The Other 'Heat': Burt Reynolds' 1986 Noir Was Better Than America Noticed
Released in France 40 years ago and dismissed in America, Burt Reynolds' 1986 'Heat' earns reappraisal as a top entry in 'Burt Noir' and one of William Goldman's finest screenplays.

Programme
- "Heat," starring Burt Reynolds, opened in France 40 years ago; Michael Mann's same-titled film followed nine years later.
- The film reached U.S. theaters in March 1987 after at least four directors, including Dick Richards, credited by DGA arbitration with 40% of the picture.
- Screenwriter William Goldman adapted his own novel with a contractual no-rewrite clause; Robert Altman quit days before shooting.
- The 2015 remake, "Wild Card," directed by Simon West with Goldman again writing, also failed with critics and audiences.
Forty years ago, a crime drama called "Heat" opened in France to positive reviews from Paris critics. It was not Michael Mann's "Heat" — that film, with Robert De Niro and Al Pacino, arrived nine years later and became a classic. This "Heat" starred Burt Reynolds, cycled through multiple directors, and was forgotten within months of its limp into American theaters in March 1987.
A new retrospective argues that the dismissal was a mistake — and that the French, as with Jerry Lewis, "Heaven's Gate" and "Mission to Mars," got American cinema right where American critics got it embarrassingly wrong. In "Heat," Reynolds plays Nick Escalante, an aging Las Vegas mercenary held prisoner by a crippling gambling addiction. The essay's author calls it not only one of Reynolds' most interesting films but one of his most personal, and a top-tier entry in a subgenre the writer dubs "Burt Noir."
What is "Burt Noir"?
The tension between Reynolds' affable onscreen persona — the smiling charmer of "Smokey and the Bandit" and "The Cannonball Run" — and the agitation simmering underneath fueled his best work. He was a premier talk-show guest of the 1970s and early 1980s, yet always seemed to carry a chip on his shoulder: angry at not being taken seriously, or taken too seriously, or at losing roles to his friend and competitor Clint Eastwood. The record complicates the grievance; Reynolds turned down "Terms of Endearment," "Die Hard" and "Pretty Woman" himself.
"Burt Noir," as defined here, comprises films in which Reynolds plays supremely confident men of action tormented by regret — "Hustle" (1975), directed by Robert Aldrich; Reynolds' directorial debut "Gator"; "Sharky's Machine"; and later "Malone," "Rent-A-Cop," "Physical Evidence" and the TV works "B.L. Stryker" and "Hard Time."
"Hustle," the first and possibly best, cast Reynolds as a Los Angeles detective surrounded by moral decay so grim it made James Ellroy look like Fred Rogers. "Sharky's Machine" gave him a cop who falls for the prostitute under his surveillance, alternating violent spurts with long passages of near-total impotence — a combination the essay says reaches its apotheosis in "Heat."
How the film dismantles its star
"Heat" opens with a 12-minute prologue that breaks down Reynolds' heroic image. Escalante tries to pick up a woman in a bar in the ugliest, most aggressive way possible — a jarring turn for the sweet charmer who courted Sally Field, Goldie Hawn, Jill Clayburgh and Julie Andrews on screen. Then the woman's meek boyfriend beats him senseless in the parking lot. We later learn the whole thing was staged: the man hired Nick to fake the fight. But the seed is planted. Reynolds and screenwriter William Goldman want the audience never to see him as a straightforward hero again.
Goldman, adapting his own novel with a no-rewrite clause in his contract, builds a hangout movie kin to "Jackie Brown" — sharp wit, contemplative self-examination, shocking bursts of choreographed violence, wistful romance. The Las Vegas setting mocks Escalante's dream of retiring to Italy; setting it at Christmas mocks him more cruelly. The essay calls it one of Goldman's most beautifully written films, easily forgotten beside "All the President's Men," "Marathon Man" and "Misery." That claim is arguable, but the film's standing as one of his least known is not.
Why did American critics pan it?
They reviewed the production's chaos, not the picture. Robert Altman quit days before shooting when his cinematographer, Pierre Mignot, was denied an H-1 visa — though reports attributed the departure to creative differences with producer Elliott Kastner. Dick Richards came on, got into a fistfight with Reynolds, left, returned, then fell off a camera crane and was hospitalized. Stunt coordinator Stan Barrett — Reynolds' double for more than 20 years — directed on off days, staging the electrifying hotel-room fight, but DGA rules barred him from directing more than five days. Jerry Jameson finished the last eight days of filming.
A DGA arbitration credited Richards with 40% of the film, more than any other director. Richards wanted his name off it, taking credit as "R.M. Richards" and publicly disowning the result. With its own director badmouthing it, "Heat" never stood a chance.
What does this change for the viewer now? The film that exists shows no dysfunction beyond an abrupt finale, and the essay's verdict is firm: Goldman and Reynolds are its true auteurs, and the conception of Escalante as an honorable, self-destructive, possibly doomed hero still works 40 years later. The 2015 remake, "Wild Card," directed by Simon West and written again by Goldman, failed with critics and audiences too — which suggests the material may simply be doomed, and that "Heat" stands as one of Goldman's finest artistic moments.
Source: indiewire.com
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,633 articles


