Christie's Closes N.Y. Auction Week With $145.9M 21st-Century Sale
Christie's 21st-century art sale totaled $145.9M, led by a $32.9M Basquiat that missed its low estimate. Dealers blamed inflated estimates and low energy.

Programme
- Christie's 21st-century art sale in New York totaled $145.9M on 51 of 56 lots sold (91 percent).
- Basquiat's Untitled (Leonardo and His Five Grotesque Heads) led at $32.9M, under its $30–50M estimate.
- Sonnabend collection works totaled $41.9M; the Gund estate's 10 works brought $25.7M.
- The hammer total of $117.7M fell short of the $126–192M estimate after Koons and Ruscha withdrawals.
- Records were set for Jim Nutt ($1.1M), Antonio Santín ($486,400) and Julia Jo ($409,600 with fees).
Christie's brought in $145.9 million at its Thursday evening sale of 21st-century art in New York, closing a marathon fall auction week in a Rockefeller Center salesroom that was visibly tired and partly empty.
The 56-lot sale found buyers for 51 lots, a 91 percent sell-through rate. But the hammer total of $117.7 million fell well short of the $126–192 million estimate, and that figure was already reduced: works by Jeff Koons and Ed Ruscha, expected to sell for as much as $11 million between them, were withdrawn before the sale.
A Jean-Michel Basquiat led the night at $32.9 million — just shy of its low estimate. The seven-foot-square Untitled (Leonardo and His Five Grotesque Heads) (1983) opened at $23 million with auctioneer Yu-Ge Wang, and for a few long moments drew no bids at all. Ana Maria Celis, head of postwar and contemporary art, eventually beat out Alex Rotter, Christie's global president and chairman of 20th- and 21st-century art. It hammered at $28 million against a $30–50 million estimate.
The seller still profited. The painting had been off the market for two decades; every one of Basquiat's 83 paintings to sell above $10 million has done so in that span. It fetched just over $400,000 at Sotheby's London in 2000 and $1.3 million five years later.
What dragged the sale down?
Two named collections anchored the evening, with mixed results:
- Sonnabend/Gund anchor: 20 works from Antonio Homem, longtime director of Sonnabend Gallery, sold to benefit his foundation for $41.9 million with fees — below the adjusted pre-sale range of $35.25–53.15 million. Ten of the 20 lots hammered under estimate; the first 19 lots of the night all failed to beat their estimates.
- Gund estate: 10 works from the late New York philanthropist Agnes Gund totaled $25.7 million, squeaking past the $24.65 million high estimate.
Andy Warhol's Campbell's Soup Can (Turkey Noodle) (1962) sold for $9 million with fees on a $6–8 million estimate. Roy Lichtenstein's six-foot Large Spool (1963), off the market since the Sonnabends bought it from Leo Castelli Gallery in 1967 and on sale amid the Whitney Museum's Lichtenstein retrospective, hammered at $7 million — $8.6 million with fees, well below its $10–15 million estimate. Koons's Hulk (Friends) (2004–12) went for $4.15 million with fees, under its $3.5–5.5 million estimate. Works by John Currin, William Eggleston, Wade Guyton, Gerhard Richter and Yayoi Kusama failed entirely; a 1990 Richter Abstraktes Bild from Marian Goodman's estate drew no bids, while a 1991 example made $9.4 million.
Jeanne Greenberg Rohatyn's verdict was blunt. "The estimates were too high for this market," she told ARTnews. "We need to readjust, and the houses need to be at the forefront of managing expectations."
Marianne Boesky agreed. "And the energy was low," she said. "The lots that were estimated too high were punished, and those estimated low were rewarded."
Where was the energy?
At the cheap end. The final lot, Julia Jo's gestural abstraction, carried a $30,000–$50,000 estimate and sold to benefit the Coalition for the Homeless. After the night's most spirited bidding, it hammered at $320,000 — $403,200 with fees, an artist record joined by new highs for Jim Nutt ($1.1 million) and Antonio Santín ($486,400).
What does this change for the market? The week's headline totals — Sotheby's $777.8 million on Wednesday, led by a record $190.4 million Van Gogh, and Christie's own $626.6 million Tuesday sale — still landed. But Thursday's empty seats and punished estimates suggest the mid-market, not the trophy tier, is where consignors and houses will have to recalibrate.
Source: ARTnews
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in arts in the broadest sense at Arts & Voices.
1,633 articles



