Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson Bring A History of Paper Off-Broadway
Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson star in A History of Paper, the Fringe First-winning two-hander, opening February 12, 2027 at Stage 42 for a 13-week run.

Programme
- A History of Paper begins performances February 12, 2027 at Stage 42 off-Broadway, running 13 weeks through May 16.
- The musical stars Tony winner Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson.
- It won a Fringe First Award at its Edinburgh Festival Fringe debut at the Traverse Theatre in 2024.
- The show originated as a BBC Radio 4 play by Oliver Emanuel in 2017.
- Andrew Panton directs, with design by Ana Inés Jabares-Pita and lighting by Bruno Poet.
Tickets are on sale now for A History of Paper, the two-character musical starring Tony winner Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson at Stage 42 off-Broadway. Performances begin February 12, 2027. The run is a 13-week limited engagement closing May 16.
The show has a book by Oliver Emanuel, music by Gareth Williams, and lyrics by Emanuel and Williams. Andrew Panton directs.
What is the musical about?
A History of Paper charts a love story through the paper artifacts that mark a relationship and a lifetime — letters, menus, train tickets, shopping lists, postcards. It is a chamber musical for two performers, small in scale by design.
The material itself has a longer paper trail than most. It began as an original BBC Radio 4 play in 2017, written by Emanuel. He and composer Williams then adapted it as a work-in-progress at Dundee Rep Theatre in 2019, staged as part of Rep Stripped, the theater's festival championing new Scottish work.
The production made its Edinburgh Festival Fringe debut at the Traverse Theatre in 2024, where it won a Fringe First Award (the Fringe's honor recognizing outstanding new writing). Cumming and Panton then arranged for it to appear in Cumming's first season as artistic director of the Pitlochry Festival Theatre.
Who is making it in New York?
The creative team includes:
- Design: Ana Inés Jabares-Pita
- Lighting design: Bruno Poet
- Sound design: listed by the production
The pairing is the draw. Cumming, a Scot with a Tony for Cabaret, returns to a smaller New York stage after years of larger venues. Henderson, known to film audiences as Moaning Myrtle in the Harry Potter films and to theater audiences for her stage work, makes a rare New York appearance. Two actors, one love story, thirteen weeks. That arithmetic alone tells you the scale.
The show's route to Stage 42 — radio play, Dundee workshop, Traverse premiere, Pitlochry season — is a textbook case of British new-work development, where a piece earns its stripes in incremental productions before transferring. New York is the last stop on that paper trail, and the first where commercial audiences can judge it.
Whether an intimate Scottish two-hander about postcards and shopping lists can fill a 42nd Street house for a full spring season is now the question. The Fringe First suggests the writing can carry it. February 12 will tell.
Source: broadway.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,510 articles



