Twenty-Six Platinum Records: How Gospel Lost Its Charts to Hip Hop
Scholar Charrise Barron's Harvard UP book names 1993–2013 gospel's Platinum Age: 26 platinum records, hip hop crossovers, and the identity crisis now gripping the charts.
Programme
- Twenty-six Black gospel recordings reached platinum sales (one million units) between 1993 and 2013.
- Ye's Donda has spent 256 weeks on Billboard's Top Gospel Albums chart, 163 at #1, as of end-July 2026.
- Mary Mary's "God in Me" hit #5 on Billboard's Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart in 2009.
- Kirk Franklin recorded his first live church music album since 2002 on December 6, 2025.
- GloRilla won the 2025 BET Dr. Bobby Jones Gospel/Inspirational Award.
Between 1993 and 2013, twenty-six Black gospel recordings went platinum — at least one million units each. Charrise Barron calls that stretch the Platinum Age of Gospel, and her new book, The Platinum Age of Gospel: The Years When Crossover Music Changed Everything (Harvard University Press, 2026), argues it set the industry on a collision course with its own identity.
Barron, a scholar of gospel and American religion, frames the book as "an open letter to the gospel industry — a love letter and an official complaint at the same time." It celebrates crossover gospel of the 1990s and 2000s while demanding more critical reflection on how the music industry shapes how people learn Christianity through music.
What came before the crossover?
The Golden Age — roughly 1945 to 1965, or as late as 1980 by some reckonings — focused on music for churchgoers. A handful of gospel artists crossed to mainstream audiences. The Platinum Age changed everything: how Black churches worshipped, and how artists reimagined their music, ministries and personas.
Barron dates her own conversion to a midnight in a two-bedroom apartment in southwest Houston, aged six, when Andraé Crouch came through the kitchen clock radio. "We need to hear from you / We need a word from you." She stood inches from the radio while her family slept. It was, she writes, the beginning of an enduring relationship with the music.
What does "sexy for Jesus" mean?
The book's sharpest claim concerns the body. Years later, as a PhD student and resident tutor at Harvard's Adams House, Barron showed a YouTube clip of Kirk Franklin directing "He Reigns" — his Latin-tinged 2002 remake of "Awesome God" from The Rebirth of Kirk Franklin (Live), recorded on the Hopeville Tour stop in Austin, Texas. Franklin, in an oversized white blouse and leather pants, invited the audience to dance "at a club" and demonstrated moves borrowed from James Brown.
A college senior watching the video ignored the arrangement, the three-part harmonies, the Afro-Caribbean rhythms. Her verdict: "He sure does move his hips a lot."
Barron takes that seriously. Previous generations of gospel performers traded in carnal denial, at least on stage. Platinum Age artists, she writes, "wanted to bring attention to their bodies and to their own ownership and display of sexuality." The phrase sexy for Jesus circulated among artists themselves. Angel Taylor of Trin-i-tee 5:7 used it on the short-lived 2009 show 106 & Gospel; BeBe Winans told The Grio in 2014: "I can't help that I'm sexy for Jesus."
How did gospel chase relevance?
Barron calls the strategy the performance of relevance — not branding, which emphasizes distinction, but similitude with popular culture. The tactics included:
- adopting the target market's music and dance forms
- contemporary fashion and status symbols — extensions, cars, homes
- slang and idioms
- associations with mainstream artists
- conspicuous sexuality
The duo Mary Mary exemplified the shift. Their 2008 single "God in Me" peaked at #5 on Billboard's Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart in 2009, sounding, Barron notes, like Jamie Foxx's "Blame It (On the Alcohol)" and T-Pain's "Buy U A Drank." Its video was set at a fashion show, with Ye (Kanye West), Fonzworth Bentley and CeeLo Green in the audience. The lyrics tally material blessings — checks "with a whole lot of zeros," a nice car — and use slang like "whip" and "crib" rather than scripture.
In 2013, Erica Campbell caught social-media flak for a formfitting white J. Bolin-styled outfit promoting her solo album Help. She doubled down: "God created sex and sexuality. I do not believe that it has to be negative. From a Christian perspective, take ownership of how God made you and you can still be beautiful and strong and sexy, and sexy is not a bad word."
Barron likens Mary Mary to a new generation of blues women, extending musicologist Cheryl Keyes's framing of female rappers as "daughters of the blues." Where Ma Rainey and Bessie Smith contested Black womanhood, the Campbell sisters redefined Black Protestant womanhood without rejecting the secular, the sensual or the heterosexual.
Who left the gate open?
Barron borrows a fable from Reverend Bennett Walker Smith's Grammy-nominated sermon "Watch Them Dogs" — a little dog torments a Doberman until the gate swings open. Her answer: the gospel industry left its own gate open, inviting mainstream R&B, hip hop and white Christian artists in.
The Dobermans have feasted. Ye's Donda entered Billboard's Top Gospel Albums chart at #1 in September 2021 and, by the end of July 2026, had spent 256 weeks on the chart — 163 of them at #1 — despite registering to most gospel fans as not gospel at all. Maverick City Music's contemporary worship album Old Church Basement, released by Elevation Worship, held a top-ten spot. In 2025, Southern rapper GloRilla won the BET Dr. Bobby Jones Gospel/Inspirational Award for "Rain Down on Me," her collaboration with Kierra Sheard, Kirk Franklin, Chandler Moore and the Maverick City Music choir. "This [is] my first BET Award even though I've been here three years [and was] nominated six times," she said, with Franklin and executive Norman Gyamfi standing beside her.
There is a turn, though. Kirk Franklin recorded a live church music album on December 6, 2025 — his first live recording since 2002. Choir and quartet music are reviving. Barron calls it Sankofa, the Akan term for going back to retrieve what was forgotten. The old paths, it seems, are walkable again.
Original: bookshop.org
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,577 articles


