Alan Cumming Plays Higgins in a Scottish, Stripped-Down 'My Fair Lady'
Alan Cumming plays Henry Higgins opposite Verity Power's Eliza in a Scottish, 18-strong chamber 'My Fair Lady' at Pitlochry Festival Theatre, staged by Maria Friedman, Nov. 21–Dec. 31.

Programme
- "My Fair Lady" runs at Pitlochry Festival Theatre from Nov. 21 to Dec. 31.
- Alan Cumming closes his first season as Pitlochry's artistic director by playing Henry Higgins.
- Maria Friedman stages the show as an 18-performer chamber piece instead of the usual 30.
- The production is a co-presentation with Sonia Friedman Productions.
- Verity Power, from Glasgow, plays Eliza Doolittle, keeping what she estimates at 20% of Audrey Hepburn's screen performance.
Alan Cumming will play Professor Henry Higgins in "My Fair Lady" at Pitlochry Festival Theatre from Nov. 21 to Dec. 31, closing his first season as the Perthshire venue's artistic director opposite Glaswegian actor Verity Power's Eliza Doolittle.
Four decades ago, when Cumming left drama school, everybody told him there was no point auditioning for Pitlochry because it only hired English actors. Now he runs the place. "Having two Scottish people playing the leads in a show that is about the misapprehensions and the prejudices that people have about accent — I think we very much understand that, being Scottish," Cumming tells Variety.
Maria Friedman, the director behind the Tony-winning Broadway revival of Stephen Sondheim's "Merrily We Roll Along," stages the Lerner and Loewe musical as a co-presentation with Sonia Friedman Productions.
How did the show come about?
Almost by accident, Cumming says. He was approaching artists he admired, Friedman among them, and it was she who pitched the 1956 musical. For a theater of Pitlochry's scale, a familiar title made sense as one of the season's tentpoles (the anchor shows of a program), with riskier work sitting alongside it.
"It's not your granny's 'My Fair Lady,'" Cumming says. "It's going to have an edge to it, and I feel like casting me, casting Verity, it's a bit more spunky than you might expect."
What does Friedman do with Higgins and Eliza?
Her reading starts with the two leads as mirror images. She sees a piece about patriarchy, class, status and the lack of opportunity for women, but above all about authenticity, with Higgins and Eliza as "two sides of a coin." Both react to the world viscerally, and neither has been polished out of themselves.
"I think that Higgins is definitely spectrum-y, without any question, and Eliza is emotionally incontinent, but they're both passionate people about the things that they love," Friedman says. "The further Eliza gets away from her original — she's so full of chutzpah and life force — the more ladylike she becomes, the lonelier she becomes."
Asked how she handles a relationship long sold as a romance but built on power and control, Friedman is blunt. "It's absolutely easy. We just don't go there. Love comes in all shapes and sizes, and so I'm looking absolutely at a friendship. Two people who can rub along with each other, are better off with each other than without each other, still living their own lives."
George Bernard Shaw famously resisted a romantic ending for "Pygmalion," the 1913 play the musical adapts. Friedman acknowledges his influence but steers consciously away from "any point of ever thinking that there's a love affair. It's not going to happen."
Nor is anyone sanding down Higgins. Cumming calls it a period piece about the patriarchy, in which a strong woman comes in and tries to bash it. "I'm not interested in flattening things out to make them uncontentious," he says. "I am interested in finding a way to play people so that you understand them."
Friedman, who last saw "My Fair Lady" when she was 21, sees a Higgins whose short fuse comes from repression — a man who treats Eliza as a scientific experiment until "that kind of microscope looking at this specimen flashes out in front of him into a human being, which is most alarming for him." Cumming, she adds, "can turn on a sixpence: one minute he makes you want to cry, then you're roaring with laughter."
Who is Verity Power's Eliza?
For Power, the shadow of Audrey Hepburn and Julie Andrews was something to study and then mostly set aside. A Hepburn devotee who has watched the 1964 film since she was about 7, she says she kept perhaps 20% of the screen Eliza. "There's a big, fat 80% which just has to come from me, otherwise it's, you know, 100 girls all auditioning as Audrey Hepburn or Julie Andrews," Power says. "Eliza is so close to who I am in terms of how overly emotional she is, and how reactive she is, and how she sort of likes to storyboard her life."
Friedman says the search for an Eliza was a long one. "Verity walked in, and she is authentic," the director says. "Somebody hasn't ironed her out."
The accent question runs through the whole project. Cumming describes enduring "a low-level racism, actually," in London over his accent and the assumptions people made about his education and background. In New York, the same qualities were celebrated. "[As] a baby actor, I was sort of told to squash it or hide it," he says. "Once again, it's kind of what the show is about, your authenticity and all that sort of stuff being your biggest gift."
Power, who mostly works in retail when she isn't acting, describes sizing up customers to decide whether she can talk in her own voice or needs her "shop voice." "I go, 'No, no, I'm from Glasgow,' and they'll be, 'God, your accent's not strong at all,' and I'm like, 'That's because I'm trying to make your life easier!'" she says. "Every Scottish person I know has had those."
What does the production change in scale?
Friedman turns a show that would normally need around 30 performers into a chamber piece with 18, swings included, and a smaller orchestra. "These things are too expensive to put on. So it's really, really hard for these shows to go on and have a life," she says. "I want to make it into a piece that speaks to us today in a beautifully concentrated, chiseled-down version."
That fits Cumming's ambitions for Pitlochry's musicals, which he wants to stand on their own and travel beyond Perthshire. He has "no interest in doing musicals that are just sort of regurgitations of West End things." For that to happen, the shows "need to have idiosyncrasy and passion and panache."
Power says Friedman has treated the show from day one "as a play where we just so happen to also sing sometimes." Cumming describes a director who keeps pushing and questioning, and who is specific early. "Her energy is very, what's the word, effervescent," he says. "So it's an exciting room to be in."
Cumming's own profile has shifted since he took on hosting duties for "The Traitors," a job he accepted on a whim, knowing nothing about competition reality shows. He built a character for it, and the result has brought him commercials and wider visibility. The lesson, he says, is much the same as the play's: value your authenticity and go with your gut. "I went with something that everybody thought I was bonkers to do, and it's turned out into this kind of amazing thing for me," he says.
Alongside Cumming and Power, the cast includes Martin Ball as Colonel Pickering, Alexander Newland as Alfred P. Doolittle, Juliet Cadzow as Mrs. Pearce, Julie Legrand as Mrs. Higgins and Alex James-Hatton as Freddy Eynsford-Hill. Tim Hatley designs, with choreography by Ashley Nottingham, lighting by Neil Austin and musical supervision by Joel Fram.
Asked what will land hardest with audiences now, Power points to the pressure on women to be polite, sound right and look a certain way, citing the lip filler and Botox ads that appear unsolicited on her phone. "It happened then, and it happens now, and it will sadly probably happen forever," she says. "But it is something that we can take hold of and scrunch up in a ball and chuck away and go, 'No, we're fab as we are.'"
If the chamber model works, Friedman's 18-strong template could give regional houses a viable route to producing big musical titles without West End budgets — exactly the traveling life Cumming wants for Pitlochry's work.
Source: Variety Film
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,596 articles



