The Fantasticks Opens on Broadway With Two Mothers Plotting Love
The Fantasticks opens at Broadway's Hayes Theater with mothers Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles scheming to unite Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy's young lovers.

Programme
- The Fantasticks is officially open at Broadway's Hayes Theater.
- Tony winner Christopher Gattelli directs and choreographs the reimagined production.
- Maxim Chlumecky plays Matt and Nathan Levy plays Lewis, the musical's central couple.
- Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer plays Mildred Hucklebee; Tony winner Ruthie Ann Miles plays Bessie Mae Bellomy.
The Fantasticks is officially open at Broadway's Hayes Theater, with a reimagined production that swaps the meddling fathers of the original for two scheming mothers. Tony winner Christopher Gattelli directs and choreographs the revival, which held its opening night celebration with the full company walking the carpet.
The casting marks the production's most concrete departure from the show audiences think they know. Maxim Chlumecky plays Matt, and Nathan Levy plays Lewis — together forming the musical's central couple, two young people whose parents engineer their romance. Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, a Tony nominee, plays Matt's mother, Mildred Hucklebee. Tony winner Ruthie Ann Miles plays Lewis' mother, Bessie Mae Bellomy.
So what does this change for the audience? In the classic structure of The Fantasticks, neighboring parents fake a feud so their children will fall for each other, then hire a bandit to stage a rescue that resolves the pretend conflict. Here, the mechanism stays intact, but the household geometry shifts: the scheming parents are two mothers, and the young lovers at the center of the story are two boys. It's a reframing of a well-worn tale of young love and parental interference rather than a wholesale rewrite — the source describes it as a "fresh spin" on the classic love story.
The opening-night gallery from Broadway.com, shot by photographer Sergio Villarini, captures the company in celebration mode:
- Maxim Chlumecky, who plays Matt, celebrated on the opening night carpet — a caption the gallery tags "A match made on Broadway!"
- Nathan Levy, who plays Lewis, "one half of the musical's central couple," smiled for the cameras ("Love is in the air!").
- Ruthie Ann Miles was captioned "Mother knows best!" for her turn as Bessie Mae Bellomy.
- Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer earned the tag "mother of the year" as Mildred Hucklebee.
- Director-choreographer Christopher Gattelli — "He's got every move covered!" — was also on hand for the festivities.
The first Broadway cast portrait also lists David Patrick Kelly, Zane Phillips, Ahmad Simmons and Kevin Del Aguila among the company posing on the opening night carpet, alongside Chlumecky, Levy, Kritzer and Miles.
The creative team carries weight of its own. Gattelli is a Tony winner, as are two of his lead actors: the production stacks established Broadway credentials — Miles' Tony among them — onto a chamber-sized musical long known for its intimacy. The Hayes Theater, one of Broadway's smallest houses, is a natural fit for a show whose original DNA depends on close quarters, whispered plots and a narrator's direct address.
For a title that has lived mostly in the public imagination through its record-setting off-Broadway run and its signature song, "Try to Remember," this staging gives the property its Broadway frame and updates its family portrait. As the photo captions put it, the invitation is simple: "Try to remember the night's festivities" — and, now, the mothers who made the match.
Source: broadway.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,563 articles



