Young, British and Tradwife review: three wives, one ideology, too little interrogation
Poppy Jay interviews three UK tradwives, from Instagram sponsorships to Christian nationalism, in a documentary that provokes more questions than it answers.
Programme
- Poppy Jay's documentary Young, British and Tradwife profiles three UK women in the tradwife movement
- Laura Zachary married Zion six months before filming; Molly is mother of seven and wife of theologian Aaron
- Molly met Aaron at 19 after wanting to be a journalist
- The tradwife movement is fracturing in the US amid high-profile divorces and abuse stories
- Jay previously made Young, British and Anti-Abortion
Poppy Jay's new documentary Young, British and Tradwife interviews three UK women advocating a lifestyle that began as a US social media phenomenon. The film follows her earlier Young, British and Anti-Abortion, and it demands a similar tolerance for elevated blood pressure from its viewers.
Jay, a film-maker and journalist, has chosen her trio with visible care. Each woman represents a different manifestation of the movement, which in the US is bound up with evangelical Christianity and social conservatism — influences weaker here, but present.
Who are the three wives?
Megan sits at the gentler end of what Jay acknowledges is a spectrum. The Bible's call for wives to be subservient to husbands, Megan argues, is best understood as a relationship in which both partners are expected "to lay down your lives for each other" — giving selflessly, maximally and by implication equally. She runs an Instagram account featuring her children and earns money from sponsorship deals, the only way the couple can afford for her to stay home. Before children, she founded a kombucha business with a friend; after them, she "handed the reins" to her husband, Joseph. We never hear from the friend about how the business is doing now.
Laura Zachary, a born-again Christian, married Zion six months ago and posts deliberately provocative content. "A lot of women got upset when I told them I treat my husband like he's Jesus," runs her most infamous video. Women who refuse to cook or clean for a man aren't free, she says — they're lazy. She notes that the more people disagree and engage, "the more you get paid!" Yet Jay doesn't press her on how much of the spiel is a business decision, or what Zion means when he takes "things I don't like about myself" off her shoulders.
Molly is the biggest hitter. Mother of seven and wife of Christian nationalist theologian Aaron, she has lived this way longer than TikTok has existed. Shown footage of a leading tradwife influencer, she says it makes a mockery of her life.
What does the film leave unanswered?
Aaron supplies the film's sharpest quotes: "Christian chivalry in a feminist age will be seen as misogynistic … because it requires on some level limiting the agency of women." And, more pointedly during Jay's stay with the couple: "I'm the king, and she's my queen … she doesn't get to usurp the throne."
The swap — Molly stays in Jay's London flat — produces the film's most interesting exchange. Both agree women cannot, whatever they've been told, have it all, though Jay's attitude to non-marital relationships chills the atmosphere. Molly once wanted to be a journalist and never expected to marry. Jay cannot discern whether meeting Aaron at 19 let her admit a real desire for marriage, or forced her to abandon her ambitions. Mask or face? The film never decides.
The result is a hugely frustrating watch. You want twelve hours of interrogation by a trained psychotherapist, plus interviews with friends and parents willing to burn bridges. That, of course, is not possible in an hour. Jay — fearless with the men, perhaps too careful with the women — showcases the movement's facets and hints at its tangled motives.
The timing matters. In the US, the movement is starting to fall apart, with high-profile members divorcing and stories of abuse and coercion surfacing behind the scenes. That, more than the film's deliberate provocations, is the argument for the deeper dive Jay's hour only gestures toward.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,456 articles



