitchfork's 100 Best Indie Rock Albums list "pretty good" at the Pavement zine launch, arguing Slanted and Enchanted should top it, as Steve Keene painted zines live.

Programme
- Stephen Malkmus rated Pitchfork's 100 Best Indie Rock Albums list "pretty good" at the zine launch at Rough Trade Below, Rockefeller Center.
- Malkmus said Slanted and Enchanted, not Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain, should top the list, and noted Slint as an omission.
- Steve Keene painted over a batch of zines live at the event, accenting Brian Karlsson's cover photo.
- Keene previously painted the cover of Pavement's Wowee Zowee, Silver Jews' The Arizona Record and the Apples in Stereo's Fun Trick Noisemaker.
Stephen Malkmus has delivered his verdict on Pitchfork's list of the 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time: it was "pretty good." He delivered the half-endorsement at the launch of Pitchfork's Pavement zine, held at Rough Trade Below in Rockefeller Center before a packed house.
Malkmus did find one flaw. He said the list should have placed Pavement's debut, Slanted and Enchanted, at the top instead of Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain. Pitchfork's own account of the evening couldn't resist a jab, adding "but what does he know?"
Who shared the stage — and who painted beside it
Malkmus appeared with his Pavement bandmate Mark Ibold and Grayson Haver Currin, the author of Pitchfork's Pavement cover story. The three spent the evening trading stories and, as Pitchfork put it, interrogating "the past and future of indie rock." The talk ranged over the list itself:
- Malkmus flagged at least one omission he cared about: Slint, the Louisville band whose absence he noted by name.
- He singled out a genuinely off-beat inclusion for praise: Thinking Fellers Union Local 282.
- The crowd got involved too. One audience member asked Malkmus and Ibold a long, winding question about whether Pavement actually sucked. Pitchfork's response: "Really good."
The conversation wasn't the only thing happening in the room. While the men onstage talked, the painter Steve Keene worked over a batch of zines live, in situ, adding his brushwork on top of Brian Karlsson's cover photograph. Keene is no stranger to indie rock visuals — his art appears on the cover of Pavement's Wowee Zowee, as well as Silver Jews' The Arizona Record and the Apples in Stereo's Fun Trick Noisemaker. Pitchfork said the outlet was "so honored" to have him accenting the cover photo in person.
What does this change for the zine — and for the list?
For the zine itself, the event functions as proof of concept. A print object tied to a legacy indie band can still fill a basement venue in Midtown Manhattan and generate a live, one-of-a-kind artifact: copies physically altered by the same painter who shaped Pavement's visual identity in the 1990s. Those Keene-overpainted zines are, by definition, unrepeatable editions.
For Pitchfork's canonical list, the evening adds a footnote with unusual authority. When the frontman of the band your ranking crowns says the ordering is wrong — Slanted and Enchanted over Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain — that objection is now on the record. Whether it nudges a future revision remains to be seen, but the debate the list was built to spark clearly still has fuel.
Source: pitchfork.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,676 articles



